Kommentar zu Kohelet 9:20

To make [all this] clear. And to clarify —

“Everything is as it is for everyone; there is one fate for the righteous and for the wicked, for the good, for the pure and for the impure, for one who sacrifices and for one who does not sacrifice; like the good, so is the sinner; one who takes an oath is like one who is apprehensive of an oath” (Ecclesiastes 9:2).
Rabbi Shimon bar Abba began: “Everything is as it is for everyone; there is one fate for the righteous” – this is Noah, as it is stated: “Noah was a righteous man, he was faultless” (Genesis 6:9). They said that when he emerged from the ark, a lion bit him and injured him, and he was limping. “And for the wicked” – this is Pharaoh. They said that when Pharaoh came to sit on Solomon’s throne, that he took as payment for his daughter’s marriage contract,¹Solomon had married the daughter of Pharaoh (I Kings 3:1). he did not know its mechanism, and a lion bit him and injured him, and he was limping. This one died with a limp, and that one died with a limp; that is: “There is one fate for the righteous and for the wicked.”
“For the good” – this is Moses, as it is stated: “She saw him, that he was good” (Exodus 2:2). Rabbi Meir said: “Good” – that he was circumcised. “And for the pure” – this is Aaron, who was engaged in the purification of Israel. “And for the impure” – these are the scouts who spoke slander about the Land and did not enter the Land. These²Moses and Aaron spoke of the goodness and praise of the Land of Israel, and did not enter it.³Thus, “there is one fate for the righteous and for the wicked.”
“For one who sacrifices” – this is Josiah, as it is written: “Josiah donated to the members of the people…[for the paschal offering]” (II Chronicles 35:7). “And for one who does not sacrifice” – this is Ahab, who abolished offerings from upon the altar.⁴He prevented his subjects from taking offerings to sacrifice in Jerusalem. This one died with arrows, and that one died with arrows.
“Like the good” – this is David, in whose regard it is written: “And of good appearance” (I Samuel 16:12). Rabbi Yitzḥak said: Of good appearance in halakha, as anyone who would see him would remember his learning. “So is the sinner” – this is Nebuchadnezzar, as it is written: “Redeem your sins with charity” (Daniel 4:24). This one built the Temple⁵David laid the foundations of the Temple (see Tanḥuma, Aḥarei 1; Etz Yosef). and ruled for forty years, that one destroyed it and ruled for forty years; that is: “One fate.”
“One who takes an oath” – this is Zedekiah, as it is written: “[He also rebelled against King Nebuchadnezzar,] who had administered an oath to him [by God]” (II Chronicles 36:13). On what [object] did he administer the oath? Rabbi Yosei said: He administered the oath to him on the covenant.⁶The covenant of circumcision. Rabbi said: He administered the oath to him on the altar. “Is like one who is apprehensive of an oath” – this is Samson, as it is stated: “Take an oath to me” (Judges 15:12).⁷The men of Judah sought to bind Samson and deliver him to his enemies, the Philistines. Samson was not afraid of being handed to the Philistines, but sought an oath from the men of Judah that they themselves would not harm him. From the fact that he relied on their oath, it may be derived that Samson viewed taking an oath with the utmost seriousness (Yefei To’ar). This one died with his eyes gouged out, and that one died with his eyes gouged out.
Another matter, “for the righteous” – these are Aaron’s sons. “And for the wicked” – this is the congregation of Koraḥ. These entered to sacrifice in dispute and emerged burned, and the sons of Aaron, who did not enter in dispute, [also] emerged burned; that is what is written: “After the death of the two sons of Aaron…” (Leviticus 16:1).

All this. I clarified and tested.

“For anyone who is joined to any of the living there is hope, as a living dog is better than a dead lion” (Ecclesiastes 9:4).
“For anyone who is joined [yeḥubar],” Rabbi Aḥa said: “Chooses [yivḥar]” is written. Who will choose the good inclination over the evil inclination? These are the righteous. Who will choose the evil inclination over the good inclination? These are the wicked. “To any of the living there is hope” – even those who extended their hands against God’s dwelling⁸Those who aided in the destruction of the Temple. have hope.⁹To avoid Gehenna, if they repented. To resurrect them¹⁰In the revival of the dead. is impossible, as they already extended their hand against God’s dwelling, but to eliminate them is impossible because they already repented. In their regard it says: “They will sleep an eternal slumber” (Jeremiah 51:39). The Rabbis say: The minors among the wicked of the nations, they and the armies of Nebuchadnezzar¹¹Those who were forced to participate in the destruction of the Temple but did not do so willfully, or those who repented (Midrash HaMevoar). are not resurrected, and not judged. In their regard it says: “They will sleep an eternal slumber.” Rabbi Yoḥanan said: Each and every drop that the Holy One blessed be He rained on the Generation of the Flood, He boiled it and then rained it on them, as it is stated: “When they are seared they vanish” (Job 6:17); their searing was for eternity.

That the righteous and the wise and their works are in the hand of God. He helps them and He judges them in order to benefit them in their end.

That the righteous and the wise and their works are in the hand of God. He helps them and He judges them in order to benefit them in their end.

And their works. These are their students, their servants, who follow [in] their ways.

Whether it be love or hate. The rest of mankind neither knows nor perceives what would make them become beloved by the Omnipresent and what causes them to become hated.¹Alternatively, man is unable to comprehend what inspires him to love or to hate. (Metsudas Dovid)

All is before them. Before the righteous and the wise.²Alternatively, all preceded them, i.e., all was decreed before they were born. (Ibn Ezra)

All things come alike to all. All perceive when the occurrence happens to all mankind, and they know that ultimately each person is recompensed according to his ways.

All things come alike to all. All perceive when the occurrence happens to all mankind, and they know that ultimately each person is recompensed according to his ways.

The same fate [awaits]. And [they] know that ultimately everyone, whether righteous or wicked, will die, and they all have one fate in this world. All this they know, but nevertheless, they choose for themselves the proper path, because they know that there is a distinction between them in the World to Come.

The righteous. Such as No’ach.

And the wicked. [Such as] Pharaoh Necho. This one became crippled, and that one [No’ach] became lame.

The good. This is Moshe.³Those who do good with others. (Metsudas Dovid)

And the pure. This is Aharon.⁴Those who have pure thoughts. (Metsudas Dovid)

And the impure. These are the spies;⁵Those who focus on impure thoughts and levity. (Metsudas Dovid) these spoke well in praise of the land of Yisroel, but those spoke derogatorily about it. Neither these entered the land, nor those entered the land, hence, they have the same fate.

To him who brings offerings. This is Yoshiyahu, as it is stated, “And Yoshiyahu offered a sacrifice.”⁶II Divrei Hayomim 35:7. The reading of the text is, “And Yoshiyahu separated” [וירם יאשיהו] instead of “ויזבח יאשיהו.” Rashi apparently did not have our version of the text.

And to him who does not bring offerings. This is Achav, who abolished [Bnei] Yisroel’s festival pilgrimages [to the Beis Hamikdosh]. and that one [Yoshiyahu] was killed by arrows.⁸See I Melochim 22:34-35.

As is with the good man. This is Dovid.

So is it with the sinner. This is Nevuchadnetzar. This one [Dovid] built the Beis Hamikdosh, and that one destroyed it; this one reigned forty years, and that one reigned forty years.

As is with one who swears [easily]. This is Tzidkiyahu, who swore falsely, as it is stated, “And he also rebelled against King Nevuchadnetzar, who had made him swear, etc.”⁹See II Divrei Hayomim 35:23-24.

So is it with the one who fears an oath. This is Shimshon, as it is stated, “And Shimshon said to them, ‘Swear to me, that you, yourselves, will not strike me.’”¹⁰II Divrei Hayomim 36:13. We learn that he was strict in his observance of an oath. This one died after his eyes were gouged out,¹¹Shoftim 15:12. and that one [Tzidkiyahu] died after his eyes were gouged out.¹²See Shoftim 16:21. Therefore—

The hearts of men are filled with evil. For they say that there is no judgment of retribution for the wicked. Everything is attributed to chance, [benefitting] sometimes the righteous, and sometimes the wicked.

And afterwards they join the dead. And they ultimately descend to Gehinnom.

For to him that is joined to all the living, there is hope. For as long as he lives, even if he is wicked and he associates with the wicked, as it is stated, “to all the living,” [including] even the wicked, there is hope that he will repent before his death.¹³See II Melochim 25:7. ¹⁴For the lowliest person, as long as he is alive, can grow spiritually, whereas the wisest and most righteous who are dead cannot. (Metsudas Dovid)

For a live dog is better than a dead lion. And they are both wicked. It was better for Nevuzaradan, who was a wicked slave and became a proselyte, that death did not overtake him sooner than Nevuchadnetzar, his master, who is called a “lion,” as it is stated, “A lion has come up from his thicket,”¹⁵The written text is יבחר [=will choose], to indicate that only those having the ability to choose have hope, but for the dead, being that they are unable to choose, all hope is lost. (Ibn Ezra) and who died in his wickedness, in Gehinnom, while his slave [Nevuzaradan] is in the Garden of Eden. Our Rabbis expounded upon this, that we may butcher a carcass for dogs on Shabbos, but a human corpse, lying in the sun, may not be moved unless one places a child or a loaf on it.

For the living know that they will die. And perhaps they will be mindful of the day of death, and they will repent of their ways, but once they die, they do not know anything,¹⁶Yirmiyahu 4:7. and they no longer earn reward for the actions¹⁷And even if they were to have perception, it is too late for them to repent. (Metsudas Dovid) that they do from their death and onwards, for “whoever toils on the eve of Shabbos will [have what to] eat on Shabbos.”¹⁸Alternatively, ואין להם עוד שכר כי נשכח זכרם means “there is no reward for them, when [= כי] their memory is forgotten,” i.e., when those who die leave no legacy of good deeds for others to follow. However, for the righteous who leave a legacy of good deeds for others to follow [i.e., their memory is not forgotten], there is further reward. (Kehilas Shlomo)

“For the living know that they will die; but the dead do not know anything, and they no longer have a reward, as their memory is forgotten” (Ecclesiastes 9:5).
“For the living know that they will die.” Rabbi Ḥiyya the Great and Rabbi Yonatan were walking before the bier of Rabbi Shimon ben Yosei ben Lakoneya, and Rabbi Yonatan’s garment¹⁴With its ritual fringes. was dragging on the coffin. Rabbi Ḥiyya the Great said to him: ‘My son, lift your garment, so they will not say: Tomorrow they are coming to us, and they are mocking us.’¹⁵The dead should not perceive Rabbi Yonatan as mocking them by allowing his ritual fringes to drape on the bier, while the dead are unable to perform mitzvot. He said to him: ‘Rabbi, is it not written: “But the dead do not know anything”?’ He said to him: ‘My son, Bible, you know; Midrash, you do not know. “For the living know” – these are the righteous, who, even in their death, are called alive. “But the dead do not know anything” – these are the wicked, who, even in their lifetimes, are called dead.
‘From where is it derived that the righteous, even in their death, are called alive? It is as it is stated: “To the land in whose regard I took an oath to Abraham, to Isaac and to Jacob, saying: [I will give it to your descendants]” (Exodus 33:1). He did not say: To the patriarchs, but rather, “to Abraham, to Isaac, and to Jacob.” He said to Moses: Go out and say to them: The oath that I took to them, I have fulfilled, as it is stated: “I will give it to your descendants.” The wicked, even in their lifetimes, are called dead, as it is written: “For I do not desire the death of the dead” (Ezekiel 18:32). Do the dead die? Rather, these are the wicked who, even in their lifetimes, are called dead.’ [Rabbi Yonatan] said to [Rabbi Ḥiyya the Great]: ‘Blessed is he who taught me Midrash.’ [Rabbi Ḥiyya] kissed him on his head.

Also their love. That they loved folly and scorn.

“Even their love, even their hatred and even their envy, have already perished; they will never again have a portion in anything that is done under the sun” (Ecclesiastes 9:6).
“Even their love” – that they had for their idolatry more than for the Holy One blessed be He; “even their hatred” – that they had for the Holy One blessed be He [and they expressed] through their actions; “even their envy [kinatan]” – that they infuriated Him [kinuhu] with their idol worship, as it is stated: “They would infuriate Him with strange gods” (Deuteronomy 32:16). They no longer have a portion in the world.¹⁶The World to Come. But Israel has a portion and an excellent reward, as it is stated: “Go eat your bread joyfully” (Ecclesiastes 9:7).

[Also] their hate. That they hated knowledge.

[Also] their jealousy. That they provoked the Holy One, Blessed Is He, with their [evil] deeds. And a portion they will never again have, etc.,

in anything that is done, etc. The merit of a son or a daughter did not avail those wicked men who worshiped idols, and they have no atonement after death.

Go eat [your bread] in joy. But you, the righteous man, who the Holy One, Blessed Is He, has already accepted your good deeds and who will merit the World to Come, “go, eat [your bread] in joy.”¹⁹See Maseches Avodah Zarah 3a.

“Go, eat your bread joyfully, and drink your wine goodheartedly, as God has already accepted your actions” (Ecclesiastes 9:7).
“Go, eat your bread joyfully.” Rabbi Huna son of Rabbi Aḥa said: When the children take their leave from school,¹⁷To go home and eat their lunch. a Divine Voice emerges and says to them: “Go, eat your bread joyfully,” – your breath¹⁸The words of Torah you have expressed. has been accepted before Me as a pleasing aroma. When Jews take their leave of synagogues and study halls, a Divine Voice emerges and says to them: “Go, eat your bread joyfully” – your prayer has been accepted before Me as a pleasing aroma.
Another matter, “go, eat your bread joyfully” – this is the Torah portion of ḥalla; “and drink your wine goodheartedly” – this is the Torah portion of libations; “as God has already accepted your actions” – this is the entry of the Israelites into the Land, as it is stated: “When you come to the Land” (Numbers 15:2).
Rabbi Azarya in the name of Rabbi Yehuda bar Simon interpreted the verse as regarding Abraham our patriarch. When the Holy One blessed be He said to him: “Take now your son, your only one […and offer him up there as a burnt offering on one of the mountains that I will tell you]” (Genesis 22:2), on the first day, he did not see anything, nor on the second. On the third day, this is what is written in its regard: “He saw the place from afar” (Genesis 22:4). What did he see? He saw a cloud affixed to the mountain. He said: It appears that this is the mountain upon which the Holy One blessed be He said to me to bring up my son Isaac. He said to him: ‘Isaac, my son, do you see what I see?’ [Isaac] said to him: ‘Yes.’ He said to [Isaac]: ‘What do you see?’ [Isaac] said to him: ‘A cloud affixed to the mountain.’ He said to Eliezer and Ishmael, his lads: ‘Do you see anything?’ They said: ‘No.’ He said: ‘Since you do not see anything and the donkey does not see anything, “stay here with the donkey [im haḥamor]” (Genesis 22:5) – a people comparable to a donkey [am domin laḥamor].¹⁹The slaves and children of maidservants are lowly, and in that sense comparable to the donkey. Then he took Isaac and took him up mountains, took him down hills, and took him up to the peak of a particularly high and steep mountain. He built an altar, arranged the arrangement of wood, bound him upon it, and took the knife to slaughter him. Had the angel not come and said to him: “Do not extend your hand to the lad” (Genesis 22:12), he would have already slaughtered him.
When [Isaac] came to his mother, she said to him: ‘Where were you, my son?’ He said to her: ‘Father took me, and took me up mountains, took me down hills, and took me up to a certain mountain. He built an altar, arranged the arrangement of wood, bound me upon it, and took the knife to slaughter me. Had the angel not come and said to him: “Abraham, Abraham, do not extend your hand to the lad,” I would have already been slaughtered.’ When Sarah heard this, she screamed, and did not manage to complete her cry until her soul departed, as it is written: “Abraham came to eulogize Sarah and to weep for her” (Genesis 23:2). From where did he come? He came from Mount Moriah. Rabbi Yehuda ben Rabbi Simon said: Abraham was ruminating in his heart: Perhaps there was a defect in my son and he was not accepted.²⁰He was deemed unfit to be sacrificed as an offering. A Divine Voice emerged and said to him: ‘Abraham, Abraham, “go, eat your bread joyfully…as God has already accepted your actions,” God has accepted your offering.’
Rabbi Mona of Shaab and Rabbi Yehoshua of Sikhnin in the name of Rabbi Levi interpreted the verse as regarding Rosh HaShana and Yom Kippur. This is analogous to a province that owed taxes to the king. The king dispatched a tax collector from the treasury to collect it. [When he was] at a distance of ten mil, the prominent leaders of the province emerged and lauded him, and he forgave one-third for them. At a distance of five mil, the middling ones emerged and lauded him, and he forgave one-third for them. When he neared [and was right outside the province], men, women, and children emerged to greet him, and he forgave it in its entirety. He said, ‘What is past is past, from here onward is a new account.’ So too, on the day before Rosh HaShana, the prominent leaders of the generation fast and the Holy One blessed be He absolves them of one-third of their transgressions, as it is stated: “Yet forgiveness is with You, so You will be feared” (Psalms 130:4). Rabbi Aḥa said: Forgiveness is primed for you from Rosh HaShana, “so You will be feared” – so Your fear will be on Your creations. Those days between Rosh HaShana and Yom Kippur, individuals fast, and the Holy One blessed be He absolves them of another third of their transgressions. On Yom Kippur, all of them fast, and the Holy One blessed be He absolves them of another third of their transgressions. When men, women, and children fast, the Holy One blessed be He forgives them for everything and says: ‘What is past is past, and the new account is from here onward.’ A Divine Voice emerges and says to them: “Go, eat your bread joyfully” – your prayer has already been heard.
Abba Taḥana the Pious was entering his city on Shabbat eve at [just before] nightfall, and his bundle was on his shoulder. He found a particular [individual] afflicted with boils lying at a crossroads. [The man] said to him: ‘Rabbi, perform for me a charitable act and bring me into the city.’ [Abba Taḥana] said: If I put down my bundle, how will I and my family earn a living? But if I abandon the man afflicted with boils, I deserve to lose my life. What did he do? He had the good inclination overcome the evil inclination and he took the man afflicted with boils into the city, and [then] came and took his bundle and entered with the light of the [setting] sun. Everyone was astonished and saying: Is this Abba Taḥana the Pious? He, too, ruminated in his heart and said: Would you say that I desecrated Shabbat? At that moment, the Holy One blessed be He caused the sun to shine, as it is written: “The sun of righteousness will shine for you, who fear My name” (Malachi 3:20). At that moment, he ruminated in his heart and said: Would you say that I will not receive reward?²¹He was concerned that the miracle was reward for his good deed and he would not receive reward in the World to Come. A Divine Voice emerged and said: “Go, eat your bread joyfully, and drink your wine goodheartedly, as God has already accepted your actions.” You will receive your reward.
Another matter, [the verse] “go, eat your bread joyfully,” is speaking of Daniel, the beloved man, as it is stated: “I was still speaking in prayer, and the man Gabriel, whom I had seen in the previous vision, was flying swiftly [mu’af bi’af]” (Daniel 9:21); he flew and flew again. “He explained and spoke with me” (Daniel 9:22). Rabbi Ḥagai said in the name of Rabbi Yitzḥak: Daniel, the beloved man, said: The Holy One blessed be He knows that I finished my prayer and He sent an angel²²Gabriel. and spoke with me, as it is stated: “He explained and spoke with me.” What did he say to me? He said to me: At the beginning of your supplications a word went forth” (Daniel 9:23). He said to me: I issued a decree that the Temple will be rebuilt. I said your request will be fulfilled at the beginning of your supplications, [but did not tell you until now] “because you are beloved,” (Daniel 9:23), for He desired his prayer.²³God desired Daniel’s prayers. Rabbi Shmuel bar Onya [said] in the name of Rabbi Aḥa: Beloved is written here three times, “beloved” (Daniel 9:23), “beloved” (Daniel 10:11), “beloved” (Daniel 10:19). [Gabriel] said to him: You are very beloved. You are beloved to your Creator, you are beloved to His entourage, and you are beloved to His Torah, as it is written: “For from the first day that you set your heart to understand, and to fast before your God, your words have been heard” (Daniel 10:12), your prayer has been heard. A Divine Voice emerged and said to him: “Go, eat your bread joyfully” – your prayer has already been heard.

At all times, let your garments be white. Prepare yourself at all times with good deeds, so that if you die today, you will enter [the Hereafter] in peace. And Shlomo likened this to a man whom the king invited for a day of feast, without setting a date for him. If he is wise or clever, he will immediately launder his garments, bathe, and anoint himself.²⁰Koheles addresses the righteous man to “go eat your bread in joy.” True happiness is achieved by eating “your own” bread that you have labored for, as indicated in Tehillim 128:2, “when you eat the labor of your hands you are praiseworthy and it is well with you.” Also, be satisfied with life’s basic necessities [represented by bread] without getting involved in life’s luxuries. Mesilas Yeshorim in Chapter 15 states, that once food has been swallowed, its memory is forgotten as if it had never existed, and therefore enough black bread will satiate one to the same extent as fattened swans. And similarly [he will do] tomorrow until such time that he will be summoned to the feast, all this time his garments are white²¹According to Targum, ושמן על ראשך refers to a good reputation, i.e., do not lack a good reputation. [=laundered] and he is bathed and anointed. So did our Rabbis expound it in Maseches Shabbos.²²White garments were worn on festive occasions and are symbolic of purity.

“May your garments be white at all times, and may the oil on your head not be lacking” (Ecclesiastes 9:8).
“May your garments be white at all times, and may the oil on your head not be lacking.” If the verse is referring to white garments, how many white garments are there among the nations of the world? And if the verse is referring to oils, how many oils are there among the nations of the world? It is referring only to mitzvot, good deeds, and Torah. Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi stated a parable; to what is this matter analogous? It is to a king who made a feast and invited guests. He said to them: ‘Go bathe and anoint [yourselves], press and launder your garments, and prepare yourselves for the feast.’ But he did not set a time for them when they should come to the feast. The clever among them strolled at the entrance to the king’s palace. They said: ‘Does the king’s palace lack anything?’²⁴Everything can be prepared immediately. The fools among them paid no heed and were not scrupulous regarding the king’s instructions. They said: ‘Ultimately, we will sense when the king’s feast begins. Is there any feast that does not require preparation and [arranging] seating [for the guests] next to each other?’ The plasterer went to his plaster, the potter to his mortar, the blacksmith to his coal, the launderer to his laundry room. Suddenly, the king said: ‘Everyone to the feast.’ They hurried them.²⁵The king’s messengers rushed the guests to the feast (Matnot Kehuna). These came in their glory, and those came in their repulsiveness. The king was pleased with those who were clever, who fulfilled the king’s instructions, and moreover, they brought honor to the king’s palace, but he was angry at the fools who did not fulfill the king’s instructions, and disrespected the king’s palace. The king said: ‘Let those who prepared themselves for the feast come and partake in the king’s feast, and those who did not prepare themselves for the feast will not partake of the king’s feast.’ One might [think] they would take their leave, [but] the king then said: ‘No, but rather these shall recline, eat, and drink, and those shall stand on their feet, be punished, observe, and suffer.’ So it will be in the future;²⁶Those who prepare themselves during their lifetimes will enjoy the benefits of the World to Come, and those who do not, will suffer and wish they had used their lives well. this is what Isaiah said: “Behold, My servants will eat and you will starve; [behold, My servants will drink and you will thirst; behold, My servants will rejoice and you will be ashamed]” (Isaiah 65:13).
Zivetai said in the name of Rabbi Meir: These recline, eat, and drink, and those recline, but do not eat and drink. There is no comparing the suffering of one who stands to the suffering of one who reclines. One who stands and does not eat and does not drink is like a waiter; one who reclines but does not eat, his suffering is exponentially greater and his face turns sallow. This is what the prophet says: “You will return and see the difference between the righteous and the wicked” (Malachi 3:18).
Bar Kappara and Rabbi Yitzḥak bar Kappara said: [This is analogous] to the wife of a royal courier who would adorn herself before her neighbors. Her neighbors said to her: ‘Your husband is not here, before whom are you adorning yourself?’ She said to them: ‘My husband is a sailor. If a favorable breeze will happen his way, he will come and will be standing over my head. Is it not preferable that he see me in my glory, and not in my repulsiveness?’ So too, “may your garments be white at all times” from transgressions, “and may the oil on your head not be lacking,” from mitzvot and good deeds. It is taught: Repent one day before your death (Avot 2:10). His students asked Rabbi Eliezer, they said to him: ‘Rabbi, does a person know when he will die in order to repent?’ He said to them: ‘All the more so, let him repent today, as perhaps, he will die tomorrow. The result is that all his days he is engaged in repentance.’ That is why it is stated: “May your garments be white at all times.”

See [to enjoy] life with the wife you love. See and understand to learn a skill by which to earn a livelihood,²³153a. together with Torah study that you possess.²⁴See Maseches Kiddushin 30b.

“Enjoy life with a woman whom you love all the days of your life of vanity which He has given you under the sun, all the days of your vanity, as that is your portion in life, and in your toil that you toil under the sun” (Ecclesiastes 9:9).
“Enjoy life with a woman whom you love.” Rabbi [Yehuda HaNasi] said in the name of the holy congregation: Acquire for yourself a craft with Torah. What is the reason? “Enjoy life [with a woman]…”²⁷The midrash is interpreting the world “life” to refer to Torah, and the term “woman” to refer to a craft. One should have a craft with which to earn a livelihood, in addition to studying Torah. Why does he call them the holy congregation? It is because Rabbi Yosei ben Meshulam and Rabbi Shimon ben Menaseya, who would divide the day into three, one-third for Torah, one-third for prayer, and one-third for labor, were there. Some say: They would engage in Torah study during the days of winter, and in labor during the days of summer. Rabbi Yitzḥak ben Elazar would call Rabbi Yehoshua son of Rabbi Timi and Rabbi Burki the holy congregation, because they would divide the day into three, one-third for Torah, one-third for prayer, and one-third for labor.
It is taught: It is prohibited for a mourner to marry a woman until thirty days [pass]. Rabbi Yehuda says: Until three consecutive pilgrimage festivals pass, corresponding to the three times that it is written: Life, life, life. In what case is this said? In a case when he has sons; however, if he has no sons, or if he has minor sons, it is permitted due to diminution of procreation and to see to their needs.²⁸The mourner can marry a woman even within thirty days in order to fulfill the mitzva of procreation, or so that his new wife can take care of his young children. There was an incident and the wife of Rabbi Tarfon died, and when the grave was covered, he said to her sister amidst the mourning: ‘Enter my house²⁹Marry me. and raise your sister’s children.’ Even though he married her, he did not engage in conjugal relations until after thirty days. It is taught: It is prohibited for a mourner to go to a house of feasting until thirty days [have passed].
It was taught: The mitzvot incumbent upon a father regarding his son are to circumcise him and to redeem him, and also to teach him Torah, to teach him a trade, and to marry him to a woman. Some say: Also to teach him to swim in a river. To circumcise him, from where [is it derived]? As it is stated: “He that is eight days old shall be circumcised among you, every male” (Genesis 17:12). To redeem him, from where [is it derived]? As it is stated: “And all the first-born of man among your sons you shall redeem” (Exodus 13:13). To teach him Torah, from where [is it derived]? As it is stated: “You shall teach them” (Deuteronomy 11:19). To marry a woman, from where [is it derived]? As it is stated: “Take women and beget sons and daughters and take women for your sons” (Jeremiah 29:6). To teach him to swim in a river, from where [is it derived]? As it is stated: “You shall choose life” (Deuteronomy 30:19).
Anyone who does not have a wife is without goodness, without a helper, without joy, without blessing, without atonement. Without good, from where [is it derived]? [From the verse:] “It is not good for man to be alone” (Genesis 2:18). Without help, from where [is it derived]? [From the verse:] “I will make him a helper alongside him” (Genesis 2:18). Without joy, from where [is it derived]? [From the verse:] “You shall rejoice, you and your household” (Deuteronomy 14:26). Without blessing, from where [is it derived]? [From the verse:] “To place a blessing upon your house” (Ezekiel 44:30). Without atonement, from where [is it derived]? [From the verse:] “And he shall atone for himself and for his household” (Leviticus 16:11). Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi says: Without life as well, as it is stated: “Enjoy life with a woman whom you love.” Without peace, as it is stated: “You are peace and your house is peace” (I Samuel 25:6). Rabbi Ḥiyya bar Gamda said: He is not even a complete person, as it is stated: “He blessed them and He called their name Adam”³⁰The word adam, which is the name of the first man, simply means “person.” (Genesis 5:2) – when the two of them are not as one they are not called Adam. Some say it diminishes the Divine Image, as it is stated: “Because He created man in the image of God” (Genesis 9:6).

For that is your portion in life. If you have done so, your share will be life in this world, by earning a livelihood from the skill, and in the World to Come, because laboring in both [i.e., work and Torah study] causes sin to be forgotten.²⁵Alternatively, אשה refers to one’s soul [=נשמה]. (Alshich)

Whatever you are able to do. The will of your Maker— as long as you have your strength—do.²⁶See Mishnayos Avos 2:2.

“Everything that you are capable of doing with your strength, do, as there is no action, device, knowledge, or wisdom in the grave, where you are going” (Ecclesiastes 9:10).
“Everything that you are capable of doing with your strength” – Rabbi Menaḥama in the name of Rabbi Bon transposes this verse: If you know that “there is no action, device, knowledge, or wisdom in the grave, where you are going,” “everything that you are capable of doing with your strength, do.”
Rabbi Aḥa desired to see the face of Rabbi Alexandri.³¹He had died, and Rabbi Aḥa sought to see him in a dream. He appeared to him in his dream, and showed him two matters: Those executed in Lod,³²A princess was found killed. The Romans blamed the local Jews and the prefect decreed that they should all be killed. Pappos and Luleyanus, who were innocent, took the blame for the murder and were executed, thereby sparing the entire community (Rashi to Ta’anit 18b). there are none closer than their partition.³³The area in which they are located in heaven is among those closest to God. Blessed is He who removed the shame of Luleyanus and Pappos.³⁴The Roman official who executed them was himself executed immediately afterward, as a heavenly sign pointing to the innocence of Luleyanus and Pappos. See Kohelet Rabba 3:17. And happy is he who comes here [to heaven] with his studies in his possession.³⁵One whose studies are in his possession is one who remembers the Torah he has studied.
Zavdi ben Levi desired to see the face of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi. He appeared to him in his dream and showed him people whose faces were uplifted and people whose faces were downcast. [Zavdi ben Levi] said to him: ‘Why is this so?’ He said to him: ‘Those whose faces are uplifted, their studies are in their possession; those whose faces are downcast, their studies are not in their possession.’
Reish Lakish, and some say Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi, desired to see Rabbi Ḥiyya the Great [in a dream]. They said to him: ‘You are not worthy.’³⁶The Jerusalem Talmud (Kilayim 9:3) explains that he had fasted many times in order to see Rabbi Ḥiyya in a dream, and it did not work, whereupon the other Sages said that he was not worthy to see Rabbi Ḥiyya (Etz Yosef). He said to them: ‘Why, have I not toiled in Torah study like him?’ They said to him: ‘You did not teach Torah like him. Moreover, he would travel from place to place.’³⁷Rabbi Ḥiyya would travel in order to teach his Torah to a wider audience. He said to them: ‘Did I not travel?’ They said to him: ‘You traveled to learn, he traveled to teach.’ He observed three hundred fasts and [Rabbi Ḥiyya] appeared to him in his dream. [Rabbi Ḥiyya] said: ‘Someone who is something, who conducts himself as though he is something, it would be preferable for him had he not been created.’³⁸Even if one is accomplished in his Torah studies, if he treats himself with honor, he has thereby abrogated the good he has accomplished (Rabbi David Luria).
Rabbi Asi fasted thirty days in order to see Rabbi Ḥiyya the Great [in a dream] but did not see him. They said to him: ‘You are not worthy.’³⁹And if you do see him, it will be an overpowering experience and you will be adversely affected. He said to them: ‘I will see him, and whatever will be will be.’ He saw his platform, and his eyesight became dim.⁴⁰Rabbi Asi saw the platform on which Rabbi Ḥiyya’s chair rested in heaven and he was blinded by its glow. If you say that Rabbi Assi was not a great man, [the following incident proves that he was:] A certain weaver came before Rabbi Yoḥanan and said: ‘I saw in my dream the sky falling and one of your students supported it with his hand.’ He said: ‘Would you be able to identify him?’ He said: ‘Pass them before me, I will identify him.’ When he reached Rabbi Asi, he said: ‘This is he.’
Rabbi Huna, the Exilarch, said to them:⁴¹He said to the members of his household. ‘When I die, take me up [to be buried] next to Rabbi Ḥiyya the Great.’ When he died, they took him up to the Land of Israel. They said: ‘Rabbi Huna is worthy to be brought here for burial alongside Rabbi Ḥiyya the Great. Who will enter [the burial cave] and place him there?’⁴²They were concerned that whoever would enter the cave might not be worthy to be in the presence of Rabbi Ḥiyya the Great, and might die. Rabbi Ḥagai said: ‘I will take him.’ They said [of Rabbi Ḥagai]: ‘When he was eighteen years old, he was expert in his studies, and he never experienced a seminal emission.’⁴³This was a testament to Rabbi Ḥagai’s greatness. At the time of this incident, however, he was already an old man. They said to him: ‘You are seeking to enter because you are an old man, and if you die there, you do not care about losing your life.’⁴⁴You are volunteering to enter the cave because you do not mind dying now and being interred in the cave alongside Rabbi Ḥiyya the Great and Rabbi Huna. He said to them: ‘Do the following to me. Bring a rope and tie it around my legs. If I emerge, fine. If not, you will pull me out by my legs.’ It was done to him. He entered and found three sitting in judgment:⁴⁵Rabbi Ḥiyya had been buried along with his sons, Ḥizkiya and Yehuda, who were also very righteous. Many commentaries interpret the phrase “three sitting in judgment” non-literally, to mean that the following sentence was written on the wall of the cave. ‘Yehuda, my son, there is no one your equivalent after you. Ḥizkiya, my son, there is no one your equivalent after you. Joseph, son of Israel,⁴⁶This is a reference to the biblical Joseph. there is no one your equivalent after you.’ [Rabbi Ḥagai] lifted his eyes to look. [A voice] said to him: ‘Lower your face.’ He heard the voice of Rabbi Ḥiyya the Great saying to Yehuda his son: ‘My son, make room for Rabbi Huna the Exilarch to be placed alongside me.’ He did not accept upon himself to be placed there; ⁴⁷Rabbi Huna did not want to be buried in between Rabbi Ḥiyya and his son. therefore, his descendants will never cease. [Rabbi Ḥagai] emerged from there eighty years old, and his years were doubled.

For there is neither deed, etc., in the grave. For your merit after you die, and if you did so, you have no reckoning in the grave to worry about. The [text of the] verse is transposed [meaning], “for there is neither deed nor knowledge nor wisdom in the grave for the wicked,²⁷Alternatively, whatever charity and good deeds you are able to do, do them with all your strength. (Targum) nor reckoning for the righteous, when the wicked give an accounting and reckoning, and so is it expounded in the Midrash. And one who interprets it without transposing it, but according to its apparent meaning, interprets ‘חֶשְׁבּוֹן’ as an expression of “thought,” what more can he still do²⁸For them to use as an excuse for their sins. to exempt himself from judgment.²⁹I.e., once one is in the grave, there is nothing more he can think of doing to exempt himself from judgment.

Rabbi Ze’eira desired to see Rabbi Yosei ben Rabbi Ḥanina [in a dream]. He appeared to him. [Rabbi Ze’eira] said to him: ‘Alongside whom are you situated [in heaven]?’ He said: ‘Alongside Rabbi Yoḥanan.’ [Rabbi Ze’eira asked:] ‘And Rabbi Yoḥanan, alongside whom [is he situated]?’ ‘Alongside Rabbi Yonatan ben Amram.’ ‘And Rabbi Yonatan ben Amram, alongside whom?’ ‘Alongside Rabbi Ḥiyya the Great.’ ‘And Rabbi Rabbi Ḥiyya the Great, alongside whom?’ ‘Alongside Rabbi Yoḥanan.’⁴⁸The last exchange is omitted in the portrayal of this dream in Bava Metzia 85b. That version appears to be more accurate, given the next sentence. [Rabbi Ze’eira asked:] ‘But Rabbi Yoḥanan is not alongside Rabbi Ḥiyya?’ [Rabbi Yosei ben Rabbi Ḥanina] said to him: ‘In a place of fiery sparks and burning fires, who can bring the son of Nappaĥa⁴⁹Son of a blacksmith, an appellation for Rabbi Yoḥanan. there?’
When Rabbi Naḥum, the man who was holy of holies, died, they covered the faces of the statues with mats. They said: Let him not see in his death what he did not see in his lifetime.⁵⁰Rabbi Naḥum would not look at statues in his lifetime, which he considered idolatrous or semi-idolatrous, and they did not want him to see them as his funeral procession passed by. Is it possible that he would see them [when he was dead]? Rabbi Ashyan said: The difference between the righteous [after death] and the wicked [while alive] is only with regard to speech.⁵¹Even after death, the righteous see and hear what is happening on earth. Rabbi Shimon ben Levi said: The difference between the righteous and us is only with regard to speech. Rabbi Ze’eira said: The dead hears his accolades from inside his bier like a dream. Why was he called Naḥum, the man who was holy of holies? Because he never looked at the image engraved on a coin in his life. Rabbi Ḥiyya said: “Do not turn to false gods” (Leviticus 19:4) – do not turn [to them] to worship them. Rabbi [Yehuda HaNasi] said: Do not turn to see them, in its plain sense. Why was [Rabbi Yehuda haNasi] called our holy Rabbi? Because he never looked at his circumcision in his life. Antalimus⁵²Antoninus. was circumcised. He said to Rabbeinu [Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi]: ‘Look at this circumcision of mine.’⁵³He was proud that he had converted. He said to him: ‘At my own I have never looked, will I look at yours?’

When Rabbi [Yehuda HaNasi] was dying in Tzippori, the residents of Tzippori were saying: ‘Anyone who comes and says that Rabbi died, we will kill him.’ Bar Kappara⁵⁴He was one of Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi’s disciples, and was with him as he died. went to the window and looked outside, and his head was covered and his garments were rent. He said: ‘Our brethren, descendants of Yedaya,⁵⁵Beginning in the Second Temple period, the members of the priestly watch of Yedaya resided in the city of Tzippori. hear me, hear me. Angels and righteous people grasped the Tablets. Angels overcame the righteous, and they snatched the Tablets.’⁵⁶This was his way of saying that Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi’s soul had ascended to heaven. They said to him: ‘Has Rabbi died?’ He said to them: ‘You said so, I did not say so.’ Why did he not say? Because it is written: “One who utters a negative report is a fool” (Proverbs 10:18). They rent their garments until the sound of the rending reached Gufteta, at a distance of three mil. It was read in his regard:⁵⁷Regarding bar Kappara. “The advantage of knowledge is that wisdom [preserves the life of its possessors]” (Ecclesiastes 7:12).
Rabbi Neḥemya [said] in the name of Rabbi Mona: Miraculous acts were performed on that day. It was Friday and all the cities gathered for Rabbi’s eulogy. They stopped his [burial procession to eulogize him] at eighteen synagogues and took him to Beit She’arim,⁵⁸That was Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi’s home. Several years earlier he had taken ill and he moved to Tzippori. and the day lasted until each and every one of the people of Israel reached home and kindled a lamp for himself, roasted a fish for himself, filled a barrel of water for himself, until the last of them did so; [then] the sun set and the rooster crowed.⁵⁹The rooster crowed signifying daybreak, which came just after sunset because sunset had been miraculously delayed for so long. [The people] began to become agitated and said: ‘Alas, we have desecrated Shabbat!’ A Divine Voice called out and said: ‘Anyone who was not indolent in the eulogy of Rabbi is destined for life in the World to Come except for the launderer, who was there, but did not come.⁶⁰He was in the town but did not come to the funeral. When [the launderer] heard [this], he ascended and cast himself from the roof, and he fell and died. A Divine Voice called out and said: Even the launderer is destined for life in the World to Come. Yerushalmi Gittin, Ketubot, and Avoda Zara, all the incidents involving the pious>.

Again I saw. Like ‘זָכוֹר’[=remebering continually], wedant in O.F.

“I again saw under the sun that the race is not to the swift, and the war is not to the valiant; also bread is not to the wise, and also wealth is not to the clever, and also favor is not to the knowledgeable, but rather, time and chance befalls them all” (Ecclesiastes 9:11).
“That the race is not to the swift” – this is Jacob our patriarch; yesterday: “Jacob lifted his feet [and went to the land of the children of the east]” (Genesis 29:1), and today it is written: “He gathered his feet onto the bed [and expired]” (Genesis 49:33). “And the war is not to the valiant” – this is Jacob; yesterday, “he rolled the stone off the mouth of the well” (Genesis 29:10), and Rabbi Yoḥanan said: Like a person removing the stopper from the mouth of a flask,⁶¹This demonstrates Jacob’s great strength, as the stone was heavy enough that generally multiple people had to lift it together (see Genesis 29:8). and today, “the sons of Israel transported Jacob their father” (Genesis 46:5), his body, and he could not be carried even [sitting] in a litter.⁶²Jacob was so weak that his sons had to carry him themselves as they traveled.
“Also bread is not to the wise” – this is Jacob; yesterday, “Jacob sacrificed an offering on the mountain…[and called his brethren to eat bread] and they ate bread” (Genesis 31:54). Were they his brethren? He had one brother, and if only he had buried him.⁶³His only brother, Esau, wanted to kill him; it would have been better for Jacob had Esau died. Were they not his sons? Rather, once they reached his shoulders he likened them to himself and called them brethren. Today, “Return and purchase a little food for us…” (Genesis 43:2).⁶⁴Jacob asked his sons to return to Egypt to purchase food. Instead of him providing for them, he asked them to provide food for him.
“And also wealth is not to the clever” – this is Jacob; “the man became exceedingly prosperous [vayifrotz]” (Genesis 30:43). Rabbi Simon teaches in the name of Rabbi Shimon that he had a microcosm of the World to Come, as it is stated: “The one who breaks through [haporetz] will have ascended before them” (Micah 2:13).⁶⁵Just as the Messiah, the subject of that verse, will break the laws of nature, God broke the laws of nature in causing Jacob’s flocks to multiply in order to grant him wealth. But today, “Joseph sustained his father and his brothers…” (Genesis 47:12).
“And also favor is not to the knowledgeable” – this is Jacob. Yesterday, “I know my son, I know” (Genesis 48:19). I know about the incident of Judah and Tamar, the incident of Reuben and Bilha. If the matters that were not revealed to you, were revealed to me, the matters that were revealed to you, all the more so. But today, he said to him: “If I have found favor in your eyes…do not bury me in Egypt (Genesis 47:29).⁶⁶Jacob was more knowledgeable than Joseph, as indicated in Genesis 48:19, yet he had to ask for Joseph’s favor so that he could be buried in the land of Israel.
Another matter, “the race is not to the swift” – this is Asael, as it is stated: “Asael was light on his feet, like one of the antelopes…” (II Samuel 2:18). How was his lightness manifest? He would run over the awns of the stalks and they would not break. Yesterday, “Asael was light on his feet,” and today, “Avner struck him with the back of the spear” (II Samuel 2:23).
“And the war is not to the valiant” – this is Avner, as it is written: “Are you not a man? Who is your equal in Israel…” (I Samuel 26:15). As Rabbi Asi said in the name of Rabbi Yoḥanan: It is easier for a person to move a six-cubit-wide wall than one of Avner’s legs; but today, “shall Avner die the death of a scoundrel?” (II Samuel 3:33).⁶⁷David said this after Yoav tricked Avner and killed him.
“Also bread is not to the wise” – this is Solomon. Yesterday, “Solomon’s daily provision was thirty kor of fine flour and sixty kor of flour” (I Kings 5:2), and it is written: “Ten fattened bulls…” (I Kings 5:3). Rabbi Yoḥanan said: Likewise, each and every day, and likewise each and every one of his wives would prepare a meal for him, under the impression that he would dine with her. But today, “this was my portion from all my toil” (Ecclesiastes 2:10). There is one who says: [All he had was] his bowl, there is one who says: [All he had was] his walking stick, and there is one who says: [All he had was] his belt.⁶⁸This is an allusion to the midrash (Kohelet Rabba 2:10) that Solomon was displaced from his throne and made to wander as a commoner with almost nothing.
“And also wealth is not to the clever” – this is Job. Yesterday, “his livestock was seven thousand sheep…” (Job 1:3), “and his livestock spread [paratz] in the land” (Job 1:10). Rabbi Yosei ben Rabbi Ḥanina said: He breached [paratz] the boundaries of the world. Everywhere, the way of the world is that wolves kill the goats; however, with Job, the goats would kill the wolves. But today, “pity me, pity me, you are my friends…” (Job 19:21).
“And also favor is not to the knowledgeable” – this is Joshua. Rabbi Aḥva son of Rabbi Zeira said: There are two matters that Joshua spoke before Moses, but they did not find favor in his eyes, and these are: One regarding the appointment of the elders, and one in the incident of the [Golden] Calf. In the appointment of the elders, as it is written: “My lord Moses, incarcerate them [kela’em]” (Numbers 11:28); he said to him: Put an end to them [kalem] and remove them from the world. “Moses said to him: Are you zealous on my behalf?” (Numbers 11:29). [Moses] said to him: ‘Joshua, am I jealous of you?⁶⁹According to rabbinic tradition, Joshua’s statement to Moses about two elders, Eldad and Medad, was made after the latter prophesied that Moses would die and Joshua would lead the nation in the land of Israel (Sanhedrin 17a). That is the backdrop of this midrash, in which Joshua demanded that these elders be punished for their lack of respect toward Moses, and Moses responded that he was not insulted by their prophecy (Rabbi David Luria). If only my son could be like you, if only all Israel could be like you, “would that all the people of the Lord would be prophets” (Numbers 11:29).’
And one regarding the [Golden] Calf, as it is stated: “Joshua heard the sound of the people in their uproar [and he said to Moses: There is a sound of war in the camp]” (Exodus 32:17). Moses said to him: ‘A person who is destined to assert authority over six hundred thousand [men] does not know to distinguish between one sound and another sound? “It is not the sound of a cry of strength [gevura]” (Exodus 32:18),’ as it is stated: “Israel prevailed [vegavar]” (Exodus 17:11); ‘“and it is not the sound of a cry of weakness” (Exodus 32:18),’ as it is stated: “Joshua weakened [Amalek]” (Exodus 17:13); ‘“the sound of a cry, I hear” (Exodus 32:18).’ Rabbi Asi said: It is the sound of praise of idol worship, I hear. Rabbi Yudan said in the name of Rabbi Asi: You do not have any generation that did not take one ounce of the calf.⁷⁰The punishment for this sin is distributed over all the generations.

The race is not to the swift. Isohel’s swiftness³⁰See II Shmuel 2:18. did not avail him when his time [to die] arrived.³¹His swiftness allowed him to catch up with Avneir, who killed him. See II Shmuel 2:23.

Another matter, “that the race is not to the swift” – this is Moses; yesterday he flew to the sky and ascended like a bird, as it is stated: “Moses ascended to God” (Exodus 19:3), but today, “as you will not be crossing this Jordan” (Deuteronomy 3:27); he was not allowed to cross even a tract of fifty cubits.
“And the war is not to the valiant” – this is Moses. Yesterday, “The kings of hosts flee again and again” (Psalms 68:13). What is “again and again”? They flee on the way there, and flee on the way back.⁷¹At the giving of the Torah, the angels flew back and forth in fear while Moses stood calmly on the mountain. Rabbi Yudan said in the name of Rabbi Aivu: Ministering angels is not written here, but rather kings of hosts; even the kings of the angels, Mikhael and Gavriel, were afraid of Moses. Now, he is unable to look at even the weakest soldiers; that is what is written: “For I was terrified due to the wrath and the fury” (Deuteronomy 9:19).
“Also bread is not to the wise” – this is Moses. Yesterday, he became a minister and an official in Pharaoh’s palace, as it is stated: “Moses was grown up, and he went out to his brethren” (Exodus 2:11). What is [the meaning of the statement that Moses] “was grown up”? It was that his greatness was to bring in and to take out.⁷²He was in charge of providing food for Pharaoh’s household. But today, “call him and let him eat bread” (Exodus 2:20).
“And also wealth is not to the clever” – this is Moses. From where did the wealth come to him, such that he became wealthy? Rabbi Ḥanin said: The Holy One blessed be He revealed to him a sapphire quarry inside his tent and he found it. It is from there that Moses became wealthy, as it is stated: “Carve for yourself [pesol lekha]” (Exodus 34:1); its residue [pesilatan] shall be for you. But today, none of that wealth remains.
“And also favor is not to the knowledgeable” – this is Moses. Yesterday, “as you have found favor in my eyes” (Exodus 33:17), and today, “do not continue to speak to Me anymore about this matter” (Deuteronomy 3:26).
“But rather, time and chance [vafega] befalls them all.” It is time that harms the person and undermines him in all these matters, and he is injured [mafgia]. What shall he do? He shall go and engage in prayer and supplication, and he will be saved. Rav Huna asked Shmuel, he said to him: ‘What is this that is written: “But rather time and chance [vafega]”?’ [Shmuel] said to him: ‘At times a person entreats in prayer and is answered, at times he entreats and is not answered, as you have no one who arranged prayers and supplications more than Moses our master, and ultimately it was stated to him: “Behold, your days to die are approaching” (Deuteronomy 31:14).’⁷³Moses prayed many times, and intensely, that he be permitted to enter the land of Israel, yet he died without being allowed to do so.

Nor the battle to the strong. Avner’s might did not avail him when his day [to die] arrived.

Nor does bread [come] to the wise. For example, I, whose daily bread was “thirty kor of fine flour, etc.,”³²I Melochim 5:2. and now, “this [was] my portion [reward] from all my labor,”³³Above 2:10. Being wise is no guarantee for having food. Metsudas Dovid) my staff and my cup.

Nor riches to men of understanding. Such as Iyov. In the beginning, “His livestock consisted of, etc.,”³⁴Iyov 1:3. But when his time came, he said, “Have pity on me, you, my friends.”³⁵Ibid. 19:21. Alternatively, this phrase is connected with the preceding one. The reason that bread does not come to the wise is because wealth is not bestowed upon men of understanding, for if it were, they would share their wealth and provide the wise with bread so they would not lack anything. (Hafla’ah)

Nor favor to the learned. Referring to Moshe; there was no one more knowledgeable or wiser than he in Yisroel, and yet he did not find favor with his prayer to enter the land [of Yisroel].³⁶Alternatively, knowledge does not always earn only the acclaim of his fellow man.

For time and chance. [To be interpreted] as its apparent meaning.³⁷Alternatively, “for time and death [=פגע] happen to them all.” (Metsudas Tzion) Another explanation: “For time” will befall them, and to entreaty and supplication they should be accustomed, that these things should not befall them.

As fish that are caught in a weak net. Like large fish that are caught in an inferior and weak net, and our Rabbis explained: This is a fishhook, which is no more than a type of needle, by which a large fish is caught.

“For man too does not know his time; like fish that are caught in an evil trap, and like birds that are caught in the snare, so the sons of man are snared at an evil time, when it falls upon them suddenly” (Ecclesiastes 9:12).
“For man too does not know his time; like fish that are caught in an evil trap” – Rabbi Berekhya said: Is there an evil trap and a good trap? Reish Lakish said: This is a fish hook. That is what is written: “The people who spread the evil slander about the Land died [in the plague]” (Numbers 14:37). With what were they killed? The Rabbis and Rabbi Shimon bar Yoḥai, the Rabbis said: Diphtheria rose in their throats and they choked and died. Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai said: They died of their limbs falling off.⁷⁴This was the result of leprosy, one of the punishments for slander. Rabbi Yehuda ben Rabbi Simon said the reason of the Rabbis: “Evil trap” is stated here, and “evil” is written there; just as in the “evil” written here, the fish hook goes down into the throat of the fish and chokes it, so, too, the “evil” that is written there means that diphtheria rose in their throats and they died. Rabbi Berekhya said the reason of Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai: “Plague” is stated here, and plague is stated there: “This will be the plague” (Zechariah 14:12). Just as the plague stated there is with the falling off of limbs, so, too, the plague stated here is with the falling off of limbs.
Rabbi Berekhya said: You have a trap that traps in the sea and does not trap on dry land, [and there is a trap that] traps on dry land and does not trap in the sea.⁷⁵Yet, the term “evil trap” implies that it is effective both on land and at sea (Matnot Kehuna). Rather, this a hook that traps in the sea and traps on dry land, as it goes down into the throat of the fish and chokes it.⁷⁶It can also be used with bait on dry land to trap birds and animals. Rabbi Azarya and Rabbi Yonatan ben Rabbi Ḥagai [said] in the name of Rabbi Yitzḥak bar Maryon, in the name of Rabbi Ḥanina: You have a [type of] person who sins on earth but does not sin in Heaven,⁷⁷He sins in the area of interpersonal relations but not in ritual matters. [and there is a type of person who sins] in Heaven but does not sin on earth.⁷⁸He sins toward God, in ritual matters, but does not sin in the areas of interpersonal relations. However, one who speaks evil speech sins in Heaven and on earth, as it is stated: “They set their mouth against Heaven; their tongue walks across the land” (Psalms 73:9). Rabbi Elazar said: We find that they walk in Heaven,⁷⁹They boast as though the walk in Heaven. but their tongue walks on the earth. What is the reason that “they set their mouth against Heaven?” [It is because] “their tongue walks across the land.” Rabbi Yoḥanan said: A person speaks evil speech only after he denies the fundamental belief in God, as it is stated: “Who have said: With our tongue we will prevail; our lips are our own. [Who is master over us?]” (Psalms 12:5). Rabbi Yitzḥak said: “Ponder this well, you who have forgotten God” (Psalms 50:22) – these are they who speak evil speech, as it is stated: “Who have said: With our tongue we will prevail; our lips are our own. [Who is master over us?]” (Psalms 12:5).

Like them, [men] are snared. With a small and weak trap, like the weak net and the snare. People stumble at the time of the visitation of their evil, when their time comes for evil to fall upon them suddenly, in an inferior trap, malweise in O.F.

Like them. Like them.

“This, too, I have seen as wisdom under the sun; and it is great to me” (Ecclesiastes 9:13).
“This, too, I have seen as wisdom under the sun…” Rabbi Shmuel bar Imi said: This is the thinking of the deceitful in their deceit, such as one who mixes water into wine, glaucium oil into [olive] oil, spring water into honey, donkey milk into balsam oil, sap into myrrh, vine leaves into pepper. One may not make a scale rod long on this side and short on that side; an instrument for leveling grain that is thick on this side and thin on that side; a scale rod or instrument for leveling that has a receptacle for metal;⁸⁰A hidden receptacle within the instrument into which would be inserted metal, in order to change measurements and cheat customers. a rod that has a receptacle for money;⁸¹A rod used by porters or peddlers on which they would balance their loads. It could be partially hollowed out to allow the insertion of money, and then the worker could claim he had not yet been paid. the cane of a poor person with a receptacle for water;⁸²He could then claim to passersby that he does not even have any food or water with him, and they would thereby be more likely to take pity on him. or a rod with a receptacle for a mezuza and a pearl⁸³Concealing these items in order to avoid paying tax. – all these are ritually impure.⁸⁴Beyond the fact that they involve deceit, because they have a hidden receptacle, they are susceptible to ritual impurity. Wooden vessels that do not have a receptacle are not susceptible to ritual impurity.
Regarding all of them, Rabbi Yoḥanan said: Woe is me if I discuss [them], and woe is me if I do not discuss [them]. If I discuss them, I am teaching the swindlers [new techniques for swindling]. If I do not discuss [them], I am withholding knowledge and causing that which is ritually pure to become impure.⁸⁵If people do not know that these objects are susceptible to impurity, they will not know when they become impure, and will continue using them in that state, and could render impure other items which are ritually pure. Alternatively, [I should discuss them] so the swindlers will not think that the Sages are not well-versed in their actions. Rabbi Shmuel said: Nevertheless,⁸⁶Despite the potential dangers. “For the ways of the Lord are upright; the righteous will follow them and sinners will falter in them” (Hosea 14:10).⁸⁷This teaches that the truth must be stated, even if it will cause sinners to commit more transgressions.

“There was a small city, and few men in it, and a great king came against it and surrounded it, and built a great siege upon it” (Ecclesiastes 9:14).
“There was a small city” – this is the world, “and few men in it” – this is the generation of Enosh and the generation of the Flood, “and a great king came against it and surrounded it” – this is the King of kings the Holy One blessed be He, “and built a great siege upon it” – with ambush and subterfuge.

Yet no person remembered. No one attributed any importance to him.

“He found in it a poor, wise man, and he saved the city in his wisdom; but no one remembered that poor man” (Ecclesiastes 9:15).
“He found in it a poor, wise man, – this is Noah, as it is stated: “For I have seen you righteous before Me in this generation” (Genesis 7:1). “And he saved the city in his wisdom” – as he would say to them: ‘Alas, empty ones, the flood is coming tomorrow; repent!’ ⁸⁸Noah said to the people of his generation, attempting to save them. They would say to him: ‘If calamity will begin, it will begin from the house of that man.’⁸⁹This is a reference to Noah. When Methuselah died they said to him: ‘Is it not from the house of that man that the calamity began?’⁹⁰Methuselah, a righteous man, died just seven days before the beginning of the Flood. Noah was a direct descendant of his and mourned his death. “But no one remembered that poor man” – the Holy One blessed be He said to them: You did not remember him; I remember him, as it is stated: “The Lord remembered Noah…” (Genesis 8:1).

Another matter, “There was a small city” – this is Egypt, “and few men in it” – these are the Egyptians, “and a great king came against it and surrounded it” – this is the wicked Pharaoh,⁹¹Pharaoh was a wicked king who did not act in the best interest of his subjects. “and built a great siege upon it” – with ambush and subterfuge. “He found in it a poor, wise man” – this is Joseph the righteous, “and he saved the city in his wisdom” – as he said to Pharaoh: “Let Pharaoh proceed and let him appoint officials over the land…and let them gather all the food of these good years…” (Genesis 41:34). “But no one remembered that poor man” – the Holy One blessed be He said: You did not remember him; I remember him, as it is stated: “Joseph was the ruler over the land” (Genesis 42:6).

Another matter, “there was a small city” – this is Egypt, “and few men in it” – these are Joseph’s brothers, “and a great king came against it and surrounded it” – this is Joseph, “and built a great siege upon it” – these are the three edicts that he issued: That no slave shall enter Egypt, no person may enter with two donkeys, and no person may enter whose name and his father’s name, and his grandfather’s name, and his grandmother’s name are not documented.⁹²Joseph issued these edicts so that his brothers would have to come to Egypt themselves to procure food, and not send their slaves; so that they would all have to come, instead of sending just some of them; and so that he would be able to identify them (Etz Yosef). “He found in it a poor, wise man” – this is Judah, “and he saved the city in his wisdom” – as he said: “I will guarantee him…” (Genesis 43:9). Moreover, he said to Joseph: “Now please, let your servant remain instead of the lad…” (Genesis 44:33).⁹³Thus, Judah saved the extended family from starvation by convincing Jacob to allow Benjamin to travel to Egypt, and he saved Benjamin from slavery by offering himself as a slave to Joseph instead. “But no one remembered that poor man” – the Holy One blessed be He said: You did not remember him; I remember him, as it is stated: “He sent Judah before him…” (Genesis 46:28).⁹⁴God ensured that Judah would still play a lead role among the brothers when they moved to Egypt.

Another matter, “there was a small city” – this is Egypt, “and few men in it” – these are the Israelites, as it is stated: “With seventy people your ancestors descended to Egypt…” (Deuteronomy 10:22). “And a great king came against it” – this is Pharaoh. “And surrounded it and built a great siege upon it” – as he issued edicts, one harsher than the one before: He prevented them from engaging in marital relations, he pulled their foreskins,⁹⁵He forced the Israelite men to conceal their circumcisions. and had them grow a forelock.⁹⁶This was a hairstyle common among the Egyptians. Pharaoh was trying to force the Israelites to assimilate into Egyptian culture. “He found in it a poor, wise man” – this is Moses, as it is stated: “Moses said: So said the Lord: About midnight…” (Exodus 11:4).⁹⁷God had stated that the plague of the firstborn would take place at midnight. Moses, when warning Pharaoh of the impending plague, said it would take place “about midnight.” This was due to his wisdom, as he reasoned that if the Egyptians would err in calculating exactly when midnight was, they might rationalize that this was not performed by God, or that Moses did not know exactly what God would do (Midrash HaMevoar, based on Berakhot 4a). “And he saved the city in his wisdom” – as he said: “They shall take of the blood…” (Exodus 12:7).⁹⁸By instructing the Israelites as to the performance of the paschal offering, Moses caused them to be saved from the plague of the firstborn. “But no one remembered that poor man”⁹⁹The Israelites complained about Moses in the wilderness and did not take into account that he had saved them in Egypt. – the Holy One blessed be He said: You did not remember him; I remember him, as it is stated: “He remembered the days of old, Moses, His people” (Isaiah 63:11).

Another matter, “there as a small city” – this is Sinai, “and few men in it” – these are the Israelites, “and a great king came against it” – this is the King of kings the Holy One blessed be He, “and surrounded it and built a great siege upon it” – these are the two hundred and forty-eight positive commandments and the three hundred and sixty-five negative commandments. “He found in it a poor, wise man” – this is Moses, as it is stated: “No hand shall touch it…” (Exodus 19:13), “and he saved the city in his wisdom” – as it is stated: “Anyone who touches the mountain shall be put to death” (Exodus 19:12). “But no one remembered…” – the Holy One blessed be He said: You did not remember him; I remember him, as it is stated: “Remember the Torah of Moses, My servant…” (Malachi 3:22).

Another matter, “a small city” – this is Sinai, “and few men in it” – these are the Israelites, “and a great king came against it” – this is the evil inclination, “and surrounded it and built a great siege upon it” – as it is stated: “This is your god, Israel (Exodus 32:4).¹⁰⁰This was stated regarding the Golden Calf. “He found in it a poor, wise man” – this is Moses, as it is stated: “Lord, why shall Your wrath be enflamed against Your people” (Exodus 32:11). “But no one remembered…” – the Holy One blessed be He said: You did not remember him; I remember him, as it is stated: “He said He would destroy them, were it not for Moses, His chosen one…” (Psalms 106:23).

Another matter, “a small city” – this is a synagogue, “and few men in it” – this is the congregation, “and a great king came against it” – this is the King of kings the Holy One blessed be He, “and surrounded it and built a great siege upon it” – this is ambush and subterfuge.¹⁰¹This is a reference to the possibility that the congregation will act improperly in the synagogue. “He found in it a poor, wise man” – this is the wise elder or the cantor, as when the elder sits and teaches and they repeat after him: ‘Amen, may His great name be blessed,’¹⁰²This is part of the Kaddish recited after communal study of Aggada. even if [the community] has a [heavenly] document of edicts for one hundred years,¹⁰³The community was destined to experience misfortune and suffering for one hundred years. the Holy One blessed be He will forgive all its iniquities. “But no one remembered…” – the Holy One blessed be He said: You did not remember him; I remember him, “you shall rise before the elderly…” (Leviticus 19:32).

Another matter, “a small city” – this is the body, “and few men in it” – these are the limbs, “and a great king came against it” – this is the evil inclination. Why does he call the evil inclination “great”? Because it is thirteen years older than the good inclination.¹⁰⁴A person receives an evil inclination upon birth, and a good inclination only upon reaching the age of bar or bat mitzva. “And surrounded it and built a great siege upon it” – this is ambush and subterfuge. “He found in it a poor, wise man” – this is the good inclination. Why does he call it poor? Because it does not exist in all people, and most people do not heed it. “And he saved the city in his wisdom” – as anyone who heeds it is saved. David said: 'Good for one who heeds it; that is what is written: “Happy is one who attends to the helpless” (Psalms 41:2). “But no one remembered…” – the Holy One blessed be He said: You did not remember it; I remember it, “I will remove the heart of stone from your flesh…” (Ezekiel 36:26).

And [yet] I said. When I saw this, “Wisdom is better than might,” for this one’s wisdom was despised by all, but now, they were all rescued through him.

“I said: Wisdom is better than courage, but the wisdom of the poor man is despised, and his words are not heeded” (Ecclesiastes 9:16).
“I said: Wisdom is better than courage, but the wisdom of the poor man is despised.” Rabbi Yoḥanan said: Was the wisdom of Rabbi Akiva, who was poor, despised? Rather, this is an elder who sits and is impoverished regarding his words,¹⁰⁵One who does not practice what he preaches. such as an elder who sits and teaches: “Do not give preference” (Deuteronomy 16:19), but he gives [preference]; “do not take a bribe” (Deuteronomy 16:19), but he takes [bribes]; do not lend with usury, but he lends [with usury]. Samson followed his eyes, “and he judged Israel for twenty years” (Judges 16:31).¹⁰⁶Samson followed his eyes and married a Philistine woman, despite the fact that the Torah states: “Do not go about after your heart and after your eyes” (Numbers 15:39). Thus, although he judged Israel and exhorted them to follow the Torah, he himself did not practice what he preached. Gideon, as it is stated: “Gideon made it into an ephod [and he displayed it in his city, in Ofra. All Israel strayed after it there]” (Judges 8:27), and he judged Israel.¹⁰⁷He preached against idol worship but his own action ultimately led Israel to engage in idol worship. That is, “poor” is only one who impoverishes his words.

The Midrash Aggadah [expounds as follows]: A small city. This is the body.³⁸See Maseches Nedarim 32b.

With few men within it. These are the limbs of a person.

A mighty king. This is the evil inclination, which all his limbs feel.

A poor [wise] man. This is the good inclination.

Are received with pleasure. They are accepted by mankind.³⁹Alternatively, the words of the wise [spoken] gently are heard, i.e., בנחת [gently] modifies דברי [the spoken words of the wise] as opposed to בנחת נשמעים [=are received with pleasure]. (Metsudas Dovid)

“The words of the wise, softly spoken, are better heard than the cry of a ruler of fools” (Ecclesiastes 9:17).
“The words of the wise, softly spoken, are better heard” – these are the expounders, “than the cry of a ruler of fools” – these are the disseminators who stand before the public.¹⁰⁸In Talmudic times it was customary that when a scholar delivered a public lecture, a disseminator would stand near him and restate his teachings in a loud and melodious voice for the masses to hear. The midrash is saying that the words of the scholar himself (the expounder) are better for those who are able to hear and understand him, than the words of the disseminator are for the masses. Alternatively, “the words of the wise, softly spoken, are better heard” – this is Amram and his court. Rabbi Bon said: They reached a consensus behind the partition or behind the fence;¹⁰⁹In a secret meeting. they said: ‘What good it is that we marry women, beget children, and [the Egyptians] cast them into the Nile? Will the world be sustained in this manner?’ “Than the cry of a ruler of fools” – this is Pharaoh, who decreed: “Every son who is born [you shall cast him into the Nile]” (Exodus 1:22), but it was not adjudged that his decree would be observed.¹¹⁰God did not decree that Pharaoh’s decree would be successfully and fully implemented. Alternatively, it was not in Pharaoh’s power to fully enforce his decree (Matnot Kehuna).

More than the shouts of a ruler of fools. Moshe passed away many years ago, yet his decrees are still accepted by Yisroel, and how many kings of the nations issue decrees over Yisroel, but their words do not endure.

Wisdom is better than weapons of war. The wisdom of Serach, of whom it is stated, “And the woman then went to [all] the people, in her wisdom,”⁴⁰Rashi apparently did not have כל in his version of the text. availed them more than the weapons that were in their hands, to wage war with Yo’av.⁴¹II Shmuel 20:22.

“Wisdom is better than instruments of battle, and one sinner destroys much good” (Ecclesiastes 9:18).
“Wisdom is better than instruments of battle” – this is the wisdom of Jacob; “than instruments of battle” – of Esau the wicked. Rabbi Levi said: He armed them¹¹¹Jacob armed his sons and the other members of his camp. with weapons on the inside and dressed them in white garments on the outside, and he prepared himself for three matters: for prayer, for a gift, and for war. For prayer, from where is it derived? As it is stated: “Please rescue me from the hand of my brother” (Genesis 32:12). For a gift, from where is it derived? As it is stated: “You shall say: From your servant Jacob, it is a gift sent” (Genesis 32:19). For war, from where is it derived? As it is stated: “He placed the maidservants [and their children first, and Leah and her children next, and Rachel and Joseph last.] He passed before them and prostrated himself earthward” (Genesis 33:2–3). He said: It is preferable that he harm me and not my children.¹¹²Thus, Jacob was prepared for the fact that Esau might act violently upon their encounter. “Esau returned on that day on his way to Se’ir” (Genesis 33:16). Why to Se’ir? Rabbi Elazar and Rabbi Shmuel bar Naḥmani, Rabbi Elazar said: It was due to a promissory note.¹¹³The descendants of Isaac were to receiv the Land of Israel and were to be enslaved in Egypt. Esau preferred to forgo the Land of Israel and forgo the enslavement in Egypt. The midrash refers to the coming enslavement as though it were a debt set forth in a promissory note. Rabbi Shmuel said: It was due to shame.¹¹⁴He was ashamed for having sold his birthright. “And one sinner destroys much good” – this is Esau who lost all the goodness and the gifts of the World to Come.

But one sinner destroys a multitude of good. Had she not slain Sheva the son of Bichri, they would all have been destroyed by him.⁴²Alternatively, the wisdom of Yaakov was more effective than Eisav’s weapons. (Midrash)

Another matter, “wisdom is better” – this is the wisdom of Seraḥ bat Asher, “than instruments of battle” – than the instruments of battle of Yoav, as it is stated: “A wise woman called from the city…[say to Yoav: Come close to here]” (II Samuel 20:16) – from here [it is derived] that he was far away. “He approached her, and she said to him” (II Samuel 20:17): You are not Yoav,¹¹⁵Yoav has the connotation of father [av]. you shorten,¹¹⁶You shorten the lives of the people. you do not correspond to your name. You are not a Torah personality and David is not a Torah personality. Is it not written in the Torah: “When you approach a city to wage war against it, you shall call to it for peace” (Deuteronomy 20:10)? Perhaps for war?¹¹⁷Perhaps one might think that the army initiates battle immediately; the aforementioned verse therefore teaches otherwise. [This is] as is written: “She spoke, saying: They should have spoken initially…and the matter would have ended [hetamu]” (II Samuel 20:18). She said to him: ‘Is that all, have the words of the Torah ended [tamu], not to be fulfilled?’ He said to her: ‘Who are you?’ She said to him: ‘Who am I? “I am the loyal [shelumei] faithful of Israel” (II Samuel 20:19), it is I who completed [hishlamti] the tally of Israel in Egypt;¹¹⁸The Torah lists sixty-nine descendants of Jacob who descended to Egypt, and then states that the total number of his descendants who went to Egypt was seventy (see Genesis 46:8–27) The midrash (Bereshit Rabba 94:9) asserts that the seventieth individual was Seraḥ bat Asher. it is I who completed loyalty to Joseph and loyalty to Moses.¹¹⁹She revealed to Moses where Joseph was buried so he could take his bones and bury them in the Land of Israel. “And you are seeking to destroy a metropolitan city [ir ve’em] in Israel” (II Samuel 20:19); ir, this is Avel Beit Maakha,¹²⁰This was the name of the city that Yoav had besieged (see II Samuel 20:15). and me, who is a mother [em] in Israel.’
Immediately, “Yoav answered and said: Far be it from me…” (II Samuel 20:20) – far be it from Yoav, far be it from David, far be it from his kingdom. “The matter is not so. Rather a man from Mount Ephraim, his name is Sheva ben Bikhri, has raised his hand against the king, against David” (II Samuel 20:21). If [he already said] “against the king,” why [did he also say] “against David”; if “against David,” why “against the king”? Rabbi Azarya and Rabbi Yonatan ben Rabbi Ḥagai said in the name of Rabbi Yitzḥak bar Maryon: This is to teach you that anyone who is impudent toward Torah scholars and a spiritual leader of the generation, it is as though he is impudent toward a king; all the more so, David, who was a king, a scholar, and a spiritual leader of the generation. Rabbi Yudan said: Anyone who is impudent toward the king it is as though he is impudent toward the Divine Presence, as it is written: “He raised his hand against the king, against David.” “Against the king” – that is the King of kings, the Holy One blessed be He, and then “against David” – this is David king of Israel.
[Yoav continued] “Turn him, alone, over, and I will go…[the woman said to Yoav: Behold, his head will be thrown to you over the wall]” (II Samuel 20:21). He said to her: ‘How do you know?’ She said to him: ‘Anyone who is impudent to the kingdom of the house of David incurs liability from above.’ Immediately, “the woman came to the people in her wisdom” (II Samuel 20:22). She said to them: ‘Will you not obey Yoav, will you not obey David? What nation has stood against them? What kingdom has stood against them?’ They said to her: ‘What does he demand?’ She said to them: ‘One thousand men.’ They said to her: ‘Each and every person will give in accordance with what he has.’¹²¹Each household will turn over a proportion of its members. She said to them: ‘I will go and appease him, perhaps he will [accept] fewer.’ She feigned going and returning. She said to them: ‘He demands five hundred men.’ They said to her: ‘Each and every person will give in accordance with what he has.’ She said to them: ‘I will go and appeal to him, perhaps he will [accept] fewer.’ She pretended as though she were going and returning. She said to them: ‘He demands one man, and he is a non-resident [of our city].’ They said to her: ‘If he was the best man in the city we would submit him to [Yoav].’ She said to them: ‘His name is Sheva ben Bikhri.’ Immediately, they took the head of Sheva ben Bikhri and cast it over the wall. “And one sinner destroys much good” – this is Sheva ben Bikhri.

Another explanation: But one sinner destroys a multitude of good. If Yisroel were half of righteous people and half of wicked ones, and one person came and sinned and made [the wicked] the majority, the result would be that he weighed them all down to be guilty.⁴³Alternatively, when a wise man becomes a sinner, many people will abandon their pursuit of wisdom by concluding that this person’s wisdom was of no avail. (Metsudas Dovid)

Another explanation: But one sinner destroys a multitude of good. If Yisroel were half of righteous people and half of wicked ones, and one person came and sinned and made [the wicked] the majority, the result would be that he weighed them all down to be guilty.⁴³Alternatively, when a wise man becomes a sinner, many people will abandon their pursuit of wisdom by concluding that this person’s wisdom was of no avail. (Metsudas Dovid)

Another matter, “wisdom is better” – this is the wisdom of Hezekiah king of Judah, “than instruments of battle” – of Sennacherib. Rabbi Levi said: Sennacherib exiled three exiles: The first time, he exiled the tribes of Reuben and Gad; second, [he exiled] the [rest of the] ten tribes; third, he came against [the kingdom of] Judah. Immediately, Hezekiah stood and armed them with weapons on the inside and dressed them in white garments on the outside, and he prepared himself for three matters, for prayer, for a gift, and for war. For prayer, as it is written: “Hezekiah prayed to God…” (Isaiah 37:15). For a gift, as it is written: “At that time Hezekiah stripped the doors of the Sanctuary and the omenot” (II Kings 18:16). What are omenot? Rabbi Levi said hoops, and the Rabbis say hinges. For war, as it is stated: “He made weapons in abundance and shields” (II Chronicles 32:5). He inserted a sword at the entrance of the study hall and said: ‘Anyone who does not engage in Torah study, let this sword pass over his neck.’¹²²Torah study is also comparable to warfare (Etz Yosef; see, e.g., Megilla 15b) and its merit can bring success in war. “Elyakim son of Hilkiya, who was in charge of the palace” (II Kings 18:37) – of the courts and administering punishment, “came, and Shevna the scribe” (II Kings 18:37) – in charge of the officials, “and Yoaḥ son of Asaf the secretary” (II Kings 18:37) – he was the elder of the house. “And one sinner destroys much good” – this is Sennacherib, as it is stated: “He returned in shame [to his land]” (II Chronicles 32:21), “and Esar Ḥadon his son reigned in his stead” (II Kings 19:37).