Jasidut sobre Eclesiastés 5:4

ט֖וֹב אֲשֶׁ֣ר לֹֽא־תִדֹּ֑ר מִשֶׁתִּדּ֖וֹר וְלֹ֥א תְשַׁלֵּֽם׃

Mejor es que no prometas, que no que prometas y no pagues.

Kedushat Levi

The words ‎לא יחל דברו ככל היוצא מפיו יעשה‎, may also be the ‎basis of a halachic ruling concerning the care to be taken ‎when uttering a vow, even when one fully intends to keep it. The ‎Talmud Nedarim 10 illustrates this when discussing the line ‎ימיו כצל עובר‎, “man’s days (lifetime) pass as speedily as a passing ‎shadow.” According to the Talmud there, it is forbidden to use ‎the formula ‎לה' קרבן,"‏‎”, “for the Lord a sacrificial offering,” the ‎reason being that one may die a sudden death before completing ‎the word ‎קרבן‎, in which case one would have concluded one’s life ‎by uttering the name of the Lord in vain. The appropriate ‎formula therefore is: ‎קרבן לה'‏‎, “a sacrificial offering for the Lord.” ‎This is what the Midrash alludes to when commenting on ‎the words ‎איש כי ידור נדר לה'‏‎, i.e. when formulating a vow the word ‎לה'‏‎ should be the last word in the formula. [The ‎‎Midrash quoted was inspired by the words “one must carry ‎out what one has promised” being superfluous, as the Torah ‎already warned us not to profane our word (of honour), ‎Ed.]‎
We find a discussion in Nedarim 9 where Rabbi Meir ‎interprets the advice of Solomon in Kohelet 5,4 ‎טוב שלא ‏תדור משתדר ואינו משלם‎, as meaning: “it is better not to make a ‎vow to donate something to the Temple or to charity, than to ‎make such a vow and then fail to honour it.” Rabbi Yehudah, on ‎the other hand, understands the saying differently, i.e. Solomon ‎making a comparison between two less than ideal situations, but ‎that Solomon would agree that the best way to insure that one ‎pays a promise, is to reinforce it by a vow and to keep the vow. It ‎is possible to understand Rabbi Meir as referring to the ‎formulation of the vow, i.e. to make sure, as the Torah does, that ‎the word ‎לה'‏‎ is at the end of the formulation to avoid possibly ‎uttering the name of the Lord in vain, in case one died suddenly. ‎According to the view of the Torah as expressed in our verse, it is ‎best to avoid making promises which involve invoking the name ‎of the Lord.‎
Preguntar a un rabinoBookmarkShareCopy