Talmud su Proverbi 11:7
בְּמ֤וֹת אָדָ֣ם רָ֭שָׁע תֹּאבַ֣ד תִּקְוָ֑ה וְתוֹחֶ֖לֶת אוֹנִ֣ים אָבָֽדָה׃
Quando un uomo malvagio muore, la sua aspettativa perirà, e la speranza della forza perirà.
Jerusalem Talmud Berakhot
Rebbi Yoḥanan66In the parallel in Ruth rabba, this paragraph and the one after the next are taken together; the insertion of the next paragraph is difficult to understand.
The argument of R. Yoḥanan refers mostly to the parts of this and the preceding verses that are not quoted. “That is evil in all which is done under the sun, that the same happens to all; also, the heart of humans is full of evil, hooliganism is in their thoughts during their lifetime, but their end is with the dead. Who is being joined, all living beings have confidence; truly a living dog is better than a dead lion.” Is being joined is the qere, the way the word is read, but “may choose” is the ketib, the way it is written. The interpretation given the ketib here is: All the living can have confidence that they may choose (the way of virtue), but death is final; nothing can be changed after death. Hence, a living dog (a living sinner) is better (might by repentance attain a higher state of holiness) than a dead lion (a good person.) said (Eccl. 9:4): “Who is it that has been connected?” It is written: “may choose.” All living beings have the certitude that as long as a human is alive, he has hope. When he dies, his hope is lost. What is the reason (Prov. 11:7): “When an evil man dies, hope becomes lost.”
The argument of R. Yoḥanan refers mostly to the parts of this and the preceding verses that are not quoted. “That is evil in all which is done under the sun, that the same happens to all; also, the heart of humans is full of evil, hooliganism is in their thoughts during their lifetime, but their end is with the dead. Who is being joined, all living beings have confidence; truly a living dog is better than a dead lion.” Is being joined is the qere, the way the word is read, but “may choose” is the ketib, the way it is written. The interpretation given the ketib here is: All the living can have confidence that they may choose (the way of virtue), but death is final; nothing can be changed after death. Hence, a living dog (a living sinner) is better (might by repentance attain a higher state of holiness) than a dead lion (a good person.) said (Eccl. 9:4): “Who is it that has been connected?” It is written: “may choose.” All living beings have the certitude that as long as a human is alive, he has hope. When he dies, his hope is lost. What is the reason (Prov. 11:7): “When an evil man dies, hope becomes lost.”
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy