Chasidut על במדבר 11:28
Kedushat Levi
Numbers 11,28. he said: “my lord Moses lock them up!” To this Moses responded by saying: (11,29), “I wish that the entire people of G’d would be filled with prophetic insights!”,
Whereas we know that the righteous are able to bring about a cancellation of Divine decrees that would negatively affect our people, this rule holds true only as long as the decrees in question have not been written down by the prophet who had announced them. Once the decree has been committed to writing, it is beyond the ability of the righteous to bring about its reversal.
If this is so, surely we must ask ourselves how it is possible to cancel the prophecies about the disasters that will befall us during the period described in the Talmud as the חבלי משיח, “the birth pangs of the messianic age?” If you would question why in light of this the prophets committed these decrees to writing in the first place, the answer is that unless they had been written down people would deny that such prophecies had existed and would claim that had they known of them they surely would have taken them to heart and would have done teshuvah, repentance. Not only that, but people would have claimed that the fact that these dire prophecies did not come true was not due to repentance, but that they were the words of false prophets in the first place.
Maimonides in the sefer Hamadda as well as in hilchot melachim (chapter 12,2) writes that what the prophets wrote does not describe the period immediately preceding the coming of the messiah; from this it follows that we cannot pray for cancellation of decrees of which we have no knowledge. When the messiah will come he will also explain to us writings of the prophets which we were unable to understand until then.
Even if it were true that the prophets’ writings did describe the period preceding the coming of the messiah, seeing that when the messiah comes all of the Jewish people will possess intimate knowledge of G’d, just as did the prophets of old, as we know from Joel 3,1ונבאו בניכם ובנותיכם זקניכם חלומות יחלמו בחוריכם חזיונות יראו, “your sons and daughters will prophesy, and your elders will dream dreams, and your youngsters will experience visions.” At that time, when all the Jewish people are on the level of prophets, no one will accuse the prophets of having prophesied falsely, so that there is no need to record their visions in writing. They will then realize that the righteous that lived shortly before the advent of the messiah had been able to cancel these decrees so that their non occurrence is no proof of their having been falsehoods.
When Joshua told Moses to lock up Eldod and Meydod for having prophesied his death and Joshua’s becoming his successor, this prophecy could no longer have been cancelled as it has been recorded in the Torah. [actually it was not spelled out. Ed.] Moses, by saying that he wished that all the Jews could prophesy already meant, that if that were the case the prophecy of Eldod and Meydod could become void then without their being called false prophets. The righteous of his time would then be able to override that decree although it had been recorded in writing. In other words, even when prophets have been told of certain decrees G’d has issued Himself, it is within the power of the righteous to bring about an annulment. This is the meaning of Devarim Rabbah 3,11 stating when explaining the meaning of Deuteronomy 9,1 when Moses commences to describe Israel as crossing the Jordan with the words: אתה עובר היום את הירדן וגו', “you are about to cross the river Jordan today, etc,” that Moses implied that he himself was not allowed to cross the Jordan, but that he hoped that the intercession of the righteous on his behalf might result in G’d revoking His decree concerning this. To his dismay, the people did not understand the hint Moses gave them in that verse. He had hoped that although he had told them that he was about to die (on the east bank of the Jordan) they would pray for a remission of G’d’s decree. Moses, according to that Midrash was clearly not afraid that if as a result of Israel’s prayers he would be allowed to cross the Jordan, that they would consider him a false prophet, seeing he had told them himself that he would not.
Whereas we know that the righteous are able to bring about a cancellation of Divine decrees that would negatively affect our people, this rule holds true only as long as the decrees in question have not been written down by the prophet who had announced them. Once the decree has been committed to writing, it is beyond the ability of the righteous to bring about its reversal.
If this is so, surely we must ask ourselves how it is possible to cancel the prophecies about the disasters that will befall us during the period described in the Talmud as the חבלי משיח, “the birth pangs of the messianic age?” If you would question why in light of this the prophets committed these decrees to writing in the first place, the answer is that unless they had been written down people would deny that such prophecies had existed and would claim that had they known of them they surely would have taken them to heart and would have done teshuvah, repentance. Not only that, but people would have claimed that the fact that these dire prophecies did not come true was not due to repentance, but that they were the words of false prophets in the first place.
Maimonides in the sefer Hamadda as well as in hilchot melachim (chapter 12,2) writes that what the prophets wrote does not describe the period immediately preceding the coming of the messiah; from this it follows that we cannot pray for cancellation of decrees of which we have no knowledge. When the messiah will come he will also explain to us writings of the prophets which we were unable to understand until then.
Even if it were true that the prophets’ writings did describe the period preceding the coming of the messiah, seeing that when the messiah comes all of the Jewish people will possess intimate knowledge of G’d, just as did the prophets of old, as we know from Joel 3,1ונבאו בניכם ובנותיכם זקניכם חלומות יחלמו בחוריכם חזיונות יראו, “your sons and daughters will prophesy, and your elders will dream dreams, and your youngsters will experience visions.” At that time, when all the Jewish people are on the level of prophets, no one will accuse the prophets of having prophesied falsely, so that there is no need to record their visions in writing. They will then realize that the righteous that lived shortly before the advent of the messiah had been able to cancel these decrees so that their non occurrence is no proof of their having been falsehoods.
When Joshua told Moses to lock up Eldod and Meydod for having prophesied his death and Joshua’s becoming his successor, this prophecy could no longer have been cancelled as it has been recorded in the Torah. [actually it was not spelled out. Ed.] Moses, by saying that he wished that all the Jews could prophesy already meant, that if that were the case the prophecy of Eldod and Meydod could become void then without their being called false prophets. The righteous of his time would then be able to override that decree although it had been recorded in writing. In other words, even when prophets have been told of certain decrees G’d has issued Himself, it is within the power of the righteous to bring about an annulment. This is the meaning of Devarim Rabbah 3,11 stating when explaining the meaning of Deuteronomy 9,1 when Moses commences to describe Israel as crossing the Jordan with the words: אתה עובר היום את הירדן וגו', “you are about to cross the river Jordan today, etc,” that Moses implied that he himself was not allowed to cross the Jordan, but that he hoped that the intercession of the righteous on his behalf might result in G’d revoking His decree concerning this. To his dismay, the people did not understand the hint Moses gave them in that verse. He had hoped that although he had told them that he was about to die (on the east bank of the Jordan) they would pray for a remission of G’d’s decree. Moses, according to that Midrash was clearly not afraid that if as a result of Israel’s prayers he would be allowed to cross the Jordan, that they would consider him a false prophet, seeing he had told them himself that he would not.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy