לַֽמְאַחֲרִ֥ים עַל־הַיָּ֑יִן לַ֝בָּאִ֗ים לַחְקֹ֥ר מִמְסָֽךְ׃
Tym, którzy do późna przesiadują przy winie, którzy przychodzą, by napój wypróbować.
Esther Rabbah
Rabbi Azarya began: “Do not see wine in its redness, for one who sets his eye on the cup will walk the straight path” (Proverbs 23:31). Rabbi Azarya said: “Do not see wine in its redness [yitadam]” – as he will lust [yitav] for menstrual blood [dam] and for the blood of discharge [ziva]. “For one who directs his eye to the cup [kos]” – kis is written, a euphemism;1This is a euphemism for licentiousness. that is what you say: “We will have one purse [kis] for all of us” (Proverbs 1:14). “Will walk the straight path”2The midrash understands this phrase in the verse to be ironic. – ultimately his wife says: I have seen like a red rose, and he does not separate from her. Rabbi Asi said: If he is a Torah scholar, he will ultimately purify the ritually impure, and impurify the ritually pure.
Alternatively, “do not see wine in its redness” – it will certainly cause him to flush. “For one who sets his eye on the cup” – he fixes his eyes on the cup and the storekeeper fixes his eye on the purse. “Will walk the straight path [bemeisharim]” – ultimately, he will render his house a plain [meishra].3Meaning it will be empty. He says: Whatever this bronze cup does an earthenware cup does, and he sells it and drinks wine with its proceeds. Whatever this bronze pot does an earthenware pot does, and he sells it and drinks wine with its proceeds. Rabbi Yitzḥak bar Raddifa said in the name of Rabbi Ami: Ultimately, he will sell all the vessels in his house and drink wine with [what he gets for] them.
Rabbi Aḥa said: There was an incident involving a certain person who sold all the vessels in his house and drank wine with [what he got for] them. His sons said: This father of ours is not leaving us anything. What did they do? They gave him to drink, they lifted him up and carried him, and placed him in a certain cemetery. Some wine merchants passed the gate of the cemetery and heard the angaria [military unit commandeering provisions] was in the city. They unloaded their burden in that cemetery. They said: Let us go and see what is being said in the city. The old man awoke from his slumber and saw a wineskin that had been placed above his head. He untied it and put it in his mouth and drank. He drank until he fell asleep. After three days, his sons said: Should we not go and see how our father is doing? They went and found him and there was a wineskin in his mouth. They said: Here, too, your Creator has not forsaken you. Since you have it from Heaven, we don’t know what we to do with you. They made an arrangement among themselves that each of them [in turn] would provide him with drink on each day.
It is written:4These verses relate to the drinker of wine referred to above, and describe the results of drunkenness. “You will be like one lying in the midst of the sea, like one who lies atop a mast” (Proverbs 23:34). You will be like this ship that is becalmed on the high seas.5Some understand this to mean: “like a ship that is tossed on the high seas.” “Like one who lies atop a mast,” – like a rooster that sits on a rope and goes constantly to and fro; like a captain who sits atop a mast and goes constantly to and fro. “They struck me, but I did not feel it” (Proverbs 23:35) – they struck him, but he did not feel. “They beat me, but I did not know” – they exploit him, but he is unaware. He drinks five kustin6A measure of liquid volume, about a third of a liter. of beer and they say to him: ‘You drank ten kustin.’ If you say that he will awaken from his sleep and forget it, Scripture says [about the drunk]: “When will I awaken? I will continue to seek it” (Ibid.).
]“To whom is there woe? To whom alas? To whom strife? To whom talk? To whom wounds without cause? To whom redness of eyes? To those who linger over wine”] (Proverbs 23:29-30). “To whom is there woe? To whom alas?” Rav Huna said: To one who does not toil in Torah study. “To whom strife?” – to whom disputes? “To whom talk” – to whom prattle? “To whom wounds without cause” – to whom wounds for nothing? “To those who linger over wine” (Proverbs 23:30).
There was an incident involving a certain man who was accustomed to drink twelve kistin of wine every day. One day he drank eleven kistin, and he lay down but sleep would not come. He awoke in the dark and went to the storekeeper. He said to him: ‘Sell me one kista.’ He [the storekeeper] said to him: ‘I will not open for you, because it is dark and I fear the watchmen.’ He directed his eyes and saw a hole in the door. He said to him: ‘Give me from it through the hole, you will position it inside and I will drink it outside.’ He did so for him. He drank and fell asleep before the door. The watchmen passed by him; they thought he was a thief, they struck him and they wounded him. They proclaimed about him: “To whom wounds without cause” – to whom wounds for nothing? “To whom redness of eyes” – to whom eyes red like the sun?
All these befall whom? “Those who linger over wine” – this is one who enters the store first and leaves last. “To those who come to assess the mixture” – to one who hears that this [particular] person has fine wine and pursues him. What is written about him at the end? “Its [wine’s] end is that it bites like a serpent and secretes [poison] like an adder” (Proverbs 23:32). Just as this adder separates between death and life, so wine separated between Adam and Eve, as Rabbi Yehuda ben Rabbi Ilai said: The tree from which Adam the first man ate was a grape [vine]. That is what is written: “Their grapes are grapes of gall, bitter clusters for them” (Deuteronomy 32:32). These brought bitterness to the world.
Alternatively, “and secretes [yafrish] like an adder” – just as this adder separates [mafrish]7The verb lehafrish can mean both to secrete and to separate. between death and life, so, wine separated between Noah and his sons for enslavement. That is what is written: “He drank from the wine and was intoxicated and he was exposed inside the tent” (Genesis 9:21), as a result8 Subsequently, Noah’s son Ham, father of Canaan, “saw the nakedness of his father.” he [Noah] said: “Cursed is Canaan [a slave of slaves he shall be to his brothers]” (Genesis 9:25).
“And secretes [yafrish] like an adder” – just as this adder separates [mafrish] between death and life, so wine separated between Lot and his daughters for mamzerut.9The status of a child born from incest. That is what is written: “They gave their father to drink that night” (Genesis 19:33), as a result he said: “Lot’s two daughters conceived from their father” (Genesis 19:36).
Alternatively, “and secretes like an adder” – just as this adder separates between death and life, so wine separated between Aaron and his sons for death, as it is taught: Rabbi Shimon says: The sons of Aaron died only because they entered the Tent of Meeting intoxicated with wine. Rabbi Pinḥas in the name of Rabbi Levi said: This is comparable to a king who had a loyal member of his household. He found him standing at the entrance of his house, and he decapitated him without saying anything and appointed another member of his household in his stead. We do not know the reason that he killed the first one. It is only from what he commanded the second one and said to him: ‘Do not enter the house’ that we know why he killed the first one. Likewise, “Fire emerged from before the Lord and consumed them” (Leviticus 10:2) – we do not know the reason they died. It is only from what he commanded Aaron and said to him “You shall not drink wine or intoxicating drink” (Leviticus 10:9), that we know that they died only due to the wine.
Alternatively, “and secretes like an adder” – just as this adder separates between death and life, so wine separated between the ten tribes and the tribes of Judah and Benjamin for exile. That is what is written: “Woe! Those who rise early in the morning pursue intoxicating drink; those who tarry late, wine will inflame” (Isaiah 5:11), as a result: “Therefore, My people is exiled for lack of knowledge” (Isaiah 5:13).
Alternatively, “and secretes like an adder” – just as this adder separates between death and life, so wine separated the tribe of Judah and the tribe of Benjamin for exile. That is what is written: “These too erred with wine and strayed with intoxicating drink” (Isaiah 28:7); these and those.10Not only the ten tribes of Israel but also the tribes of Judah and Benjamin were eventually exiled.
Alternatively, “and secretes like an adder” – just as this adder separates between death and life, so wine separated between kingdom and kingdom for death. That is what is written: “Belshatzar said, as he tasted the wine” (Daniel 5:2), as a result it says: “During that night, Belshatzar the Chaldean king was killed” (Daniel 5:30).
Alternatively, “and secretes like an adder” – just as this adder separates between death and life, so wine separated between Aḥashverosh and Vashti for death. That is what is written: “On the seventh day, when the king was merry with wine” (Esther 1:10) – as a result he became angry and killed her.
Alternatively, “do not see wine in its redness” – it will certainly cause him to flush. “For one who sets his eye on the cup” – he fixes his eyes on the cup and the storekeeper fixes his eye on the purse. “Will walk the straight path [bemeisharim]” – ultimately, he will render his house a plain [meishra].3Meaning it will be empty. He says: Whatever this bronze cup does an earthenware cup does, and he sells it and drinks wine with its proceeds. Whatever this bronze pot does an earthenware pot does, and he sells it and drinks wine with its proceeds. Rabbi Yitzḥak bar Raddifa said in the name of Rabbi Ami: Ultimately, he will sell all the vessels in his house and drink wine with [what he gets for] them.
Rabbi Aḥa said: There was an incident involving a certain person who sold all the vessels in his house and drank wine with [what he got for] them. His sons said: This father of ours is not leaving us anything. What did they do? They gave him to drink, they lifted him up and carried him, and placed him in a certain cemetery. Some wine merchants passed the gate of the cemetery and heard the angaria [military unit commandeering provisions] was in the city. They unloaded their burden in that cemetery. They said: Let us go and see what is being said in the city. The old man awoke from his slumber and saw a wineskin that had been placed above his head. He untied it and put it in his mouth and drank. He drank until he fell asleep. After three days, his sons said: Should we not go and see how our father is doing? They went and found him and there was a wineskin in his mouth. They said: Here, too, your Creator has not forsaken you. Since you have it from Heaven, we don’t know what we to do with you. They made an arrangement among themselves that each of them [in turn] would provide him with drink on each day.
It is written:4These verses relate to the drinker of wine referred to above, and describe the results of drunkenness. “You will be like one lying in the midst of the sea, like one who lies atop a mast” (Proverbs 23:34). You will be like this ship that is becalmed on the high seas.5Some understand this to mean: “like a ship that is tossed on the high seas.” “Like one who lies atop a mast,” – like a rooster that sits on a rope and goes constantly to and fro; like a captain who sits atop a mast and goes constantly to and fro. “They struck me, but I did not feel it” (Proverbs 23:35) – they struck him, but he did not feel. “They beat me, but I did not know” – they exploit him, but he is unaware. He drinks five kustin6A measure of liquid volume, about a third of a liter. of beer and they say to him: ‘You drank ten kustin.’ If you say that he will awaken from his sleep and forget it, Scripture says [about the drunk]: “When will I awaken? I will continue to seek it” (Ibid.).
]“To whom is there woe? To whom alas? To whom strife? To whom talk? To whom wounds without cause? To whom redness of eyes? To those who linger over wine”] (Proverbs 23:29-30). “To whom is there woe? To whom alas?” Rav Huna said: To one who does not toil in Torah study. “To whom strife?” – to whom disputes? “To whom talk” – to whom prattle? “To whom wounds without cause” – to whom wounds for nothing? “To those who linger over wine” (Proverbs 23:30).
There was an incident involving a certain man who was accustomed to drink twelve kistin of wine every day. One day he drank eleven kistin, and he lay down but sleep would not come. He awoke in the dark and went to the storekeeper. He said to him: ‘Sell me one kista.’ He [the storekeeper] said to him: ‘I will not open for you, because it is dark and I fear the watchmen.’ He directed his eyes and saw a hole in the door. He said to him: ‘Give me from it through the hole, you will position it inside and I will drink it outside.’ He did so for him. He drank and fell asleep before the door. The watchmen passed by him; they thought he was a thief, they struck him and they wounded him. They proclaimed about him: “To whom wounds without cause” – to whom wounds for nothing? “To whom redness of eyes” – to whom eyes red like the sun?
All these befall whom? “Those who linger over wine” – this is one who enters the store first and leaves last. “To those who come to assess the mixture” – to one who hears that this [particular] person has fine wine and pursues him. What is written about him at the end? “Its [wine’s] end is that it bites like a serpent and secretes [poison] like an adder” (Proverbs 23:32). Just as this adder separates between death and life, so wine separated between Adam and Eve, as Rabbi Yehuda ben Rabbi Ilai said: The tree from which Adam the first man ate was a grape [vine]. That is what is written: “Their grapes are grapes of gall, bitter clusters for them” (Deuteronomy 32:32). These brought bitterness to the world.
Alternatively, “and secretes [yafrish] like an adder” – just as this adder separates [mafrish]7The verb lehafrish can mean both to secrete and to separate. between death and life, so, wine separated between Noah and his sons for enslavement. That is what is written: “He drank from the wine and was intoxicated and he was exposed inside the tent” (Genesis 9:21), as a result8 Subsequently, Noah’s son Ham, father of Canaan, “saw the nakedness of his father.” he [Noah] said: “Cursed is Canaan [a slave of slaves he shall be to his brothers]” (Genesis 9:25).
“And secretes [yafrish] like an adder” – just as this adder separates [mafrish] between death and life, so wine separated between Lot and his daughters for mamzerut.9The status of a child born from incest. That is what is written: “They gave their father to drink that night” (Genesis 19:33), as a result he said: “Lot’s two daughters conceived from their father” (Genesis 19:36).
Alternatively, “and secretes like an adder” – just as this adder separates between death and life, so wine separated between Aaron and his sons for death, as it is taught: Rabbi Shimon says: The sons of Aaron died only because they entered the Tent of Meeting intoxicated with wine. Rabbi Pinḥas in the name of Rabbi Levi said: This is comparable to a king who had a loyal member of his household. He found him standing at the entrance of his house, and he decapitated him without saying anything and appointed another member of his household in his stead. We do not know the reason that he killed the first one. It is only from what he commanded the second one and said to him: ‘Do not enter the house’ that we know why he killed the first one. Likewise, “Fire emerged from before the Lord and consumed them” (Leviticus 10:2) – we do not know the reason they died. It is only from what he commanded Aaron and said to him “You shall not drink wine or intoxicating drink” (Leviticus 10:9), that we know that they died only due to the wine.
Alternatively, “and secretes like an adder” – just as this adder separates between death and life, so wine separated between the ten tribes and the tribes of Judah and Benjamin for exile. That is what is written: “Woe! Those who rise early in the morning pursue intoxicating drink; those who tarry late, wine will inflame” (Isaiah 5:11), as a result: “Therefore, My people is exiled for lack of knowledge” (Isaiah 5:13).
Alternatively, “and secretes like an adder” – just as this adder separates between death and life, so wine separated the tribe of Judah and the tribe of Benjamin for exile. That is what is written: “These too erred with wine and strayed with intoxicating drink” (Isaiah 28:7); these and those.10Not only the ten tribes of Israel but also the tribes of Judah and Benjamin were eventually exiled.
Alternatively, “and secretes like an adder” – just as this adder separates between death and life, so wine separated between kingdom and kingdom for death. That is what is written: “Belshatzar said, as he tasted the wine” (Daniel 5:2), as a result it says: “During that night, Belshatzar the Chaldean king was killed” (Daniel 5:30).
Alternatively, “and secretes like an adder” – just as this adder separates between death and life, so wine separated between Aḥashverosh and Vashti for death. That is what is written: “On the seventh day, when the king was merry with wine” (Esther 1:10) – as a result he became angry and killed her.
Bamidbar Rabbah
“When a man or a woman will articulate…” – that is what is written: “My son, give me your heart, and your eyes will observe my ways” (Proverbs 23:26). “My son, give,” this is Israel, who are called children, as it is stated: “You are children to the Lord your God” (Deuteronomy 14:1). “Me your heart,” just as it says: “Circumsize the foreskin of your heart…” (Deuteronomy 10:16); “you shall place these words of Mine upon your heart…” (Deuteronomy 11:18). “And your eyes will observe my ways,” just as it says: “You shall see it, and remember all the mitzvot of the Lord” (Numbers 15:39). “For a harlot is a deep pit [and a foreign woman is a narrow well]” (Proverbs 23:27); the verse is speaking regarding idol worship, which is called a harlot [zona], just as it says: “[This people] will stray [vezana] after the foreign gods of the land” (Deuteronomy 31:16). It is called a pit [shuḥa] on the basis of “a person will be made lowly [vayishaḥ]” (Isaiah 2:9). “Deep,” on the basis of “and a man was made low” (Isaiah 2:9). Likewise it says: “The haughtiness of man will be made low [veshaḥ]…” (Isaiah 2:17). From where is it derived that the verse is speaking of idol worship? It is because it is written thereafter: “And the false gods will entirely perish” (Isaiah 2:18).
“Well [be’er],” because it was by means of idol worship that Israel descended into a pit, as it is stated: “They bound my life in the pit” (Lamentations 3:53). “Narrow [tzara],” just as it says: “He will besiege [vehetzar] you at all your gates” (Deuteronomy 28:52). “Foreign,” this is idol worship, just as it says: “Foreign gods” (Deuteronomy 31:16).
“She, too [af]” (Proverbs 23:28); from where do we derive that idol worship brings wrath [af] upon a person? It is as it is stated: “Lest your heart be seduced, [and you stray and worship other gods]…. The wrath [af] of the Lord will be enflamed against you…” (Deuteronomy 11:16–17). “Will lie in ambush like a kidnapper [keḥetef]”18This is expounded as though it was written baḥataf, meaning hurriedly. (Proverbs 23:28), just as it says: “You will be quickly eradicated” (Deuteronomy 11:17). “And increase the treacherous among men” (Proverbs 23:28) – “Men [adam],” this is Israel, who are called adam: “You…are men [adam]” (Ezekiel 34:31). “Treacherous [uvogedim],” just as it says: “A secret for me, a secret for me. [Woe is me; the betrayers [bogedim] betrayed and the betrayer of the betrayers [bogedim] is betrayed]” (Isaiah 24:16).
Another matter, “[and increase [vetosif]] the treacherous among men,” these are the curses in Torat Kohanim,19The book of Leviticus. which are calamities after calamities, and it is written in their regard: “I will increase,” just as it says: “And if after these you will not heed…I will increase my blows upon you” (Leviticus 26:18, 21). From where is it derived that the verse is speaking of idol worship? It is because it is written: “I will destroy your high places20The altars used for idol worship were built on high places. [and destroy your sun stones]” (Leviticus 26:30).
“To whom woe? To whom alas? [To whom strife? To whom talk? To whom wounds without cause? To whom redness of the eyes?]” (Proverbs 23:29). Although Israel sinned and the Holy One blessed be He delivered them into the hand of the nations of the world due to their iniquities, they [the nations] did not emerge unscathed as, ultimately, the Holy One blessed be He will judge the nations of the world into whose hand He delivered them, just as He did with Egypt and Babylon. This is why “to whom” is written six times – corresponding to the six exiles that Israel was exiled among the nations, and they were all punished on their account. They are: Egypt first, and then Assyria, Babylon, Media, Greece, and Edom. Likewise it says: “I am enraged with great rage at the nations that are at ease, for I was mildly enraged, and they augmented the affliction” (Zechariah 1:15).21The nations caused Israel to suffer more than God wanted them to suffer. “For I will facilitate the annihilation of all the nations where I banished you” (Jeremiah 46:28). That is why it is stated: “To whom woe? To whom alas…?”
“To those who linger over wine” (Proverbs 23:30), these are Israel, who are called wine, just as it says: “On that day, sing about it, a vineyard of wine” (Isaiah 27:2). “To those who linger,” these are the nations of the world, who linger over wine22Israel. to imbibe and take all the fruit of their labor. “To those who come to assess the mixture” (Proverbs 23:30), as they investigate strategies in their regard; how they will be able to take everything that they have, kill them, and cause them harm. “Do not look at wine in its redness” (Proverbs 23:31), the Holy One blessed be He cautions the idolaters that they should not place too onerous a yoke upon Israel. That is what is written: “Do not look at wine in its redness.”
What is “for he who directs his eye to the cup [bakos]”? (Proverbs 23:31). Bakis is written,23The word is written with a yod, kis, but is read with the letter vav, kos. as they direct their sight to the purse [bekhisam] of Israel. “Will walk smoothly [bemeisharim]” (Proverbs 23:31); that they [the nations] will take everything that they [Israel] have and leave their houses like a plain [mishor]. Alternatively, “will walk smoothly [bemeisharim],” as each of them [the nations] does to them [Israel] as he sees fit [hayashar be’einav]. Alternatively, “will walk smoothly [bemeisharim],” as they do not deem all the robberies that they rob from Israel as an iniquity, but rather, they think that everything that they do to them is in the category of uprightness [yosher].
“At its end, it bites like a serpent” (Proverbs 23:32). The Holy One blessed be He says to them: Eve, because she followed her eyes upon the advice of the serpent, just as it says: “The woman saw that the tree was good…” (Genesis 3:6). What was her ultimate fate? She was cursed, due to the serpent, seven curses mentioned in the verse, as it is stated: “To the woman He said: I will increase [your suffering and your pregnancy; in pain you shall give birth to children and your desire shall be for your husband, and he shall rule over you]” (Genesis 3:16).24The verse is expounded to include menstrual blood, the blood of the hymen, the difficulties of child rearing, the discomfort of pregnancy, the pain of childbirth, the longing for her husband in his absence, and the fact that while he can directly initiate relations, she must do so discreetly (Eiruvin 100b). That tree was wine. You, too, will be punished through Israel, who were called wine, when you look at them and imbibe their assets, as it is stated: “Israel is sacred to the Lord, the first of His crop, [all those who devour it will be guilty, evil will come upon them]” (Jeremiah 2:3).
“And secretes [yafrish] like an adder” (Proverbs 23:32); just as the adder sets a person aside [mafrish] from their life, to death, so, due to their iniquity, that they perform evil vis-à-vis Israel, He will eradicate them from the world, as it is stated: “Egypt will become desolation [and Edom will become a desolate wilderness, due to the villainy against the children of Judah]” (Joel 4:19) – this is robbery, which is tantamount to murder. That is what is written: “That they shed innocent blood in their land” (Joel 4:19).
“Your eyes will see strange things” (Proverbs 23:33) – instead of the perspective with which the idolaters would look upon Israel, the Holy One blessed be He will bring upon them uncommon calamities that will be incompatible with one another, in the manner that they befell Israel, just as it says: “Many evils and troubles will find it” (Deuteronomy 31:17); evils that are rivals with one another, like a wasp and a scorpion.25The treatment for a wasp sting, cold food, exacerbates a scorpion bite, and the treatment for a scorpion bite, hot food, exacerbates a wasp sting.
“And your heart will speak contradictions [tahpukhot]” (Proverbs 23:33); you [the nations] turn [mithapekh] against them every day, just as it says: “Indeed, against me he will again turn [yahafokh] his hand all day” (Lamentations 3:3). The heart of Israel loses its sanity due to all the troubles that they perpetrate against them. So the Holy One blessed be He will exact retribution against them measure for measure, as He will bring harsh calamities which will cause them to lose their sanity and He will speak to bring upon them confusion and He will bring terror upon them. Tahpukhot, just as it says: “Terror overwhelms [hafakh] me” (Job 30:15). Likewise it says: “The sound of the Lord as He exacts retribution against His enemies” (Isaiah 66:6) – measure for measure. “You will be like one lying in the heart of the sea” (Proverbs 23:34), this is Pharaoh, who drowned in the heart of the sea, just as it says: “The depths congealed in the heart of the sea.” (Exodus 15:8), and it says: “He hurled Pharaoh and his army into the Red Sea” (Psalms 136:15). Just as Pharaoh, the Holy One blessed be He smote him with ten plagues corresponding to the ten matters that he decreed upon Israel, and ultimately drowned him, corresponding to: “Every son who is born, [you shall cast him into the Nile]” (Exodus 1:22), so, the Holy One blessed be He will do to all the idolatrous nations who perform evil to Israel, measure for measure.
“Or like one lying atop a mast” (Proverbs 23:34), this was Sisera. What is written? “He harshly oppressed the children of Israel for twenty years” (Judges 4:3). What was his end? Because he would harshly curse them and blaspheme them, that is why he died a contemptible death, that He delivered him into the hands of a woman, just as it says: “For the Lord will deliver Sisera into the hand of a woman” (Judges 4:9). That is why it is stated: “Like one lying” – this was Sisera, in whose regard it is written: “At her feet he knelt, he fell, he lay” (Judges 5:27). “Atop a mast [ḥibel],” as Yael smashed him [hibalto] on his head with the tent peg. That is what is written: “Her hand to the peg she extended, and her right [to the laborer’s hammer]” (Judges 5:26), measure for measure.
Another matter, “or like one lying atop a mast,” this was Haman, who sought to kill all the Jews, them and their children, to plunder all their belongings, and he sought to hang Mordekhai. That is why he received measure for measure; he and his sons died and Mordekhai took all his possessions. That is why it is written: “Or like one lying [ukeshokhev]” – this is Haman, who died an unusual death, just as it says: “There is Edom, its kings and all its princes, who, despite their might, were placed with those slain by the sword; they will lie [yishkavu] with the uncircumcised and with those who descend into the pit” (Ezekiel 32:29). “Atop [berosh],” just as it says: “Let his evil plot that he had devised against the Jews return upon his head [al rosho]” (Esther 9:25). “A mast [ḥibel],” these are his sons, as it is stated: “They hanged him and his sons on the gallows” (Esther 9:25). Ḥibel is nothing other than his sons, just as it says: “Why should God become angry at your voice and destroy [veḥibel] your handiwork?” (Ecclesiastes 5:5). The handiwork of a person, these are his children. Ḥibel; ḥevel is written, this is Haman, who was strangled with a rope [ḥevel]. From where is it derived that his belongings went to Mordekhai? It is as it is stated: “Esther appointed Mordekhai over the house of Haman” (Esther 8:2), measure for measure.
“They struck me, but I did not feel pain” (Proverbs 23:35), woe unto them, to idolaters who do not learn a lesson; what the Holy One blessed be He did to the earlier generations, the later generations did not learn. That is what is written: “They struck me, but I did not feel pain.” The idolaters say: ‘Even though the Holy One blessed be He smote Pharaoh and Egypt on account of Israel; nevertheless, I did not learn my lesson.’ That is what is written: “But I did not feel pain.”
“They beat me, but I did not know” (Proverbs 23:35). [The idolaters say:] ‘Even though He exacted retribution from Sisera, in whose regard it is written: “She struck Sisera” (Judges 5:26), I did not pay attention to it, to learn a lesson from him. “When will I awaken?” (Proverbs 23:35). Moreover, I was waiting for the strike to pass so I can continue to seek Israel’s harm.’ That is what is written: “I will continue to seek it” (Proverbs 23:35). Likewise, it says: “If you crush a fool…in a mortar [with a pestle, his folly will not be removed from him]” (Proverbs 27:22).
Another matter, “My son, give me your heart, [and your eyes will observe my ways]” (Proverbs 23:26). What did the Holy One blessed be He see that led him to ask of Israel that the heart and the eyes shall follow Him? It is because transgression is dependent on them. That is what is written: “You shall not rove after your heart [and after your eyes]” (Numbers 15:39). The eyes and the heart are the two agents of sin. “For a harlot [zonah] is a deep pit, [and a foreign woman is a narrow well]” (Proverbs 23:27), just as Moses said: “After which you stray [zonim]” (Numbers 15:39), saying that harlotry is dependent upon them. The eyes see the harlot, and the heart contemplates her. So, the Divine Spirit said by means of Solomon: “For…a deep pit.” Why did he call her a pit [shuḥa]? It is based on: “For her house sags [shaḥa] toward death” (Proverbs 2:18). “Deep [amuka],” just as it says: “Her guests are in the depths [be’imkei] of the grave” (Proverbs 9:18). “Harlot,” this is a married woman.26Who commits adultery. “A narrow well [be’er],” it is because she causes the adulterer to descend to Gehenna. That is what is written: “To the netherworld her steps are supported” (Proverbs 5:5). The netherworld is called a pit [bor], as it is written: “Lord, You elevated my soul from the netherworld; You kept me alive from descending into the pit” (Psalms 30:4). That which it says: “Narrow,” this is Gehenna, which is wide at the bottom and narrow at its mouth. That is what is written: “He has even moved you from a narrow opening, its bottom broad without straitness" (Job 36:16). “Foreign,” as she is foreign to you because she is a married woman.
“She, too [af]” (Proverbs 23:28), as she brings wrath [af] upon a person, as it is written: “Do not commit adultery [lo tinaf]” (Exodus 20:13); do not let the wrath [af] benefit [tehene] from you. Alternatively, lo tinaf, do not introduce [titen] wrath [af] between a husband and his wife. “Will lie in ambush keḥetef” (Proverbs 23:28), as the Holy One blessed be He does not wait for a prolonged27Keḥetef with a tav can be interpreted as though it were with a tet, meaning in an instant.time for the adulterers, in order to exact retribution against them. Likewise it says: “I will be a swift witness against the sorcerers, and against the adulterers” (Malachi 3:5). “And increase the treacherous among men” (Proverbs 23:28), as she seduces upright people and renders them treacherous and increases the wicked in Israel. That is what is written: “The woman of folly is clamorous…. She sits at the entrance of her house…to call to the passersby who straighten their paths. Whoever is a fool, let him turn here; to one who lacks heart, she says to him: Stolen waters are sweet…but he does not know that the ghosts are there” (Proverbs 9:13–18). That is, “and increase the treacherous among men.”
“To whom woe? To whom alas? [To whom strife? To whom talk? To whom wounds without cause? To whom redness of the eyes?]” (Proverbs 23:29). Regarding the adulterer he says: “To whom woe,” just as it says: “To cause a belly to distend” (Numbers 5:22).28See Bemidbar Rabba 9:35, which describes the punishment of the adulterer. “To whom alas [avoi],” this is the father of woe [av oi], just as it says: “And a thigh to fall” (Numbers 5:22). It is because it is the thigh that performs the transgression, that it is called avoi, the father of woe. “To whom strife?” All of these befall whom? The woe and the alas befall the adulterer, who introduces strife between a husband and his wife. That is, “to whom strife?” because the strife is his. Likewise he says: “Who introduces strife between brothers” (Proverbs 6:19); this is a husband and wife who are brethren to each other.
“To whom talk?” – moreover, upon whom do these curses, the woe and the alas, come? That is “to whom talk? To whom wounds without cause?” – this is the harlot, who suffered the wounds of love without cause,29Namely, is suffering needlessly because of the adultery which she committed. and with no wound from her husband amuses herself with another. “To whom redness of the eyes,” this is the harlot who gives the adulterer wine to drink, just as it says: “Red eyed from wine” (Genesis 49:12).
Another matter, “to whom talk?" – this is the oath of the curse,30On the adulterous woman. just as it is written: “The priest shall say to the woman: May the Lord render you [as a curse and an oath]” (Numbers 5:21). “To whom wounds without cause?” – due to her affairs, she was wounded unnecessarily, as the priest exposes her hair, seizes her garments; if they are torn, they are torn, if they unravel, they unravel. “To whom redness of the eyes?” – this is the drinking of the water, as immediately when she would drink, her eyes bulged. All of these befall whom? It is “to those who linger over wine” (Proverbs 23:30). From here [we learn] that wine is a cause. “To those who come to assess the mixture” (Proverbs 23:30), when he hears where there is good wine, he pursues it.
“Do not look at wine in its redness [ki yitadam]” (Proverbs 23:31); the Divine Spirit cautioned regarding wine, that a person should not get drunk. Why? Ki yitadam, it is because his destiny is blood [aḥarito dam], as he violates a transgression for which he incurs liability to be put to death. Another matter, Ki yitadam, it is because he desires the blood of [yitaveh ledam] a menstruant and the blood of a zava. “For one who directs his eye to the cup [bakos]” (Proverbs 23:31), bakis is written; due to the kos, he will direct his eye to the pocket [kis] – the Torah employed a euphemism, saying that he would consort with a forbidden relation. “Will walk smoothly [bemeisharim]” (Proverbs 23:31), ultimately, his wife says to him, I have seen like a red rose,31I have seen menstrual blood. and he does not withdraw.32All the halakhic obstacles become like a flat plain for him, and therefore he has relations with his wife even though she is a nidda. Rabbi Asi said: If he is a Torah scholar, ultimately, he will rule the pure impure, and rule the impure pure. Another matter, “will walk smoothly [bemeisharim],” ultimately he will permit all the transgressions and render them forsaken like a plain [mishor]. He speaks with a woman in the marketplace; he speaks profanity, foul language, in his drunkenness, and is not ashamed. “At its end, it bites like a serpent” (Proverbs 23:32); just as the serpent, because it incited Eve to drink wine, the earth was cursed because of it, as it is stated: “Cursed is the earth because of you” (Genesis 3:17). Likewise, Noah, his son, one-third of the world,33Noah had three children, so if one was cursed, a third of the world was cursed. was cursed due to wine, as it is stated: “Noah awoke from his wine…cursed be Canaan” (Genesis 9:24–25). This is Ḥam, who was his third son, and he is called “the father of Canaan” (Genesis 9:18). That is the way he cursed him.
“And secretes [yafrish] like an adder” (Proverbs 23:32); just as this adder sets the person aside from life, to death, so, wine, sets man aside from the paths of life to the paths of death, as wine causes one to engage in idol worship. That is what is written: “Your eyes will see strange things [zarot]” (Proverbs 23:33), just as it says: “There shall be no strange [zar] god among you” (Psalms 81:10). Alternatively, it causes him to consort with a married woman, just as it says: “Why would you err, my son, with a strange woman [zara]” (Proverbs 5:20). Alternately, he will render the mitzvot foreign to him, just as it says: “You rebuke the accursed, insolent ones [zedim] who stray [from Your commandments]” (Psalms 119:21). Zedim are nothing other than those who err due to wine, just as it says: “An insolent [zed] arrogant man, cynic is his name; he acts with malicious ire” (Proverbs 21:24), this is a drunkard who is called arrogant and a cynic. Arrogant, from where is it derived? It is as it is stated: “Indeed wine is treacherous, so an arrogant man will not find repose” (Habakkuk 2:5). A cynic, from where is it derived: “Wine is a cynic, strong drink is tumultuous, and any who err in it will not become wise” (Proverbs 20:1). “And your heart will speak contradictions [tahpukhot]” (Proverbs 23:33) – as he turns [hofekh] his face from the Holy One blessed be He and from the mitzvot, just as it says: “For they are a fickle [tahpukhot] generation” (Deuteronomy 32:20). “You will be like one lying in the heart of the sea” (Proverbs 23:34), this is Noah, who lay in the ark for twelve months in the midst of the Flood waters, and because he drank and became inebriated, he became disqualified34See Deuteronomy 23:2. as he was castrated.
“Or like one lying atop a mast” (Proverbs 23:34), this is Adam, the first man, who was the first of all people. Due to wine,35In accordance wth the view that the fruit eaten by Adam was fruit from a vine. See Berachot 40a. he was punished with death and brought the pangs of death into the world. “They struck me, but I did not feel pain” (Proverbs 23:35); woe unto the adulterer, who does not gain knowledge from what he experienced. He saw what befell the sota due to wine, but did not gain knowledge. “They beat me, but I did not know” (Proverbs 23:35); he saw in the Torah what befell the adulterer due to wine, but did not know how to understand. Rather, he said: “When will I awaken? I will continue to seek it” (Proverbs 23:35), as whenever he will have leisure to engage in harlotry, he will pursue it. We have learned that wine causes harlotry. That is why the Holy One blessed be He wrote the portion of the nazirite after the portion of the sota, so that a person will not perform the act of an adulterer and adulteress, who drank wine and were corrupted; rather, one who fears sin will abstain from wine. That is why it is stated: “When a man or a woman will articulate [to take the vow of a nazirite, to abstain for the Lord]” (Numbers 6:2).
“Well [be’er],” because it was by means of idol worship that Israel descended into a pit, as it is stated: “They bound my life in the pit” (Lamentations 3:53). “Narrow [tzara],” just as it says: “He will besiege [vehetzar] you at all your gates” (Deuteronomy 28:52). “Foreign,” this is idol worship, just as it says: “Foreign gods” (Deuteronomy 31:16).
“She, too [af]” (Proverbs 23:28); from where do we derive that idol worship brings wrath [af] upon a person? It is as it is stated: “Lest your heart be seduced, [and you stray and worship other gods]…. The wrath [af] of the Lord will be enflamed against you…” (Deuteronomy 11:16–17). “Will lie in ambush like a kidnapper [keḥetef]”18This is expounded as though it was written baḥataf, meaning hurriedly. (Proverbs 23:28), just as it says: “You will be quickly eradicated” (Deuteronomy 11:17). “And increase the treacherous among men” (Proverbs 23:28) – “Men [adam],” this is Israel, who are called adam: “You…are men [adam]” (Ezekiel 34:31). “Treacherous [uvogedim],” just as it says: “A secret for me, a secret for me. [Woe is me; the betrayers [bogedim] betrayed and the betrayer of the betrayers [bogedim] is betrayed]” (Isaiah 24:16).
Another matter, “[and increase [vetosif]] the treacherous among men,” these are the curses in Torat Kohanim,19The book of Leviticus. which are calamities after calamities, and it is written in their regard: “I will increase,” just as it says: “And if after these you will not heed…I will increase my blows upon you” (Leviticus 26:18, 21). From where is it derived that the verse is speaking of idol worship? It is because it is written: “I will destroy your high places20The altars used for idol worship were built on high places. [and destroy your sun stones]” (Leviticus 26:30).
“To whom woe? To whom alas? [To whom strife? To whom talk? To whom wounds without cause? To whom redness of the eyes?]” (Proverbs 23:29). Although Israel sinned and the Holy One blessed be He delivered them into the hand of the nations of the world due to their iniquities, they [the nations] did not emerge unscathed as, ultimately, the Holy One blessed be He will judge the nations of the world into whose hand He delivered them, just as He did with Egypt and Babylon. This is why “to whom” is written six times – corresponding to the six exiles that Israel was exiled among the nations, and they were all punished on their account. They are: Egypt first, and then Assyria, Babylon, Media, Greece, and Edom. Likewise it says: “I am enraged with great rage at the nations that are at ease, for I was mildly enraged, and they augmented the affliction” (Zechariah 1:15).21The nations caused Israel to suffer more than God wanted them to suffer. “For I will facilitate the annihilation of all the nations where I banished you” (Jeremiah 46:28). That is why it is stated: “To whom woe? To whom alas…?”
“To those who linger over wine” (Proverbs 23:30), these are Israel, who are called wine, just as it says: “On that day, sing about it, a vineyard of wine” (Isaiah 27:2). “To those who linger,” these are the nations of the world, who linger over wine22Israel. to imbibe and take all the fruit of their labor. “To those who come to assess the mixture” (Proverbs 23:30), as they investigate strategies in their regard; how they will be able to take everything that they have, kill them, and cause them harm. “Do not look at wine in its redness” (Proverbs 23:31), the Holy One blessed be He cautions the idolaters that they should not place too onerous a yoke upon Israel. That is what is written: “Do not look at wine in its redness.”
What is “for he who directs his eye to the cup [bakos]”? (Proverbs 23:31). Bakis is written,23The word is written with a yod, kis, but is read with the letter vav, kos. as they direct their sight to the purse [bekhisam] of Israel. “Will walk smoothly [bemeisharim]” (Proverbs 23:31); that they [the nations] will take everything that they [Israel] have and leave their houses like a plain [mishor]. Alternatively, “will walk smoothly [bemeisharim],” as each of them [the nations] does to them [Israel] as he sees fit [hayashar be’einav]. Alternatively, “will walk smoothly [bemeisharim],” as they do not deem all the robberies that they rob from Israel as an iniquity, but rather, they think that everything that they do to them is in the category of uprightness [yosher].
“At its end, it bites like a serpent” (Proverbs 23:32). The Holy One blessed be He says to them: Eve, because she followed her eyes upon the advice of the serpent, just as it says: “The woman saw that the tree was good…” (Genesis 3:6). What was her ultimate fate? She was cursed, due to the serpent, seven curses mentioned in the verse, as it is stated: “To the woman He said: I will increase [your suffering and your pregnancy; in pain you shall give birth to children and your desire shall be for your husband, and he shall rule over you]” (Genesis 3:16).24The verse is expounded to include menstrual blood, the blood of the hymen, the difficulties of child rearing, the discomfort of pregnancy, the pain of childbirth, the longing for her husband in his absence, and the fact that while he can directly initiate relations, she must do so discreetly (Eiruvin 100b). That tree was wine. You, too, will be punished through Israel, who were called wine, when you look at them and imbibe their assets, as it is stated: “Israel is sacred to the Lord, the first of His crop, [all those who devour it will be guilty, evil will come upon them]” (Jeremiah 2:3).
“And secretes [yafrish] like an adder” (Proverbs 23:32); just as the adder sets a person aside [mafrish] from their life, to death, so, due to their iniquity, that they perform evil vis-à-vis Israel, He will eradicate them from the world, as it is stated: “Egypt will become desolation [and Edom will become a desolate wilderness, due to the villainy against the children of Judah]” (Joel 4:19) – this is robbery, which is tantamount to murder. That is what is written: “That they shed innocent blood in their land” (Joel 4:19).
“Your eyes will see strange things” (Proverbs 23:33) – instead of the perspective with which the idolaters would look upon Israel, the Holy One blessed be He will bring upon them uncommon calamities that will be incompatible with one another, in the manner that they befell Israel, just as it says: “Many evils and troubles will find it” (Deuteronomy 31:17); evils that are rivals with one another, like a wasp and a scorpion.25The treatment for a wasp sting, cold food, exacerbates a scorpion bite, and the treatment for a scorpion bite, hot food, exacerbates a wasp sting.
“And your heart will speak contradictions [tahpukhot]” (Proverbs 23:33); you [the nations] turn [mithapekh] against them every day, just as it says: “Indeed, against me he will again turn [yahafokh] his hand all day” (Lamentations 3:3). The heart of Israel loses its sanity due to all the troubles that they perpetrate against them. So the Holy One blessed be He will exact retribution against them measure for measure, as He will bring harsh calamities which will cause them to lose their sanity and He will speak to bring upon them confusion and He will bring terror upon them. Tahpukhot, just as it says: “Terror overwhelms [hafakh] me” (Job 30:15). Likewise it says: “The sound of the Lord as He exacts retribution against His enemies” (Isaiah 66:6) – measure for measure. “You will be like one lying in the heart of the sea” (Proverbs 23:34), this is Pharaoh, who drowned in the heart of the sea, just as it says: “The depths congealed in the heart of the sea.” (Exodus 15:8), and it says: “He hurled Pharaoh and his army into the Red Sea” (Psalms 136:15). Just as Pharaoh, the Holy One blessed be He smote him with ten plagues corresponding to the ten matters that he decreed upon Israel, and ultimately drowned him, corresponding to: “Every son who is born, [you shall cast him into the Nile]” (Exodus 1:22), so, the Holy One blessed be He will do to all the idolatrous nations who perform evil to Israel, measure for measure.
“Or like one lying atop a mast” (Proverbs 23:34), this was Sisera. What is written? “He harshly oppressed the children of Israel for twenty years” (Judges 4:3). What was his end? Because he would harshly curse them and blaspheme them, that is why he died a contemptible death, that He delivered him into the hands of a woman, just as it says: “For the Lord will deliver Sisera into the hand of a woman” (Judges 4:9). That is why it is stated: “Like one lying” – this was Sisera, in whose regard it is written: “At her feet he knelt, he fell, he lay” (Judges 5:27). “Atop a mast [ḥibel],” as Yael smashed him [hibalto] on his head with the tent peg. That is what is written: “Her hand to the peg she extended, and her right [to the laborer’s hammer]” (Judges 5:26), measure for measure.
Another matter, “or like one lying atop a mast,” this was Haman, who sought to kill all the Jews, them and their children, to plunder all their belongings, and he sought to hang Mordekhai. That is why he received measure for measure; he and his sons died and Mordekhai took all his possessions. That is why it is written: “Or like one lying [ukeshokhev]” – this is Haman, who died an unusual death, just as it says: “There is Edom, its kings and all its princes, who, despite their might, were placed with those slain by the sword; they will lie [yishkavu] with the uncircumcised and with those who descend into the pit” (Ezekiel 32:29). “Atop [berosh],” just as it says: “Let his evil plot that he had devised against the Jews return upon his head [al rosho]” (Esther 9:25). “A mast [ḥibel],” these are his sons, as it is stated: “They hanged him and his sons on the gallows” (Esther 9:25). Ḥibel is nothing other than his sons, just as it says: “Why should God become angry at your voice and destroy [veḥibel] your handiwork?” (Ecclesiastes 5:5). The handiwork of a person, these are his children. Ḥibel; ḥevel is written, this is Haman, who was strangled with a rope [ḥevel]. From where is it derived that his belongings went to Mordekhai? It is as it is stated: “Esther appointed Mordekhai over the house of Haman” (Esther 8:2), measure for measure.
“They struck me, but I did not feel pain” (Proverbs 23:35), woe unto them, to idolaters who do not learn a lesson; what the Holy One blessed be He did to the earlier generations, the later generations did not learn. That is what is written: “They struck me, but I did not feel pain.” The idolaters say: ‘Even though the Holy One blessed be He smote Pharaoh and Egypt on account of Israel; nevertheless, I did not learn my lesson.’ That is what is written: “But I did not feel pain.”
“They beat me, but I did not know” (Proverbs 23:35). [The idolaters say:] ‘Even though He exacted retribution from Sisera, in whose regard it is written: “She struck Sisera” (Judges 5:26), I did not pay attention to it, to learn a lesson from him. “When will I awaken?” (Proverbs 23:35). Moreover, I was waiting for the strike to pass so I can continue to seek Israel’s harm.’ That is what is written: “I will continue to seek it” (Proverbs 23:35). Likewise, it says: “If you crush a fool…in a mortar [with a pestle, his folly will not be removed from him]” (Proverbs 27:22).
Another matter, “My son, give me your heart, [and your eyes will observe my ways]” (Proverbs 23:26). What did the Holy One blessed be He see that led him to ask of Israel that the heart and the eyes shall follow Him? It is because transgression is dependent on them. That is what is written: “You shall not rove after your heart [and after your eyes]” (Numbers 15:39). The eyes and the heart are the two agents of sin. “For a harlot [zonah] is a deep pit, [and a foreign woman is a narrow well]” (Proverbs 23:27), just as Moses said: “After which you stray [zonim]” (Numbers 15:39), saying that harlotry is dependent upon them. The eyes see the harlot, and the heart contemplates her. So, the Divine Spirit said by means of Solomon: “For…a deep pit.” Why did he call her a pit [shuḥa]? It is based on: “For her house sags [shaḥa] toward death” (Proverbs 2:18). “Deep [amuka],” just as it says: “Her guests are in the depths [be’imkei] of the grave” (Proverbs 9:18). “Harlot,” this is a married woman.26Who commits adultery. “A narrow well [be’er],” it is because she causes the adulterer to descend to Gehenna. That is what is written: “To the netherworld her steps are supported” (Proverbs 5:5). The netherworld is called a pit [bor], as it is written: “Lord, You elevated my soul from the netherworld; You kept me alive from descending into the pit” (Psalms 30:4). That which it says: “Narrow,” this is Gehenna, which is wide at the bottom and narrow at its mouth. That is what is written: “He has even moved you from a narrow opening, its bottom broad without straitness" (Job 36:16). “Foreign,” as she is foreign to you because she is a married woman.
“She, too [af]” (Proverbs 23:28), as she brings wrath [af] upon a person, as it is written: “Do not commit adultery [lo tinaf]” (Exodus 20:13); do not let the wrath [af] benefit [tehene] from you. Alternatively, lo tinaf, do not introduce [titen] wrath [af] between a husband and his wife. “Will lie in ambush keḥetef” (Proverbs 23:28), as the Holy One blessed be He does not wait for a prolonged27Keḥetef with a tav can be interpreted as though it were with a tet, meaning in an instant.time for the adulterers, in order to exact retribution against them. Likewise it says: “I will be a swift witness against the sorcerers, and against the adulterers” (Malachi 3:5). “And increase the treacherous among men” (Proverbs 23:28), as she seduces upright people and renders them treacherous and increases the wicked in Israel. That is what is written: “The woman of folly is clamorous…. She sits at the entrance of her house…to call to the passersby who straighten their paths. Whoever is a fool, let him turn here; to one who lacks heart, she says to him: Stolen waters are sweet…but he does not know that the ghosts are there” (Proverbs 9:13–18). That is, “and increase the treacherous among men.”
“To whom woe? To whom alas? [To whom strife? To whom talk? To whom wounds without cause? To whom redness of the eyes?]” (Proverbs 23:29). Regarding the adulterer he says: “To whom woe,” just as it says: “To cause a belly to distend” (Numbers 5:22).28See Bemidbar Rabba 9:35, which describes the punishment of the adulterer. “To whom alas [avoi],” this is the father of woe [av oi], just as it says: “And a thigh to fall” (Numbers 5:22). It is because it is the thigh that performs the transgression, that it is called avoi, the father of woe. “To whom strife?” All of these befall whom? The woe and the alas befall the adulterer, who introduces strife between a husband and his wife. That is, “to whom strife?” because the strife is his. Likewise he says: “Who introduces strife between brothers” (Proverbs 6:19); this is a husband and wife who are brethren to each other.
“To whom talk?” – moreover, upon whom do these curses, the woe and the alas, come? That is “to whom talk? To whom wounds without cause?” – this is the harlot, who suffered the wounds of love without cause,29Namely, is suffering needlessly because of the adultery which she committed. and with no wound from her husband amuses herself with another. “To whom redness of the eyes,” this is the harlot who gives the adulterer wine to drink, just as it says: “Red eyed from wine” (Genesis 49:12).
Another matter, “to whom talk?" – this is the oath of the curse,30On the adulterous woman. just as it is written: “The priest shall say to the woman: May the Lord render you [as a curse and an oath]” (Numbers 5:21). “To whom wounds without cause?” – due to her affairs, she was wounded unnecessarily, as the priest exposes her hair, seizes her garments; if they are torn, they are torn, if they unravel, they unravel. “To whom redness of the eyes?” – this is the drinking of the water, as immediately when she would drink, her eyes bulged. All of these befall whom? It is “to those who linger over wine” (Proverbs 23:30). From here [we learn] that wine is a cause. “To those who come to assess the mixture” (Proverbs 23:30), when he hears where there is good wine, he pursues it.
“Do not look at wine in its redness [ki yitadam]” (Proverbs 23:31); the Divine Spirit cautioned regarding wine, that a person should not get drunk. Why? Ki yitadam, it is because his destiny is blood [aḥarito dam], as he violates a transgression for which he incurs liability to be put to death. Another matter, Ki yitadam, it is because he desires the blood of [yitaveh ledam] a menstruant and the blood of a zava. “For one who directs his eye to the cup [bakos]” (Proverbs 23:31), bakis is written; due to the kos, he will direct his eye to the pocket [kis] – the Torah employed a euphemism, saying that he would consort with a forbidden relation. “Will walk smoothly [bemeisharim]” (Proverbs 23:31), ultimately, his wife says to him, I have seen like a red rose,31I have seen menstrual blood. and he does not withdraw.32All the halakhic obstacles become like a flat plain for him, and therefore he has relations with his wife even though she is a nidda. Rabbi Asi said: If he is a Torah scholar, ultimately, he will rule the pure impure, and rule the impure pure. Another matter, “will walk smoothly [bemeisharim],” ultimately he will permit all the transgressions and render them forsaken like a plain [mishor]. He speaks with a woman in the marketplace; he speaks profanity, foul language, in his drunkenness, and is not ashamed. “At its end, it bites like a serpent” (Proverbs 23:32); just as the serpent, because it incited Eve to drink wine, the earth was cursed because of it, as it is stated: “Cursed is the earth because of you” (Genesis 3:17). Likewise, Noah, his son, one-third of the world,33Noah had three children, so if one was cursed, a third of the world was cursed. was cursed due to wine, as it is stated: “Noah awoke from his wine…cursed be Canaan” (Genesis 9:24–25). This is Ḥam, who was his third son, and he is called “the father of Canaan” (Genesis 9:18). That is the way he cursed him.
“And secretes [yafrish] like an adder” (Proverbs 23:32); just as this adder sets the person aside from life, to death, so, wine, sets man aside from the paths of life to the paths of death, as wine causes one to engage in idol worship. That is what is written: “Your eyes will see strange things [zarot]” (Proverbs 23:33), just as it says: “There shall be no strange [zar] god among you” (Psalms 81:10). Alternatively, it causes him to consort with a married woman, just as it says: “Why would you err, my son, with a strange woman [zara]” (Proverbs 5:20). Alternately, he will render the mitzvot foreign to him, just as it says: “You rebuke the accursed, insolent ones [zedim] who stray [from Your commandments]” (Psalms 119:21). Zedim are nothing other than those who err due to wine, just as it says: “An insolent [zed] arrogant man, cynic is his name; he acts with malicious ire” (Proverbs 21:24), this is a drunkard who is called arrogant and a cynic. Arrogant, from where is it derived? It is as it is stated: “Indeed wine is treacherous, so an arrogant man will not find repose” (Habakkuk 2:5). A cynic, from where is it derived: “Wine is a cynic, strong drink is tumultuous, and any who err in it will not become wise” (Proverbs 20:1). “And your heart will speak contradictions [tahpukhot]” (Proverbs 23:33) – as he turns [hofekh] his face from the Holy One blessed be He and from the mitzvot, just as it says: “For they are a fickle [tahpukhot] generation” (Deuteronomy 32:20). “You will be like one lying in the heart of the sea” (Proverbs 23:34), this is Noah, who lay in the ark for twelve months in the midst of the Flood waters, and because he drank and became inebriated, he became disqualified34See Deuteronomy 23:2. as he was castrated.
“Or like one lying atop a mast” (Proverbs 23:34), this is Adam, the first man, who was the first of all people. Due to wine,35In accordance wth the view that the fruit eaten by Adam was fruit from a vine. See Berachot 40a. he was punished with death and brought the pangs of death into the world. “They struck me, but I did not feel pain” (Proverbs 23:35); woe unto the adulterer, who does not gain knowledge from what he experienced. He saw what befell the sota due to wine, but did not gain knowledge. “They beat me, but I did not know” (Proverbs 23:35); he saw in the Torah what befell the adulterer due to wine, but did not know how to understand. Rather, he said: “When will I awaken? I will continue to seek it” (Proverbs 23:35), as whenever he will have leisure to engage in harlotry, he will pursue it. We have learned that wine causes harlotry. That is why the Holy One blessed be He wrote the portion of the nazirite after the portion of the sota, so that a person will not perform the act of an adulterer and adulteress, who drank wine and were corrupted; rather, one who fears sin will abstain from wine. That is why it is stated: “When a man or a woman will articulate [to take the vow of a nazirite, to abstain for the Lord]” (Numbers 6:2).
Bamidbar Rabbah
“From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain: vinegar of wine and vinegar of intoxicating drink he shall not drink; he shall not drink anything in which grapes were soaked, and grapes, fresh or dried, he shall not eat” (Numbers 6:3).
“From wine and intoxicating drink…” – that is what is written: “Woe, the valiant to drink wine…who vindicate the wicked following a bribe…” (Isaiah 5:22–23). There it is written: “Happy are you, land, that your king is a free man” (Ecclesiastes 10:17). When is the land characterized as happy? It is when its king engages in Torah, as it is stated: “The tablets were the work of God [and the writing was the writing of God, engraved [ḥarut] on the tablets]” (Exodus 32:16) – do not read it as ḥarut, but rather, as ḥerut, freedom, as one is a free man [ben ḥorin] only when one engages in Torah study. “And your princes dine at the proper time” (Ecclesiastes 10:17), as they set fixed times for Torah and they eat thereafter, to realize what is stated: “Go, eat your bread with joy, and drink your wine with a good heart, as God has already accepted your actions” (Ecclesiastes 9:7). That is what is written thereafter: “In valor and not in drunkenness” (Ecclesiastes 10:17), with the valor of Torah, not with the drunkenness of wine. That is why Isaiah said: The valor of Torah is characterized with “happy” (Ecclesiastes 10:17), but the valor of wine is with “woe,” – “woe, the valiant to drink wine” (Isaiah 5:22). Likewise it says: “To whom, woe? To whom, alas…. To those who linger over wine” (Proverbs 23:29–30). “And capable men [anshei ḥayil] to mix intoxicating drink” (Isaiah 5:22). There it is written: “You shall identify from among the people [capable men [anshei ḥayil]]…They shall judge the people…” (Exodus 18:21–22). But these are capable men only to mix intoxicating drink, just as it says: “To those who come to assess the mixture” (Proverbs 23:30). What is “to mix intoxicating drink”? They would mix strong wine with weak wine in order to become inebriated with it. There was an incident involving a group of dissolute men, who would eat and drink until midnight but would not become inebriated. Wine was brought to them; they said mix wine with wine. They did so until the wine entered them. They arose and struck one another in a drunken state. Their cry circulated throughout the city. The constable came, apprehended them, transferred them to the custody of the kingdom, and they were all eliminated. What caused this to befall them? It was the wine that they were drinking. In their regard it is stated: “To those who come to assess the mixture” – the mixture is nothing other than wine mixed with wine. That is, “and capable men to mix intoxicating drink.” On account of this they forget the Torah and corrupt the law, as it is written thereafter: “Who vindicate the wicked following a bribe” (Isaiah 5:23), and it says: “Lest he drink, and forget what was legislated” (Proverbs 31:5) – he will forget the Torah that was given by means of the lawgiver, this is Moses, as it is stated: “As there the lawgiver’s plot is hidden” (Deuteronomy 33:21). What is written? “And subvert justice for all the children of the poor” (Proverbs 31:5).
Wine and knowledge are likened to the Pleiades and Scorpio. Whenever the Pleiades are visible in the sky, Scorpio is not visible in the sky, and when Scorpio is visible, the Pleiades are not visible. So, wine is likened to Scorpio, and knowledge is likened to the Pleiades. Just as the scorpion strikes with its tail, so, wine, strikes in its aftermath, as it is stated: “At its end, it bites like a serpent” (Proverbs 23:32). Just as the Pleiades ripens fruits and provides them with flavor, so, knowledge provides flavor and fragrance to a person’s words. Wine enters, knowledge exits. Any place there is wine, there is no knowledge. Wine enters, a secret emerges; the numerical value of wine [yayin] is seventy84Yod – 10, yod – 10, nun – 50 = 70. and the numerical value of secret [sod] is seventy.85Samekh – 60, vav – 6, dalet – 4 = 70.
Knowledge is divided into four portions; two in the two kidneys, one portion in the mouth, and one portion in the heart. From where is it derived that two portions of wisdom are in the two kidneys? It is as it is stated: “Who set wisdom in obscurity [batuḥot]?” (Job 38:36). These are the kidneys, that are obscured [tuḥot] in the body. And one portion in the heart, as it is stated: “Inform me of wisdom in the closed place” (Psalms 51:8). And one portion in the mouth, as it is stated: “My mouth will speak wisdom” (Psalms 49:4). Wisdom was placed in these four receptacles and, corresponding to them, the Sages established the measure of inebriation in four receptacles, each containing a quarter log of undiluted wine, which constitute four cups.86Of wine diluted in the customary manner. If a person drank one cup, which is a quarter log, one-quarter of his knowledge has departed. If he drank two cups, two portions of his knowledge have departed. If he drank three cups, three portions of his knowledge have departed, and his heart is confused. Immediately, he begins speaking inappropriately. If he drank the fourth cup, all of his knowledge has departed. Both his kidneys have gone mad, his heart is confused, and the tongue ceases. He seeks to speak but cannot. Instead, his tongue is despondent.
This is why they said that a priest who drank a quarter log of wine was disqualified from Temple service, and an Israelite who drank a quarter log of wine was disqualified from serving as a judge. This is to teach you that no good emerges from wine. That is what is written: “From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain: vinegar…” – due to inebriation. Why did the Torah prohibit “anything in which grapes were soaked,” that he would not become inebriated from them? Eating anything that emerges from the grapevine is also prohibited; things from which he would not become inebriated. Why? From here one learns that a person is obligated to distance himself from impropriety, and from anything resembling impropriety, and from anything that resembles anything that resembles it. From here one learns that the Torah established a fence surrounding its matters. There we learned: Be measured in judgment, establish many students, and establish a fence around the Torah (Mishna Avot 1:1).
How does a person establish a fence around his matters, like the Torah did around its matters? It says: “To a woman in her menstrual impurity you shall not approach” (Leviticus 18:19). May one, perhaps, hug her, kiss her, or speak idle matters with her? The verse states: “You shall not approach.” May she, perhaps, sleep with him on the bed clothed? The verse states: “You shall not approach.” May she, perhaps, wash her face and line her eyes, and may he take a cup from her? The verse states: “And one who is afflicted with her menstruation [benidata]…” (Leviticus 15:33), as long as she is afflicted, she shall be ostracized [benidui].87From her husband. From here they said: Any woman who makes herself repulsive during the days of her menstruation, the Sages are pleased with her. But any woman who adorns herself during the days of her menstruation, the Sages are not pleased with her.
It says: “Any man shall not approach his kin [to uncover nakedness]” (Leviticus 18:6). From here they said: A man may not enter into seclusion with any women at an inn, even with his sister, even with his daughter, and even with his mother-in-law, due to the [potential] allegations of the people [there]. One may not converse with a woman in the marketplace, even with one’s wife, and it goes without saying with another woman, due to the allegations of the people. Here, it is stated regarding his kin: “You shall not approach [tikrevu], and elsewhere it says: “You shall not approach [tikrav]” (Leviticus 18:19) – to a matter that brings one to a matter of transgression, you shall not approach; distance yourself from impropriety and from anything that resembles impropriety. For, so said the Sages: Distance yourself from a minor sin, lest it bring you to a major one; run to fulfill a minor mitzva, as it will bring you to a major one.
“At its end, it bites like a serpent” – just as the serpent, because it incited Eve to drink wine, the earth was cursed because of it, as it is stated: “Cursed is the earth because of you” (Genesis 3:17), likewise, due to wine, one-third of the world was cursed, as it is stated: “Noah awoke from his wine…. He said: Cursed is Canaan” (Genesis 9:24–25). This is Ḥam, who was his third son, and he is called “the father of Canaan” (Genesis 9:18).
Just as this adder sets aside between life and death, so wine sets man aside from the paths of life to the paths of death, as wine causes one to engage in idol worship. That is what is written: “Your eyes will see strange things [zarot]” (Proverbs 23:33), just as it says: “There shall be no strange [zar] god among you” (Psalms 81:10).
Likewise, it says: “He shall not drink anything in which grapes were soaked…from anything that may be derived from the grapevine…” (Number 6:3–4). The Torah established a fence surrounding its matters, that one may not eat and may not drink from anything that is made from the grapevine, so that he will not come to drink. The parable says: ‘Go, go,’ one says to the nazirite, ‘around, around; do not approach the vineyard.’ “From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain,” even if he said only: ‘Behold, I am a nazirite from wine,’ he is a full-fledged nazirite, as we found three matters are prohibited for a nazirite: Drinking wine, shaving hair, and becoming impure due to a dead person. Is one, perhaps, not a nazirite until he abstains from all of them? The verse states: “From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain” – even from one of the three, he is a nazirite. They said: One who says: ‘Behold I am a nazirite from the [grape] seeds, from the [grape] skins, from shaving, from impurity’ is a nazirite, and all the minutiae of the nazirite are incumbent upon him.
Rabbi Yosei HaGelili says: “From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain” – why did the verse repeat “wine and intoxicating drink”? Is wine not intoxicating drink, and is intoxicating drink not wine? Why did it do so? It is because it says: “You shall eat before the Lord your God, in the place that He will choose…the tithe of your grain, [your wine…]” (Deuteronomy 14:23), is it perhaps that even the nazirite is included? How then do I realize: “From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain”? It is with all other types of wine, with the exception of the wine of mitzva. Or, is it even with the wine of mitzva? How, then, do I realize the verse: “You shall eat before the Lord your God, in the place that He will choose…the tithe [of your grain, your wine…]”? It is regarding all other people, with the exception of the nazirite. The verse states: “From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain,” to render the wine of mitzva as wine that is optional.
Rabbi Elazar HaKapar says: “Wine,” this is diluted, “and intoxicating drink,” this is undiluted. Or, perhaps, it is that “wine,” this is undiluted; “and intoxicating drink,” this is diluted? The verse states: “Its libation is wine, one fourth of a hin…” (Leviticus 23:13), “Pour a libation of intoxicating drink […to the Lord]” (Numbers 28:7). You pour libations of undiluted wine, but you do not pour libations with diluted wine. Consequently, you must not say like the second formulation, but rather like the first formulation: “Wine,” this is diluted; “and intoxicating drink,” this is undiluted.
“He shall abstain [yazir]” – nezirut everywhere is nothing other than separation. Likewise, it says: “They shall abstain [veyinazeru] from the sacred items of the children of Israel” (Leviticus 22:2). And it says: “[You shall not…gather] the grapes that you left untended [nezirekha]” (Leviticus 25:5). And it says: “They separated themselves [vayinazeru] from me and turned to the shameful” (Hosea 9:10). And it says: “Shall I weep during the fifth month, abstaining [hinazer]?” (Zechariah 7:3). Consequently, nezirut everywhere is nothing other than separation. “He shall abstain” – do I hear, from his commerce and from his healing? The verse states: “He shall not drink” – drinking is forbidden to him, but his medical needs and his commerce are permitted.88He is allowed to sell wine, and place wine on a wound if necessary.
“Vinegar of wine and vinegar of intoxicating drink he shall not drink,” this tells that it rendered vinegar like wine in this regard, and the vinegar of a mitzva like the wine of a mitzva.89If he took a vow to drink vinegar and then vowed to become a nazirite, he cannot drink the vinegar.
“Anything in which…were soaked” – it tells that if one soaked grapes in water, its status is determined by the flavor.90If the water tastes like wine, it is prohibited for him. From here you expound to all Torah prohibitions: If what is derived from the vine, the prohibition of which is not an eternal prohibition,91The prohibitions of the nazirite are limited in time. At the time of the vow the person determines the amount of time that he will be a nazirite (with a thirty day minimum). and the prohibition of which is not a prohibition against benefit,92A nazirite may not drink wine, but he may benefit from wine. For example, he can sell wine. and there is dissolution of the prohibition,93A nazirite can have his vow abrogated if he has a sufficient reason. it rendered flavor the same as substance; the rest of the Torah prohibitions, prohibitions that are eternal, prohibitions that are prohibitive of benefit, and there is no dissolution of the prohibitions, is it not logical that we would render flavor the same as substance?
“And grapes,” in their plain sense; “fresh” to include the unripe; “or dried, he shall not eat,” to incur liability for this by itself, and for that by itself. From here you expound to all nazirite prohibitions. If, here, where it is one species with two names, one incurs liability for this by itself and for that by itself, so, too, in all cases where there is one species with two names, one incurs liability for this by itself and for that by itself.94If he was warned not to eat grapes and nevertheless ate fresh grapes and dried grapes, he gets punished twice, once for eating fresh grapes and once for eating dried grapes. This comes to include new wine and grapes, that he incurs liability for two.
“From wine and intoxicating drink…” – that is what is written: “Woe, the valiant to drink wine…who vindicate the wicked following a bribe…” (Isaiah 5:22–23). There it is written: “Happy are you, land, that your king is a free man” (Ecclesiastes 10:17). When is the land characterized as happy? It is when its king engages in Torah, as it is stated: “The tablets were the work of God [and the writing was the writing of God, engraved [ḥarut] on the tablets]” (Exodus 32:16) – do not read it as ḥarut, but rather, as ḥerut, freedom, as one is a free man [ben ḥorin] only when one engages in Torah study. “And your princes dine at the proper time” (Ecclesiastes 10:17), as they set fixed times for Torah and they eat thereafter, to realize what is stated: “Go, eat your bread with joy, and drink your wine with a good heart, as God has already accepted your actions” (Ecclesiastes 9:7). That is what is written thereafter: “In valor and not in drunkenness” (Ecclesiastes 10:17), with the valor of Torah, not with the drunkenness of wine. That is why Isaiah said: The valor of Torah is characterized with “happy” (Ecclesiastes 10:17), but the valor of wine is with “woe,” – “woe, the valiant to drink wine” (Isaiah 5:22). Likewise it says: “To whom, woe? To whom, alas…. To those who linger over wine” (Proverbs 23:29–30). “And capable men [anshei ḥayil] to mix intoxicating drink” (Isaiah 5:22). There it is written: “You shall identify from among the people [capable men [anshei ḥayil]]…They shall judge the people…” (Exodus 18:21–22). But these are capable men only to mix intoxicating drink, just as it says: “To those who come to assess the mixture” (Proverbs 23:30). What is “to mix intoxicating drink”? They would mix strong wine with weak wine in order to become inebriated with it. There was an incident involving a group of dissolute men, who would eat and drink until midnight but would not become inebriated. Wine was brought to them; they said mix wine with wine. They did so until the wine entered them. They arose and struck one another in a drunken state. Their cry circulated throughout the city. The constable came, apprehended them, transferred them to the custody of the kingdom, and they were all eliminated. What caused this to befall them? It was the wine that they were drinking. In their regard it is stated: “To those who come to assess the mixture” – the mixture is nothing other than wine mixed with wine. That is, “and capable men to mix intoxicating drink.” On account of this they forget the Torah and corrupt the law, as it is written thereafter: “Who vindicate the wicked following a bribe” (Isaiah 5:23), and it says: “Lest he drink, and forget what was legislated” (Proverbs 31:5) – he will forget the Torah that was given by means of the lawgiver, this is Moses, as it is stated: “As there the lawgiver’s plot is hidden” (Deuteronomy 33:21). What is written? “And subvert justice for all the children of the poor” (Proverbs 31:5).
Wine and knowledge are likened to the Pleiades and Scorpio. Whenever the Pleiades are visible in the sky, Scorpio is not visible in the sky, and when Scorpio is visible, the Pleiades are not visible. So, wine is likened to Scorpio, and knowledge is likened to the Pleiades. Just as the scorpion strikes with its tail, so, wine, strikes in its aftermath, as it is stated: “At its end, it bites like a serpent” (Proverbs 23:32). Just as the Pleiades ripens fruits and provides them with flavor, so, knowledge provides flavor and fragrance to a person’s words. Wine enters, knowledge exits. Any place there is wine, there is no knowledge. Wine enters, a secret emerges; the numerical value of wine [yayin] is seventy84Yod – 10, yod – 10, nun – 50 = 70. and the numerical value of secret [sod] is seventy.85Samekh – 60, vav – 6, dalet – 4 = 70.
Knowledge is divided into four portions; two in the two kidneys, one portion in the mouth, and one portion in the heart. From where is it derived that two portions of wisdom are in the two kidneys? It is as it is stated: “Who set wisdom in obscurity [batuḥot]?” (Job 38:36). These are the kidneys, that are obscured [tuḥot] in the body. And one portion in the heart, as it is stated: “Inform me of wisdom in the closed place” (Psalms 51:8). And one portion in the mouth, as it is stated: “My mouth will speak wisdom” (Psalms 49:4). Wisdom was placed in these four receptacles and, corresponding to them, the Sages established the measure of inebriation in four receptacles, each containing a quarter log of undiluted wine, which constitute four cups.86Of wine diluted in the customary manner. If a person drank one cup, which is a quarter log, one-quarter of his knowledge has departed. If he drank two cups, two portions of his knowledge have departed. If he drank three cups, three portions of his knowledge have departed, and his heart is confused. Immediately, he begins speaking inappropriately. If he drank the fourth cup, all of his knowledge has departed. Both his kidneys have gone mad, his heart is confused, and the tongue ceases. He seeks to speak but cannot. Instead, his tongue is despondent.
This is why they said that a priest who drank a quarter log of wine was disqualified from Temple service, and an Israelite who drank a quarter log of wine was disqualified from serving as a judge. This is to teach you that no good emerges from wine. That is what is written: “From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain: vinegar…” – due to inebriation. Why did the Torah prohibit “anything in which grapes were soaked,” that he would not become inebriated from them? Eating anything that emerges from the grapevine is also prohibited; things from which he would not become inebriated. Why? From here one learns that a person is obligated to distance himself from impropriety, and from anything resembling impropriety, and from anything that resembles anything that resembles it. From here one learns that the Torah established a fence surrounding its matters. There we learned: Be measured in judgment, establish many students, and establish a fence around the Torah (Mishna Avot 1:1).
How does a person establish a fence around his matters, like the Torah did around its matters? It says: “To a woman in her menstrual impurity you shall not approach” (Leviticus 18:19). May one, perhaps, hug her, kiss her, or speak idle matters with her? The verse states: “You shall not approach.” May she, perhaps, sleep with him on the bed clothed? The verse states: “You shall not approach.” May she, perhaps, wash her face and line her eyes, and may he take a cup from her? The verse states: “And one who is afflicted with her menstruation [benidata]…” (Leviticus 15:33), as long as she is afflicted, she shall be ostracized [benidui].87From her husband. From here they said: Any woman who makes herself repulsive during the days of her menstruation, the Sages are pleased with her. But any woman who adorns herself during the days of her menstruation, the Sages are not pleased with her.
It says: “Any man shall not approach his kin [to uncover nakedness]” (Leviticus 18:6). From here they said: A man may not enter into seclusion with any women at an inn, even with his sister, even with his daughter, and even with his mother-in-law, due to the [potential] allegations of the people [there]. One may not converse with a woman in the marketplace, even with one’s wife, and it goes without saying with another woman, due to the allegations of the people. Here, it is stated regarding his kin: “You shall not approach [tikrevu], and elsewhere it says: “You shall not approach [tikrav]” (Leviticus 18:19) – to a matter that brings one to a matter of transgression, you shall not approach; distance yourself from impropriety and from anything that resembles impropriety. For, so said the Sages: Distance yourself from a minor sin, lest it bring you to a major one; run to fulfill a minor mitzva, as it will bring you to a major one.
“At its end, it bites like a serpent” – just as the serpent, because it incited Eve to drink wine, the earth was cursed because of it, as it is stated: “Cursed is the earth because of you” (Genesis 3:17), likewise, due to wine, one-third of the world was cursed, as it is stated: “Noah awoke from his wine…. He said: Cursed is Canaan” (Genesis 9:24–25). This is Ḥam, who was his third son, and he is called “the father of Canaan” (Genesis 9:18).
Just as this adder sets aside between life and death, so wine sets man aside from the paths of life to the paths of death, as wine causes one to engage in idol worship. That is what is written: “Your eyes will see strange things [zarot]” (Proverbs 23:33), just as it says: “There shall be no strange [zar] god among you” (Psalms 81:10).
Likewise, it says: “He shall not drink anything in which grapes were soaked…from anything that may be derived from the grapevine…” (Number 6:3–4). The Torah established a fence surrounding its matters, that one may not eat and may not drink from anything that is made from the grapevine, so that he will not come to drink. The parable says: ‘Go, go,’ one says to the nazirite, ‘around, around; do not approach the vineyard.’ “From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain,” even if he said only: ‘Behold, I am a nazirite from wine,’ he is a full-fledged nazirite, as we found three matters are prohibited for a nazirite: Drinking wine, shaving hair, and becoming impure due to a dead person. Is one, perhaps, not a nazirite until he abstains from all of them? The verse states: “From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain” – even from one of the three, he is a nazirite. They said: One who says: ‘Behold I am a nazirite from the [grape] seeds, from the [grape] skins, from shaving, from impurity’ is a nazirite, and all the minutiae of the nazirite are incumbent upon him.
Rabbi Yosei HaGelili says: “From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain” – why did the verse repeat “wine and intoxicating drink”? Is wine not intoxicating drink, and is intoxicating drink not wine? Why did it do so? It is because it says: “You shall eat before the Lord your God, in the place that He will choose…the tithe of your grain, [your wine…]” (Deuteronomy 14:23), is it perhaps that even the nazirite is included? How then do I realize: “From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain”? It is with all other types of wine, with the exception of the wine of mitzva. Or, is it even with the wine of mitzva? How, then, do I realize the verse: “You shall eat before the Lord your God, in the place that He will choose…the tithe [of your grain, your wine…]”? It is regarding all other people, with the exception of the nazirite. The verse states: “From wine and intoxicating drink he shall abstain,” to render the wine of mitzva as wine that is optional.
Rabbi Elazar HaKapar says: “Wine,” this is diluted, “and intoxicating drink,” this is undiluted. Or, perhaps, it is that “wine,” this is undiluted; “and intoxicating drink,” this is diluted? The verse states: “Its libation is wine, one fourth of a hin…” (Leviticus 23:13), “Pour a libation of intoxicating drink […to the Lord]” (Numbers 28:7). You pour libations of undiluted wine, but you do not pour libations with diluted wine. Consequently, you must not say like the second formulation, but rather like the first formulation: “Wine,” this is diluted; “and intoxicating drink,” this is undiluted.
“He shall abstain [yazir]” – nezirut everywhere is nothing other than separation. Likewise, it says: “They shall abstain [veyinazeru] from the sacred items of the children of Israel” (Leviticus 22:2). And it says: “[You shall not…gather] the grapes that you left untended [nezirekha]” (Leviticus 25:5). And it says: “They separated themselves [vayinazeru] from me and turned to the shameful” (Hosea 9:10). And it says: “Shall I weep during the fifth month, abstaining [hinazer]?” (Zechariah 7:3). Consequently, nezirut everywhere is nothing other than separation. “He shall abstain” – do I hear, from his commerce and from his healing? The verse states: “He shall not drink” – drinking is forbidden to him, but his medical needs and his commerce are permitted.88He is allowed to sell wine, and place wine on a wound if necessary.
“Vinegar of wine and vinegar of intoxicating drink he shall not drink,” this tells that it rendered vinegar like wine in this regard, and the vinegar of a mitzva like the wine of a mitzva.89If he took a vow to drink vinegar and then vowed to become a nazirite, he cannot drink the vinegar.
“Anything in which…were soaked” – it tells that if one soaked grapes in water, its status is determined by the flavor.90If the water tastes like wine, it is prohibited for him. From here you expound to all Torah prohibitions: If what is derived from the vine, the prohibition of which is not an eternal prohibition,91The prohibitions of the nazirite are limited in time. At the time of the vow the person determines the amount of time that he will be a nazirite (with a thirty day minimum). and the prohibition of which is not a prohibition against benefit,92A nazirite may not drink wine, but he may benefit from wine. For example, he can sell wine. and there is dissolution of the prohibition,93A nazirite can have his vow abrogated if he has a sufficient reason. it rendered flavor the same as substance; the rest of the Torah prohibitions, prohibitions that are eternal, prohibitions that are prohibitive of benefit, and there is no dissolution of the prohibitions, is it not logical that we would render flavor the same as substance?
“And grapes,” in their plain sense; “fresh” to include the unripe; “or dried, he shall not eat,” to incur liability for this by itself, and for that by itself. From here you expound to all nazirite prohibitions. If, here, where it is one species with two names, one incurs liability for this by itself and for that by itself, so, too, in all cases where there is one species with two names, one incurs liability for this by itself and for that by itself.94If he was warned not to eat grapes and nevertheless ate fresh grapes and dried grapes, he gets punished twice, once for eating fresh grapes and once for eating dried grapes. This comes to include new wine and grapes, that he incurs liability for two.