Génesis 49:28 Midrash: Midrash Tanchuma, Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Midrash Tehillim & Pesikta Rabbati

(Deut. 33:1:) “And this is the blessing.” This text is related (to Prov. 31:29), “Many daughters have done valiantly, but you surpass them all.” This is the blessing of Moses,¹PRK 31:11. in respect to which you should note that in the case of the earlier generations each and every one blessed his generation, but there was none was like the blessing of Moses. Noah blessed his children, but it contained a divergence, as he blessed one and cursed another, as stated (Gen. 9:27,) “May God enlarge (ypt) Japheth (ypt) [...]; and let Canaan be a slave to them.” Isaac blessed Jacob, but there was strife in it. It is so stated (in Gen. 28:4), “May He give you the blessing of Abraham, but he said to Esau (in Gen. 27:35), “Your brother came with deceit”; and it is stated (in vs. 41), “Then Esau hated Jacob […, and Esau said in his heart, ‘Let the days of mourning for my father come, and I will kill my brother Jacob’].” Jacob blessed the tribes, but there was strife among them, in that he rebuked Reuben, as stated (in Gen. 49:4), “Unstable as water”; and similarly (in vs. 5), “Simeon and Levi [are brothers; weapons of violence are their swords].” And from where did each and every one of the patriarchs learn to bless his generation? [They learned it] from the Holy One, blessed be He. When he created Adam, He blessed him, as stated (in Gen. 1:27-28), “male and female. Then [God] blessed them.” And the world was maintained by that blessing, until the generation of the flood came, and they cancelled it out, as stated (in Gen. 6:7), “And the Lord said, “I will blot out the humanity which I created.” When Noah left the ark, the Holy One, blessed be He, saw that this blessing had passed from them. He blessed Noah and his children anew, as stated (in Gen. 9:1), “Then God blessed Noah and his children.” The world was maintained by this blessing, until Abraham came into the world, and He added blessing, as stated (in Gen. 12:2), “For I will make you into a great nation.” Once Abraham came, the Holy One, blessed be He, said, “It is not honorable for Me, that I should be obliged to bless My creatures. Rather take note! I am handing over the blessings to Abraham and to his seed, so that for all who they issue a blessing, I am placing my seal upon [those blessings], as stated (in vs. 2, cont.), ‘[I will bless you and magnify your name] and so become a blessing.’” (Vs. 3:) “I will bless those who bless you….” What is the meaning of “I will bless?” The Holy One, blessed be He, said, “Take note. I am handing over the blessings to all whom you bless, and I am sealing [them] through you.” But if from then on the blessings were [handed over] to Abraham, why did he not bless Isaac? It was because Abraham saw that Esau would issue from him. He said, “If I bless Isaac, then Esau will be blessed, and Isaac will be found lacking.” A parable: To what is the matter comparable? To the head of a household that had a vineyard,²See Gen. R. 61:6; Numb. R. 11:2; M. Pss. 1:5. [and] gave it to a tenant. And in that vineyard was a tree of life, but it had overgrown a tree having a deadly poison. Now he did not know what to do. He said, “If I cultivate that vineyard, then the tree having a deadly poison will flourish; but if I do not cultivate that vineyard, then the tree of life will die. So what shall I do? I will bear with that vineyard until the owner of the vineyard comes. Then he may do what he wants with his vineyard.” And so also did Abraham say, “If I bless Isaac, Esau will end up being blessed and Jacob will lose out. Rather look here. I will leave him alone until the Holy One, blessed be He, comes, when He will deal with what belongs to Him.” Jacob came and received five blessings: two from his father, one from Abraham, one from the angel, and one from the Holy One, blessed be He.³Cf. Gen. R. 94:5. From his father, as stated (in Gen. 27:33), “Then Isaac trembled (when he realized he had blessed Jacob instead of Esau). Why “trembled?” R. Eliezer ben Pedat said, “[He did so] because he saw Gehinnom open in front of him. He wanted to say, ‘Cursed will be [Jacob.’ Instead,] he went back [on it], and added blessing [to it], when he said (ibid., end), ‘he also shall be blessed.’” Here is one [blessing]. A second (is in Gen. 28:1), “So Isaac called Jacob and blessed him.” The blessing of the Holy One, blessed be He, (is in Gen. 35:9), “Now God appeared unto Jacob [… and blessed him].” The blessing of Abraham (is in Gen. 28:4), “And may He grant you the blessing of Abraham.” And the blessing of an angel is (in Gen. 32:30), “and he (the angel) blessed him there.” When Jacob came to bless the tribes, he blessed them with the five blessings that he had in hand and added one blessing to them, as stated (in Gen. 49:28), “All these are the tribes of Israel, [twelve in number, and this is what their father spoke to them when he blessed them, each one with his own blessing is how he blessed them].”⁴The midrash notes that the words, HE BLESSED THEM, occur twice and interprets the verse to mean that one blessing, the fivefold blessing he had received, was for the tribes as a group while the other blessing was a specific blessing for each tribe. When Moses came to bless Israel, he added a seventh blessing to them. Thus it is stated (in Deut. 33:1), “And this is the blessing.” [According to another interpretation, Moses made] an addition to the blessings with which Balaam had blessed Israel,⁵Cf. PRK 31(suppl. 1):4. since it was fitting for him to bless them with seven blessings corresponding to the seven altars [he had built];⁶On these altars, see Numb. 23:1, 14, 29. but [Balaam] only blessed them with three, as stated (in Numb. 24:10), “but here you have even blessed them these three times.” The Holy One, blessed be He, said to him, “O wicked one, your eye is too jaundiced for you to bless them. Moreover, I am not putting the power in your hand to finish your blessing over Israel. Moses will come, whose eye is fair; then he will bless Israel.” And it is about him that Solomon has said (in Prov. 22:9), “He that has a benevolent eye shall be blessed (ybrk).” Do not read “ybrk [with vowels meaning] shall be blessed,” but [with vowels meaning] “shall bless.” This refers to Moses our master whose eyes were fair when he blessed Israel, such that he blessed them with [the other] four blessings: The first is (in Exod. 39:43), “When Moses saw all the work […] he blessed them.” The second is (in Lev. 9:23), “Then Moses and Aaron came unto the tent of meeting; and when they came out, they blessed the people….” The third is (in Deut. 1:11), “May the Lord God of your ancestors add [to your numbers a thousand times more than you are and bless you].” The fourth is (here in Deut. 33:1), “And this is the blessing.” It is therefore stated (in Prov. 31:29), “Many daughters have done valiantly, but you surpass them all.”(Deut. 33:1:) And this is the blessing.” It was fitting for Moses to bless Israel because he had constantly risked his life for them.⁷PRK 31(suppl. 1):12. For this reason, it is stated (in Deut. 33:1), “And this is the blessing [that Moses blessed... the Children of Israel].” (Deut. 33:1:) “The man of God (the Power).” If it says, “man,” why does it say, “God,” and if it says, “God,” why does it say, “man?” It is simply that at the time he fled from in front of Pharaoh, he was a man, but at the time he trounced [the Egyptians], he was a power. Another interpretation: At the time that he went up to the firmament, he was a man; in front of the angels that were all fire, he was a man. But at the time he came down, he was a power. Before he went up to the firmament, he was a man, as he would eat and drink. But all the time that he was there, he was a power, as stated (in Exod. 34:20), “and they were afraid to approach him.”

(Deut. 33:1:) AND THIS IS THE BLESSING. This text is related (to Prov. 31:29): MANY DAUGHTERS HAVE DONE VALIANTLY, BUT YOU SURPASS THEM ALL. This is the blessing of Moses,¹Tanh., Deut. 11:1; PRK 31:11. in respect to which you should note that in the case of the earlier generations each and every one blessed his generation, but compared to all of them none was like the blessing of Moses. Noah blessed his children, but it contained a divergence. He blessed one and cursed another. (Gen. 9:27:) MAY GOD ENLARGE (YPT) JAPHETH (YPT); but he said (vs. 25:) CURSED BE CANAAN. Isaac blessed Jacob. There was strife in it, in that he said to Esau (in Gen. 27:35): YOUR BROTHER CAME WITH DECEIT; and it is stated (in vs. 41): THEN ESAU HATED JACOB <…, AND ESAU SAID IN HIS HEART: LET THE DAYS OF MORNING FOR MY FATHER COME, AND I WILL KILL MY BROTHER JACOB>. Jacob blessed the tribes, but there was strife among them, in that he said to Reuben (in Gen. 49:4): UNSTABLE AS WATER; and similarly (in vs. 5): SIMEON AND LEVI <ARE BROTHERS; WEAPONS OF VIOLENCE ARE THEIR SWORDS>. And from where did each and every one of the patriarchs learn to bless his generation? [They learned] from the Holy One. When he created Adam, he blessed him, as stated (in Gen. 1:28): THEN GOD BLESSED THEM; [and²The other part of this bracket is several lines below. the world was maintained by that blessing, until the generation of the flood came, and they cancelled it out, as stated (in Gen. 6:7): AND THE LORD SAID: I WILL BLOT OUT THE HUMANITY WHICH I CREATED. When Noah left the ark, the Holy One saw that this blessing had passed from them. He blessed Noah and his children anew, as stated (in Gen. 9:1): THEN GOD BLESSED NOAH AND HIS CHILDREN. The world was maintained by this blessing, until Abraham came into the world. Then the Holy One added one blessing for him, as stated (in Gen. 12:2): FOR I WILL MAKE YOU INTO A GREAT NATION…. When Abraham came, the Holy One said: It is not a practice worthy of me, that I should be obliged to bless my creatures. Rather take note! I am handing over the blessings to Abraham and to his seed, so that for all who issue a blessing through him, I am placing my seal upon <those blessings>, as stated (in vs. 2, cont.): <I WILL BLESS YOU AND MAGNIFY YOUR NAME> AND SO BECOME A BLESSING. (vs. 3:) I WILL BLESS THOSE WHO BLESS YOU…. What is the meaning of I WILL BLESS THOSE WHO BLESS YOU. The Holy One said: Take note. I am handing over the blessings to ALL WHOM YOU BLESS, and I am sealing <them> through you. But if from then on the blessings were {spoken} [handed over] to Abraham, why did he not bless Isaac? It was because Abraham saw that Esau would issue from him. He said: If I bless Isaac, then Esau will be blessed, and Isaac will be found lacking. A parable: To what is the matter comparable? To the head of a household that had a vineyard.³See Gen. R. 61:6; Numb. R. 11:2; M. Pss. 1:5; also Matthew 13:24–30.: He gave it to a tenant. And in that vineyard was a tree of life, but it had overgrown a tree having a deadly poison. Now he did not know what to do. He said: If I cultivate that vineyard, then the tree having a deadly poison will flourish; but if I do not cultivate that vineyard, then the tree of life will die. So what shall I do? I will bear with that vineyard until the owner of the vineyard comes. Then he may do what he wants with his vineyard.⁴Cf. Matthew 13:24–30. And so also did Abraham say: If I bless Isaac, Esau will end up being blessed and Jacob will lose out. Look here. It is simply that he is leaving him alone until the Holy One comes, when he will deal with what belongs to him.] Jacob came and received five blessing: two from his father, one from Abraham, one from the angel, and one from the Holy One.⁵Cf. Gen. R. 94:5.: Two from his father, according to what is stated (in Gen. 27:33): THEN ISAAC TREMBLED (when he realized he had blessed Jacob instead of Esau). Why TREMBLED? R. Eleazar ben Padat said: <He did so> because he saw Gehinnom open for Esau. He wanted to say: Cursed. He repented and added a blessing when he said (ibid., end): HE ALSO SHALL BE BLESSED. Here is one blessing. A second (is in Gen. 28:1): SO ISAAC CALLED JACOB AND BLESSED HIM. [The blessing of Abraham (is in Gen. 28:4): AND MAY HE GRANT YOU THE BLESSING OF ABRAHAM…; the blessing of an angel is (in Gen. 32:30 [29]): AND HE (the angel) BLESSED HIM THERE; and the blessings of the Holy One (in Gen. 35:9): NOW GOD APPEARED UNTO JACOB AGAIN…, AND BLESSED HIM.] When Jacob came to bless the tribes, he blessed them with the five blessing that he had in hand and added one blessing to them, as stated (in Gen. 49:28): ALL THESE ARE THE TRIBES OF ISRAEL, <TWELVE IN NUMBER, AND THIS IS WHAT THEIR FATHER SPOKE TO THEM> WHEN HE BLESSED THEM, EACH ONE WITH HIS OWN BLESSING IS HOW HE BLESSED THEM.⁶The midrash notes that the words, HE BLESSED THEM, occur twice and interprets the verse to mean that one blessing, the fivefold blessing he had received, was for the tribes as a group while the other blessing was a specific blessing for each tribe. When Moses came to bless Israel, he added a seventh blessing to them. Thus it is stated (in Deut. 33:1): AND THIS IS THE BLESSING. < According to another interpretation, Moses made> an addition to the blessings with which Balaam had blessed Israel,⁷Cf. PRK 31(suppl. 1):4 since it was fitting for him to bless with seven blessings corresponding to the seven altars <he had built>;⁸On these altars, see Numb. 23:1, 14, 29. but <Balaam> only blessed them with three, as stated (in Numb. 24:10): BUT HERE YOU HAVE EVEN BLESSED THEM THESE THREE [TIMES]. The Holy One said to him: You are wicked. Your eye is too jaundiced for you to bless them. Moreover, I am not putting the power in your hand to finish your blessing over Israel. Moses will come, whose eye is fair. Then he will bless Israel, and it is about him that Solomon has said (in Prov. 22:9): HE THAT HAS A BENEVOLENT EYE SHALL BE BLESSED (YBRK). Do not read YBRK <with vowels meaning> SHALL BE BLESSED, but <with vowels meaning> SHALL BLESS. This refers to Moses our Master whose eyes were fair when he blessed Israel. He also blessed them with <the other> four blessings:

Another interpretation of “Blessed is the person” (Psalms 1:1): This [relates to] that which is said in the verse: “For the Lord God is a sun and a shield; [God gives grace and glory, and does not withhold good from those who walk with integrity]” (Psalms 84:12). Chezkiah the son of Rabbi Chiyya said, “Blessed are the righteous prophets for they liken the form to He who gives form; and [they liken] the plant to He who plants. Like that which you say, “For the Lord God is a sun and a shield” (Psalm 84:12). And [likewise, Ezekiel] said, “And there, coming from the east with a roar like the roar of mighty waters, was the Presence of the God of Israel, and the earth was lit up by His glory” (Ezekiel 43:2). But [don’t blame the prophets for using these metaphors for describing God because] the ear can only be made to hear what an ear can hear, and an eye can only be shown what an eye can see.” Another interpretation of “For the Lord God is a sun and a shield” (Pslams 84:12). If [you were to say] just as this sun overwhelms [the earth], so too does the Holy One, blessed be He; [the verse continues] to teach us [that, in addition to being like a sun, God is like] “a shield.” Just as a shield protects a person, so too, the Holy One, blessed be He, protects His world. Rabbi Chiyya son of Avin said, “He illuminates [the world] like the sun, and covers [the world] like a shield.” Another interpretation: the shield [in this verse might] refer [only] to a special type of shield called a Persian Targa, which surrounds a person on three sides. So, how do we know to include the fourth side [such that we can rest assured that God protects us from all sides]? [Another verse comes to] teach us: “[For you bless the righteous,] Oh Lord, encompassing them with favour like a shield” (Psalms 5:13). Another interpretation: the sun and the shield allude to Abraham our father. Abraham is likened to the sun, because it is said, “Who raised up one from the east” (Isaiah 41:2). And “shield” [also] alludes to Abraham [because God tells Abraham that He will be his shield], as it is said, “I am a shield to you” (Genesis 15:1). [Even the word] אלוהים [which is a name of God] alludes to Abraham, as it is said, “You are a Prince of אלוהים in our midst” (Genesis 23:6). [Having associated the sun and the shield, and the name אלוהים, with Abraham, we now move on to the next part of Psalms 84:12]: “God gives grace and glory;” this [also] alludes to Abraham, as it is written, “And Abraham was heavily loaded with cattle, silver, and gold” (Genesis 13:2); [the word for heaviness, כבד, in this verse, shares its root with the word for glory כבוד. God] “does not withhold good from those who walk with integrity” (Psalms 84:12), this [also] alludes to Abraham, as it says, “Walk before me, and [do so with] integrity” (Genesis 17:1). But if this Psalm [i.e. Psalm 84] was talking about Abraham, it should have said that [God] “does not withhold good from he who walks with integrity.” Why does it say [in the plural], “those who walk with integrity”? Rather, just as with Abraham, who walked with the Holy One, blessed be He, with integrity, had a shield made for him, so too, anyone who walks with integrity before Him has a shield made for him. And what is written directly after [this verse]? “[Oh God of Hosts,] blessed is the person who trusts in you” (Psalms 84:13). “Abraham” isn’t written here, but “person” is. Any person. David said, ““Blessed [or more accurately, perhaps, “happy”] is the person [who doesn’t walk in the counsel of the wicked...]” (Psalms 1:1). You have given tranquillity [rather than happiness] to the wicked. And there is no pleasantness in their tranquillity. Rather they stand [unlike David’s happy person, who is walking, and unlike those who walk with integrity. The wicked, who might seem to be happy, are – in fact – static].” Rabbi Yuden began [his teaching] and said [the following verse]: “Do not exalt yourself before the King; do not stand in the place of nobles” (Proverbs 25:6). Rabbi Yuden [taught that David wasn’t so arrogant as to bless the Jewish people in a wholly original way, since he would not stand in the place of all of the nobles who had already uttered their own blessings over Israel. Instead,] he read [the texts so as to make it clear that] from the place that this one opened, this one closed. And from the place that this one closed, this one opened. [That is to say, as will become clear later on in this Midrash, Rabbi Yuden recognised a historical chain of blessings uttered by great people in the past. Each person in this chain would begin or end their blessing with the words used by the previous person in the chain to begin or conclude his blessing]. Rabbi Pinchas [expounded, in his discourse, and drew out in a more] lengthy form [what Rabbi Yuden had meant]. He began [his discourse] with the verse: “I have understood more than my elders” (Psalms 119:100). [On a simple reading of that verse, it seems as if David is claiming to know more than his elders. But, as we’ll see, according to Rabbi Pinchas, it means, “I have gained understanding from my elders;” since David learnt how to bless the Jews from his predecessors.] You find that, at first, the Holy One, blessed be He, was in the habit of blessing His world, as it is said: “And God blessed them” (Genesis 1:28). Once Noah arose, He blessed him, as it said, “And God blessed Noah and his sons” (Genesis 9:1). Abraham arose, and He blessed him, as it is said, “And God blessed Abraham in everything” (Genesis 24:1). What is the meaning of “you shall be a blessing” (Genesis 12:2)? Rav Nachman said, [it means] that he passed the blessings over to him and told him, “Until now, I was required to bless my world, but from now on, the blessings are passed over to you, and whoever you bless will be blessed.” When Isaac arose, [Abraham] blessed him. What [does it mean when it is] written, “And he gave all that he had to Isaac” (Genesis 25:5)? What did he give to him? [There is a three-way debate about this between] Rabbi Yehuda, Rabbi Nechemia, and the Rabbis. Rabbi Yehuda said, [he gave him the entitlements of] the first born. Rabbi Nechemia said it was a blessing. And the Rabbis said it was burial [rights] and a document of inheritance [for the cemetery in Hebron]. Rabbi Levi said, in the name of Rabbi Chamma, “He didn’t bless him. He only gave him gifts. And why didn’t he bless him? It can be compared to a king who had an orchard, and he gave it to a tenant farmer. And he had all sorts of trees within it, intertwined with one another; one with the elixir of life, and one with the elixir of death. The tenant said, “If I water [the tree] that contains the elixir of life within it, [the tree] that contains the elixir of death within it will live alongside it. And if I don’t water it, how will [the tree] that contains the elixir of life [continue] to live?” That tenant turned around and said [to himself], “I’ll complete my tenancy this year and go elsewhere. And let the owner of the orchard do what he sees fit with whatever benefit I have provided.” So too, Abraham said, “I will not bless Isaac [because that would mean that] the children of Ishmael and the children of Ketura are now being blessed.” He said, “I am flesh and blood. Today I am here, and tomorrow in the grave. And that which needs to be done in this world, will be done.” When Abraham died, the Holy One, blessed be He, revealed himself to Isaac and blessed him, as it is said, “It was after Abraham died that God blessed Isaac his son” (Genesis 25:11). And so, He did to Jacob, as it is said, “And God appeared to Jacob again, as he came from Padam Aram, and He blessed him” (Genesis 35:9). And Isaac arose and blessed Jacob with [a gift of] giving, as it is said, "May God give you of the dew of heaven” (Genesis 27:28). And he sealed it with a calling: “And Isaac called unto Jacob and blessed him” (Genesis 28:1). Jacob arose to bless the tribes and he began where Isaac left off. As it is written, “And Jacob called unto his children” (Genesis 49:1). And he sealed his blessing with [the word] זאת [meaning, this], as it is said, “And this [זאת] is what their father said to them” (Genesis 49:28). When Moses rose to bless the Israelites, he said, “Jacob the firstborn of the Omnipresent opened with calling and sealed with this, behold, I will open [my blessing] where my elder left off, and he opened [his blessing] with “this is the blessing” (Deuteronomy 33:1). And he sealed [his blessing with the phrase] “Blessed are you – אשריך.” When David arose, he opened [his blessings] with [the phrase] with which Moses sealed [his blessing], and he said, “Also I will bless Israel with [the word] אשרי [i.e., the first word of Psalms 1:1].”