Midras Hosea 4:2: Ein Yaakov (Glick Edition), Midrash Tanchuma, Midrash Tanchuma Buber & Mekhilta DeRabbi Yishmael

(Fol. 13) R. Juda said in the name of Samuel: "Whoever is not well versed in the legal statute of divorce and betrothal documents shall not occupy himself with it." R. Assi said in the name of R. Jochanan: "And such that occupy themselves, [although not well posted in it], are as hard (injurious) upon the world, even more so than the generation which perished in the flood, as it is said (Hos. 4, 2) Swearing and lying, and killing and stealing, and committing adultery! They break all bounds, and blood toucheth blood." What does this passage prove? This is as R. Joseph translated it [by quoting Jonathan b. Uziel]: "They begot children from strange wives, thereby increasing crime upon crime;" and immediately after this it is written, Therefore shall the land mourn, and everybody that dwelleth therein shall languish, with the beasts of the field, and with the fowls of the heaven; yea also the fishes of the sea shall perish, while concerning the flood a decree against fishes was not issued, as it is said (Gen. 7, 22) Of all that were on the dry land died, but not the fishes in the sea, here even the fishes in the sea are included. But how do you know that the passage above refers to single crimes? Perhaps it refers to all the crimes when committed together. It is impossible to think this, since the passage says (Jer. 23, 10) For because of swearing the land mourneth. Perhaps false swearing is a crime great in itself, but the rest of the crimes mentioned in the passage above are subject to punishment only when they go together? (Ib. b) Is it then written Uparatzu in a coordinate construction? [which would mean that all the elements mentioned in the passage are united]. The construction of the passage is in an ordinate form Paratzu, [hence everything is counted separately].

(Numb. 5:17), “Then the priest shall take holy water in an earthen vessel and some of the dust.” And, why does he take water and dust and test her? Because he was created from the dust, and she was formed from the water.²¹Cf. Gen. R. 14:7. Therefore she was tested by water and by dust as to whether she was as pure as when she was created or not. Another interpretation: Why is she tested with water and with dust? Because they are her witnesses. Thus it is stated (in Deut. 30:19), “I have called the heavens and the earth to witness against you today.” Another interpretation: Why is she tested with water [and with dust]? Because a person who sows some seeds in the dust does not know what they are, until the water comes down upon them and makes known whether they belong to the owner of the field, or [whether they are] what others have sown. [(Numb. 5:12), “If anyone has his wife go astray.”] This text is related (to Job 24:15), “The eye of an adulterer watches for twilight, saying, ‘No eye shall see me.’” And so the adulterer says, “No human being knows about me”; but the Holy One, blessed be He, has His eyes ranging over all the earth.²²Numb. R. 9:1. So it says (in Jer. 23:24), “’If someone hides in secret places, shall I not see him; do I not fill heaven and earth,’ says the Lord.” Such is the way of those who commit transgression. They wait for a time of darkness, so that no one will see them. It is therefore stated (in Job 24:15), “The eye of the adulterer watches for twilight.” So also thieves watch for an hour of darkness, as stated (in vs. 16), “He breaks into houses in the dark.” And so it says (in Is. 29:15), “Woe to those who delve deeply to hide a plan from the Lord, for their works are in darkness; [so they say, ‘Who sees us and who knows about us?’]” The thief and the adulterer are obdurate, because they remove the Divine Presence. The Holy One, blessed be He, as it were, fills the realms above and the realms below, as stated (in Jer. 23:24), “’do I not fill heaven and earth,’ says the Lord.” Also in regard to the place where the adulterer comes to commit adultery, the Holy One, blessed be He, is there in His glory. It is so stated (in Is. 6:3), “the whole earth is full of His glory.” Now the adulterer says to the Holy One, blessed be He, “Remove Yourself, and give way to me for a while.” The matter is exceedingly difficult, as it were. Since He is slow to anger, He gives way to him; for (according to Job 11:11) “He knows those who are worthless; so when He sees iniquity, [does He not discern it?]” It also says (in Job 24:15, cont.), “He (i.e., the Holy One, blessed be He) turns a secret into a face.”²³This rendering fits the context of what follows in the midrash. A more traditional rendering, which fits the context of Job, would read, “AND HE (i.e., the adulterer) PUTS A VEIL ON HIS FACE. Ergo (in Job 24:15), “When the eye of an adulterer watches for twilight, saying, ‘No eye shall see me.’” So what does the Holy One, blessed be He, do? He turns a secret into a face. He puts the face of [the] adulterer on that fetus.²⁴Lev. R. 23:12. While the adulterer and the adulteress do not want her to become pregnant but only to satisfy their sexual desire, the Holy One, blessed be He, proclaims²⁵Gk.: parresiazesthai. them to the world. Ergo, “He turns a secret into a face,” so that the people may know [about him] and say, “Surely this one's face resembles the face of [the] adulterer”; for [the Holy One, blessed be He,] has formed the image of the fetus in the likeness of the adulterer. Ergo (ibid.), “He turns a secret into a face.” It is therefore called whoredom (zimmah); for they both deny and say, “We do not know what this is (zeh mah).”²⁶Literally: “This is what?” The Hebrew uses the unusual word order to make the parallel with “whoredom” (zimmah). R. Isaac said, “The power of the adulterer is strong, because it weakens the power of the Divine Presence. How? When the fetus is conceived from the husband, the Holy One, blessed be He, forms its image in forty days. For thus have our masters taught, ‘In forty days the image of the fetus is recognizable.’ After forty days, when the adulterer comes into her, the Holy One, blessed be He, stands wondering and says, ‘After whom shall I form [the fetus]? The image (rt.: tswr) of the husband or the image of the adulterer?’ (According to Deut. 32:18,) As it were, ‘You were unmindful of (tshy) the Rock (tswr) that bore you.’²⁷I.e., the adulterer forgot that the Holy One would expose him. The yod (= y) is [here written] small. [Thus, you] weaken (tsh, without the yod) the hands (yad in the dual) of the Creator (tsayyar).” R. Abbahu said, “To what is the matter comparable? To a sculptor (tsayyar, rt.: tsyr), who was fashioning (rt.: tsyr) an image²⁸Gk.: eikonion. of a king. When he came to finish the face,²⁹Gk.: prosopon. they said to him, “The king is dead, and another king has arisen.” When the sculptor heard that, his hands failed. He began to say, “What shall I do with these colors³⁰In the ancient world statues were painted. which I have? Shall I fashion [them] in the form of the former king or in the form of the second king?” He began to be bewildered. Now similarly, when the husband has marital relations with his wife, the Holy One, blessed be He, forms the fetus in the likeness of its father. [Then] in turn the adulterer comes into her. Ergo, the colors are mingled. Thus it is stated (in Hos. 4:2), “Swearing, lying, murdering, stealing, committing adultery break out; bloodshed follows bloodshed.” What does the Holy One, blessed be He, do? He returns, as it were, and changes the face into the likeness of the adulterer. Ergo (in Job 24:15) “He turns a secret into a face.”

(Ib. b) R. Chiya b. Abin said in the name of R. Joshua b. Karcha: "An aged inhabitant of Jerusalem once told me that in this valley two hundred and eleven thousand myriads were massacred by Nebusaradan, captain of the guard, and in Jerusalem itself he slaughtered upon a single stone ninety-four myriads, so that the blood flowed till it touched the blood of Zachariah [the prophet], to uphold the passage (Hos. 4, 2) And blood toucheth blood. When he saw the blood of Zechariah, and noticed that it was boiling and agitating, he asked: 'What is this?' and he was told that it was the blood spilled of the sacrifices. Then he ordered blood from the sacrifices to be brought and compared it with the blood of the murdered prophet, and when he found the one unlike the other," he said: 'If ye tell me the truth, well and good; if not, I will comb your flesh with iron currycombs!' Upon this they confessed: 'We had a prophet among us, and because he rebuked us on matters of religion we arose and killed him, and it is now some years since his blood has been in this restless condition.' 'Well,' said he, 'I will appease him.' He then went and brought the greatest together with the smaller Sanhedrin and slaughtered them, but the blood of the prophet did not rest. He next slaughtered young men and maidens, but the blood continued restless as before. He finally brought school children and slaughtered them, but the blood being still unappeased, be exclaimed; 'Zachariah! Zachariah! I have the best among them already killed. Do you want me to kill them all?' As he said this the blood of the prophet remained silent. At that moment a spark of repentance flashed through Nebusaradan's mind, for he said to himself: 'If the blood of one individual has brought about so great a punishment, how much greater will my punishment be for the slaughter of so many!' He fled from his house, sent a document concerning the disposal of his property, and became a proselyte." We are taught Na'aman was merely a Ger Toshab, Nebusaradan, however, was a true proselyte, from the descendants of Sissera were such who studied the Law in Jerusalem, and from the descendants of Sanherib were such who taught the Torah among the multitudes of Israel, and they are Shmayah and Abtalion. This is also meant by the passage (Ez. 24, 8) I place her blood upon the dry rock, so that it shall not be covered up.