Midras Bilangan 5:23: Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Midrash Tanchuma, Bamidbar Rabbah & Sifrei Bamidbar

(Numb. 5:11–12):¹Neither the Buber nor the traditional Tanhuma have a parashah, the beginning of which coincides with the beginning of Naso (Numb. 4:21-7:89) from the annual cycle. Such a parashah is also missing in other sources for the so-called “triennial cycle.” See B.Z. Wacholder, “prolegomenon,” in The Bible as Read and Preached in the Old Synagogue, by Jacob Mann (“Library of biblical Studies”; New York: Ktav, 1971), p. LX. THEN THE LORD SPOKE UNTO MOSES, SAYING: SPEAK UNTO THE CHILDREN OF ISRAEL AND SAY UNTO THEM: IF ANYONE HAS HIS WIFE GO ASTRAY. Let our master instruct us: When someone wanted to accuse his wife (of infidelity), how did he accuse her?²Tanh., Numb. 2:1. Thus have our masters taught (in Sot. 1:4–5; 2:2–3.):³The Mishnah quotation has several variants from the standard text. See also TSot. 1:3-4. ONE ACCUSING HIS WIFE BROUGHT HER TO THE GREAT COURT WHICH WAS IN JERUSALEM, AND THEY WOULD ADMONISH HER IN THE WAY THAT THEY WOULD ADMONISH WITNESSES IN CAPITAL CASES< … >.⁴See Sanh. 4:5. Then afterwards: THEY WOULD BRING HER UP TO THE EASTERN GATE, TO < … > THE GATE OF NICANOR, WHERE THEY WOULD PURIFY THE LEPERS AND GIVE DRINK TO SUSPECTED ADULTERESSES< … >. A PRIEST WOULD BRING AN EARTHENWARE BOWL⁵Gk.: phiale; Lat.: fiala. AND PUT A HALF LOG OF WATER INTO IT FROM THE BASIN< … >. HE WOULD ENTER THE TEMPLE AND TURN TO HIS RIGHT. NOW A PLACE WAS THERE ONE CUBIT SQUARE WITH A MARBLE FLAGSTONE⁶Gk.: tabla (“tablet”); Lat.: tabula. THERE AND A RING FIXED IN IT. HE WOULD RAISE IT, TAKE DUST FROM UNDERNEATH, AND PUT IT UPON THE WATER, AS STATED (in Numb. 5:17): AND TAKING SOME OF THE DUST WHICH IS IN THE FLOOR OF THE TABERNACLE, THE PRIEST SHALL PUT IT INTO THE WATER. THEN HE WOULD WRITE THE SCROLL (in the wording of Numb. 5:19): AND IF NO ONE HAS SLEPT WITH YOU…. From here (Numb. 5:19) our masters have taught: When one opens capital cases, you begin with <the case for> acquittal. Then he writes further (in vss. 20–21): AND IF YOU HAVE GONE ASTRAY …, MAY THE LORD MAKE YOU A CURSE…. And so Solomon has said (in I Kings 8:31–32 // II Chron. 6:22–23): WHENEVER ONE SINS AGAINST HIS NEIGHBOR, AND HE GIVES HIM AN OATH FOR HIM TO SWEAR; THEN WHEN HE COMES FOR THE OATH BEFORE YOUR ALTAR IN THIS HOUSE, YOU WILL HEARKEN IN HEAVEN, TAKE ACTION, AND JUDGE YOUR SERVANT, IN ORDER TO CONDEMN THE WICKED SO AS TO SET HIS CONDUCT UPON HIS OWN HEAD AND JUSTIFY THE RIGHTEOUS SO AS TO RENDER TO HIM ACCORDING TO HIS RIGHTEOUSNESS. In the parashah on the adulteress the text says what is stated (in Numb. 5:23): THEN <THE PRIEST> SHALL WRITE DOWN THESE CURSES <IN A SCROLL>. (I Kings 8:32 // II Chron. 6:23:) YOU WILL HEARKEN IN HEAVEN, TAKE ACTION, AND JUDGE YOUR SERVANT, IN ORDER TO CONDEMN THE WICKED SO AS TO SET HIS CONDUCT UPON HIS OWN HEAD. (Numb. 5:27:) SO THAT HER BELLY SHALL DISTEND AND HER THIGH SHALL SAG. (I Kings 8:32/II Chron. 6:23:) AND JUSTIFY THE RIGHTEOUS SO AS TO RENDER TO HIM ACCORDING TO HIS RIGHTEOUSNESS. (Numb. 5:28): BUT IF THE WOMAN HAS NOT DEFILED HERSELF AND IS PURE, SHE SHALL BE GUILTLESS AND SHALL CONCEIVE SEED. If she was defiled, (according to Sot. 3:4; 5:1) SHE WOULD NOT HAVE FINISHED DRINKING BEFORE HER FACE TURNS GREEN, HER EYES PROTRUDE, AND SHE IS FULL OF <SWOLLEN> VEINS. THEN THE PRIEST SAYS: TAKE HER OUT, TAKE HER OUT, SO THAT SHE DOES NOT DEFLE THE TEMPLE COURT< … >. JUST AS THE WATER TESTS THE WOMAN, SO DOES THE WATER TEST THE MAN, SINCE IT IS STATED <TWICE> (in Numb. 5:22 & 24): AND IT (i.e., the water that causes the curse> SHALL GO< … >. AND IT SHALL GO <INTO HER … >. JUST AS SHE IS FORBIDDEN TO HER HUSBAND, SO IS SHE FORBIDDEN TO THE LOVER, SINCE IT IS STATED <TWICE> (in Numb. 5:13 & 14): SHE HAS DEFILED HERSELF< … >. SHE HAS DEFILED HERSELF.⁷The gemara ([Sot. 28a) explains these double usages more fully. Cf. also ibid., 26b. If, however, she drinks <the potion> and is found pure, then if she was barren, she is <now> visited (i.e., given conception).⁸Sot. 26a. <If> she used [to] bear ugly <children>, she <now> bears beautiful ones. <Instead of> dark <children>, she bears fair ones. <Instead of> short <children>, she bears tall ones. <Instead of> females, she bears males. Thus it is stated (in Numb. 5:28): BUT IF THE WOMAN HAS NOT DEFILED HERSELF AND IS PURE, SHE SHALL BE GUILTLESS AND SHALL CONCEIVE SEED. The Holy One said to Moses: Write a section on the adulteress so that she may know which name the priest blots out for her,⁹On the scroll of Numb. 5:23, where the priest put down the curses in writing and then rubbed them off into the bitter water. See also Sot. 2:4. what is to be her death, and how it will be made public.¹⁰Gk.: parresiazesthai. Where is it shown? {Where it is stated} [from what they have read on the matter] (in Numb. 5:12): IF ANYONE HAS HIS WIFE GO ASTRAY.

(Numb. 5:12),¹Neither the Buber nor the traditional Tanhuma have a parashah, the beginning of which coincides with the beginning of Naso (Numb. 4:21-7:89) from the annual cycle. Such a parashah is also missing in other sources for the so-called “triennial cycle.” See B.Z. Wacholder, “prolegomenon,” in The Bible as Read and Preached in the Old Synagogue, by Jacob Mann (“Library of Biblical Studies”; New York: Ktav, 1971), p. LX. “If anyone has his wife go astray.” Let our master instruct us: When someone wanted to accuse his wife (of infidelity), how did he accuse her? Thus have our masters taught (in Sot. 1:4-5; 2:2-3.):²The Mishnah quotation has several variants from the standard text. See also TSot. 1:3-4. One accusing his wife brought her to the great court which was in Jerusalem, and they would alarm her in the way that they would alarm witnesses in capital cases.³See Sanh. 4:5. Then afterwards they would bring her up to the eastern gate, to the Gate of Nicanor, where they would purify birthing mothers and lepers and give drink to suspected adulteresses. A priest would bring an earthenware bowl⁴Gk.: phiale; Lat.: fiala. and put a half log of water into it from the basin. He would enter the Temple and turn to his right. Now a place was there one cubit square with a marble flagstone⁵Gk.: tabla (“tablet”); Lat.: tabula. and a ring fixed in it. He would raise it, take dust from underneath, and put it upon the water, as stated (in Numb. 5:17), “and some of the dust which is in the floor of the Tabernacle, [the priest shall put it into the water].” Then he would write the scroll (in the wording of Numb. 5:19), “If no one has slept with you […].” From here our masters have taught, “When one opens capital cases, one begins with [the case for] acquittal.” Then he writes further (in vs. 20), “And if you have gone astray […].” What is written after it (in vs. 21)? “May the Lord make you a curse […].” And so Solomon has said (in I Kings 8:31–32 // II Chron. 6:22–23), “Whenever one sins against his neighbor, and he gives him an oath for him to swear, then when he comes for the oath before Your altar in this house; You will hearken in heaven, take action, and judge Your servant, in order to condemn the wicked so as to set his conduct upon his own head and justify the righteous so as to render to him according to his righteousness.” (Numb. 5:28:) “But if the woman has not defiled herself [and is pure, she shall be guiltless and shall conceive seed].” If she was defiled, (according to Sot. 3:4; 5:1) she would not have finished drinking before her face turns green, her eyes protrude, and she is full of [swollen] veins. Then the priest says, “Take her out, take her out,” so that she does not defile the Temple court. Just as the water tests the woman, so does the water test the man, since it is stated [twice] (in Numb. 5:22 & 24), “And it (i.e., the water that causes the curse] shall go.” Just as she is forbidden to her husband, so is she forbidden to the lover, since it is stated [twice] (in Numb. 5:13 & 14), “she has defiled herself.”⁶The Gemara (Sot. 28a) explains these double usages more fully. Cf. also ibid., 26b. If, however, she drinks [the potion] and is found pure; then if she was barren, she is [now] visited (i.e., given conception).⁷Sot. 26a. If she used [to] give birth in pain, she [now] gives birth with tranquility; if she used [to] bear ugly [children], she [now] bears beautiful ones; [instead of] dark [children], she bears fair ones; [instead of] short [children], she bears tall ones; [instead of] females, she bears males. Thus it is stated (in Numb. 5:28), “But if the woman has not defiled herself [and is pure, she shall be guiltless and shall conceive seed].” The Holy One, blessed be He, said to Moses, “Write a section on the adulteress so that she may know which name the priest blots out for her⁸On the scroll of Numb. 5:23, where the priest put down the curses in writing and then rubbed them off into the bitter water. See also Sot. 2:4. and how it will be made public.”⁹Gk.: parresiazesthai. How is this shown? From what they have read on the matter (in Numb. 5:12), “If anyone has his wife go astray.” If she has merit, it suspends [the effect of the bitter water] a year or two or three.¹⁰The whole section comes from the Mishnah, but again there are several variants from the standard text. R. Simeon says, “Merit does not [suspend the effect of] the [bitter] water; for if you say so, you will be found postponing [the effect] for all women who drink it and spreading slander about undefiled women who have drunk it. [This slander] says, ‘They were [really] defiled, but the merit has suspended [the effect of the water] for them.’” R. Meir says,¹¹The traditional Mishnah text reads “Rabbi says.” “Really, the merit suspends the [effect of] the bitter water. If she was defiled, however, she will never again bear [children] and prosper but degenerate more and more, and in the end she will die of the same death, as stated (in Prov. 6:16), ‘Six things the Lord hates, and seven are an abomination for His soul.’” R. Jose the Galilean says,¹²Numb. R. 9:11. “[These] seven things were said about the adulteress. (Prov. 6:17:) ‘Haughty eyes,’ in that the adulterous woman raises her eyes to another man; and so it says (in Is. 3:16), ‘Because the daughters of Zion are haughty, and walk with extended neck and roving (mesakarot) eyes.’ That is an expression of untruth (sheker), in that she commits adultery with another man and becomes pregnant from him, and then lies and says to her husband, ‘I am pregnant from you.’ (Prov. 6:17, cont.:) ‘Hands that shed innocent blood,’ in that the adulterer goes in on condition that, if he is caught, he will kill or be killed. (Prov. 6:18:) ‘A heart devising wicked thoughts,’ in that the adulterer and the adulteress have thoroughly wicked thoughts all the time, when they sin in telling each other in which place and at what time. (Prov. 6:18, cont.:) ‘Feet quick (memaharot) to run to evil,’ in that they certainly are hastening (memaharim) to commit the sin. (Prov. 6:19:) ‘A false witness that spreads a lie,’ in that, if they are caught, they speak falsely and lie, when they swear and say, ‘We were talking about other things.’ (Prov. 6:19, cont.:) ‘And one that instigates a quarrel among brothers,’ in that all Israel are brothers, as it stated (in Ps. 122:8), ‘For the sake of my brothers and friends’; and in the case of one who commits adultery with his friend's wife, when her husband hears of it, he hates him. Moreover, this adulterer cannot look at [the husband]. Ergo, ‘and one that instigates a quarrel among brothers.’” Ergo, [there are] seven injurious things which the adulteress does.

“The priest shall write these curses in a scroll, and erase it in the water of bitterness” (Numbers 5:23).
“[The priest] shall write these curses.” Why water? It is from the place that she came.⁷⁵A putrid drop (see Mishna Avot 3:1). And dirt; it is to the place that she is going.⁷⁶A place of dust, maggots, and worms (see Mishna Avot 3:1). “Shall write” – it is before Him to whom she is destined to give a reckoning.⁷⁷See Mishna Avot 3:1.
“Curses” – does he perhaps write all the curses in the Torah? The verse states: “These.”
“The priest” – the verse disqualified an Israelite.
“In a scroll” – but not on paper.
“And erase it in the…water” – Rabbi Zekharya, son-in-law of Rabbi Levi, related this incident: Rabbi Meir was accustomed to preaching in the synagogue every Shabbat eve. There was a certain woman there who was accustomed to listen to his voice. One time the discourse ran late. She went and sought to enter her house, and the candle was extinguished. Her husband said to her: Where were you? She said: I was listening to the discourse. He said to her: By my word, the woman will not enter here until such time that she goes and spits in the face of the preacher. Rabbi Meir saw by means of the Divine Spirit, and made himself seem as though his eye ached. He said: ‘Any woman who knows how to utter an incantation for the eye, let her come and utter an incantation.’ Her neighbors said to her: ‘This is your opportunity to return to his house. Make yourself as though you are uttering an incantation and spit in his eye.’ She went to him. He said to her: ‘Do you know how to utter incantations for the eye?’ Because she was in awe of him, she said no. He said to her: ‘Spit into it seven times and it will be cured.’ After she spit, he said to her: ‘Go tell your husband: You said to me one time, but I spit seven times.’ His students said to him: ‘Are matters of Torah to be treated with such contempt? Had you told us, would we not have sent and brought him, flogged him on the bench, and forced him to reconcile with his wife?’ He said to them: ‘The honor of Meir shall not be greater than the honor of his Maker. If regarding the sacred Name that is written in sanctity, the verse says that it should be erased in the water in order to impose peace between a husband and his wife, all the more so, the honor of Meir.’'
“In the water of bitterness” – Shmuel’s father said: One must place a bitter substance into the water, as it is stated: “The water of bitterness” – that it is already bitter.