Komentarz do Koheleta 10:23

Dead flies decay and pollute, etc. E.g., in the winter season, flies have no strength, and are near death; nevertheless, if it falls into a perfumer’s oil and becomes mingled with the perfumes, it causes it to become putrid and it assumes a foam, which is called escume in O.F., and a sort of bubbles appears in it, and this is the meaning of ‘יַבִּיעַ.’ So an insignificant thing¹I.e., a fly. spoiled a precious thing.²I.e., the perfumer’s oil. So does a little foolishness outweigh wisdom and honor, for it outweighed them all. Suppose that a man was equally divided with transgressions and merits, and he came and committed one transgression, which tipped the scale [causing him] to be guilty. The result is that this foolishness which is small, is heavy and weighs, and is heavier than all the wisdom and honor that he possessed, for behold, it outweighed them all.

“Dead flies spoil and froth a perfumer’s oil; a little folly is weightier than wisdom, than honor” (Ecclesiastes 10:1).
“Dead flies spoil and froth a perfumer’s oil” – ben Azai and Rabbi Akiva: ben Azai said: One fly that dies does not spoil and froth a perfumer’s oil; but a single sin that one performs will cause him to lose much good.
Rabbi Akiva expounded: “Therefore, the netherworld has expanded itself, and opened its mouth without limit [ḥok]” (Isaiah 5:14). It is not written ḥukim, but rather “without ḥok,” one who does not have mitzvot to tip the scales in favor of his virtues.¹The word ḥok (plural, ḥukim) can mean limit or statute. Rabbi Akiva interprets the verse according to the second meaning, such that the verse means that the netherworld takes a person who is missing just one mitzva that would have tipped the scales in his favor.
Those who engage in allegorical interpretations of the Torah say: A person is judged on the basis of the majority of his [deeds]. A person should always assess himself as though he is half virtuous and half guilty; if he performs one mitzva, happy is he, as he tipped his scales in favor of virtue, if he performs one transgression, woe is he, as he tipped his scales in favor of guilt. Rabbi Shimon ben Elazar said: Because the individual is judged on the basis of the majority of his [deeds], and the world is judged on the basis of its majority, with the single transgression that this one [individual] performs, he causes himself and the world to lose much good.

[Are] outweighed. An expression of weight. It is heavy and weighs more than the wisdom that he possesses. The Midrash Aggadah [states], that [Scripture] compares the evil inclination to dying flies.

Another matter: “Dead flies spoil [yavish] and froth [yabia] a perfumer’s oil” refers to the congregation of Koraḥ. Yesterday they were vilifying [mavishin] Moses and saying: Moses is not a true prophet, Aaron is not the High Priest, and Torah is not from Heaven, and today²After they were swallowed by the ground, Koraḥ and his congregation declared, from the depths of the earth, that Moses had been correct (see Bemidbar Rabba 18:20; Bava Batra 74a). they are expressing [mabi’im] matters before Moses and saying: Moses is a true prophet, Aaron is the High Priest, and Torah is from Heaven. “Weightier than wisdom, than honor” – this is prophecy; “a little folly”³This is expounded to refer to the punishment of Koraḥ and his congregation, which they received due to their folly. – this is the decree of Moses, who said: “But if the Lord will create a creation [and the ground will open its mouth and swallow them up…then you will know that these men have despised the Lord]” (Numbers 16:30).
Another matter: “Dead flies spoil and froth a perfumer’s oil…” refers to Do’eg and Aḥitofel. Yesterday, they were vilifying David with their words and saying: His lineage is flawed; does he not descend from Ruth the Moavite? Today they are expressing matters and are ashamed. “Weightier than wisdom, than honor” – this is the prophecy of David.⁴David’s former antagonists eventually admitted that he was a worthy king and prophet. “A little folly” – “You, God, bring them down to the pit of destruction…” (Psalms 55:24).
Another matter: “Dead flies spoil and froth a perfumer’s oil…” is speaking of the generation of Elijah, who would vilify him with their words and say: “Baal, answer us” (I Kings 18:26). Today they are expressing matters and saying: “The Lord, He is God; the Lord, He is God” (I Kings 18:39). “Weightier than wisdom, than honor” – this is prophecy, this is the prophecy of Elijah. “A little folly” – “Elijah took them down to the Kishon Stream and slaughtered them” (I Kings 18:40).

Decay and pollute. A good name, which is more pleasant than a perfumer’s oil.

The heart [understanding] of a wise man is at his right hand. His wisdom will turn him onto the proper path for his benefit.³Alternatively, his intellect is always at hand when he needs it. (Metsudas Dovid)

“The heart of the wise is to his right, and the heart of a fool is to his left” (Ecclesiastes 10:2).
“The heart of the wise is to his right…” – Rabbi Ḥanina bar Pappa said: [This is analogous] to two people who had two kor, one of wheat and one of barley. One of them said to the other: ‘If yours is of barley mine is of wheat, and if mine is of wheat yours is of barley. In any case, I am taking the one of wheat.’ So, Abraham said to Lot: “If to the left, I will go to the right, and if to the right, I will go to the left [asme’ila]” (Genesis 13:9). Rabbi Ḥanina ben Rabbi Yitzḥak said: It is not written here “esmola,” but rather “asme’ila.”⁵Esmola means, “I will go to the left.” Asme’ila can mean, “I will cause to go to the left.” Even if you are impertinent, I will cause you to go to the left.⁶Abraham told Lot: Ultimately, I will go to the right, the direction of the wise, and you will go to the left, which is the direction of the fool. Rabbi [Yehuda HaNasi], when a person would enter for judgment before him, if [the party that lost the case] would obey the ruling that would be fine, and if not, [Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi] would say to a member of his household: ‘Cause him to go left’;⁷Cause him to understand that he is wrong. and he would signal and show him that he should strike him from the other side.
Another matter: “The heart of the wise is to his right” – this is Jacob, as it is stated: “Jacob arose and placed his sons and his wives [upon the camels]” (Genesis 31:17).⁸Jacob understood that the main objective of marriage is producing the next generation. Therefore, he tended first to his sons and then to his wives. “And the heart of a fool is to his left” – this is the wicked Esau, as it is stated: “Esau took his wives, his sons, [and his daughters]” (Genesis 36:6).⁹Esau prioritized his own pleasure; therefore he tended to his wives and then to his sons. It was not because he was concerned with his wives’ safety that he tended to them first, as he tended to his daughters, who were even more vulnerable, last.

But the heart of a fool is at his left. To drive him off the proper path, which is a glory and a comfort for him.⁴Alternatively, his intellect is not ready in time of need. (Metsudas Dovid)

And proclaims to all that he is a fool. By his walk and with his speech, everyone recognizes that he is a fool.⁵His actions make it so obvious, that it is as if he proclaims to all that he is a fool. (Ibn Ezra)

“Even when a fool walks on the way his heart is lacking; and he says to everyone that he is a fool” (Ecclesiastes 10:3).
“Even when a fool walks on the way…” – a fool believes that all the people are fools like him, but he does not know that he is a fool and all the people are wise.

If the spirit [anger] of the Ruler. The Ruler of the Universe flares up against you, to scrutinize you with the Divine standard of justice.

“If the spirit of the ruler comes upon you, do not forsake your place, as in its abating he will pardon great sins” (Ecclesiastes 10:4).
“If the spirit of the ruler comes upon you, do not forsake your place” – when dominion comes to you, do not forsake your attribute of humility, to teach you that anyone who forsakes his humility causes death to his world and sin to his generation. From whom do you learn this? From Zekharia, as it is stated: “The spirit of God clothed Zekharia….and he stood above the people” (II Chronicles 24:20). Did he, in fact, walk above the people? It is, rather, that he considered himself greater than all the people; son-in-law of the king,¹⁰He was actually the grandson, the son of the son-in-law, of King Yehoram. He was also a cousin to King Yoash, who was king of Judah at the time of this event. priest, prophet, and judge. He began speaking arrogantly to the people, and saying to them: “Why are you violating the mitzvot of the Lord so that you will not succeed?” (II Chronicles 24:20). Immediately, “they conspired against him and stoned him with stones at the command of the king [in the courtyard of the house of the Lord]” (II Chronicles 24:21).
Rabbi Yudan asked Rabbi Aḥa: Where did they kill Zekharia, in the Israelite Courtyard or in the Women’s Courtyard? [Rabbi Aḥa] said to him: Neither in the Israelite Courtyard nor in the Women’s Courtyard, but rather in the Priests’ Courtyard. They did not treat his blood like the blood of a gazelle or the blood of a deer. Regarding the blood of a gazelle and a deer whose blood has been spilled, it is written: “You shall spill its blood and cover it with dirt” (Leviticus 17:13), but this righteous one [Zekharia], they did not treat his blood like the blood of a gazelle and not like the blood of a deer. Why [did God allow them to be wicked] to such an extent? It was “to arouse fury and to take vengeance” (Ezekiel 24:8). You find that when Nevuzaradan¹¹Nevuzaradan was the officer who led the Babylonian troops in sacking Jerusalem and destroying the Temple (see II Kings 25:8–22). ascended to destroy Jerusalem, the Holy One blessed be He indicated to that blood that it should seethe. He said to it:¹²The Holy One blessed be He said to the blood. This is the time that you will collect your debt. [Nevuzaradan] said to them: ‘What is the nature of this blood?’ They said to him: ‘It is the blood of bulls, rams, and sheep that we were sacrificing to the Holy One blessed be He.’ Immediately, he brought bulls, rams, and sheep and slaughtered many of them onto it, but it did not stop. He said to them: ‘If you tell me, fine. But if not, I will comb the flesh of these people with a comb of iron,’ but [at first] they did not say. Once he [again] said to them that [their explanation] was not [true], they said to him: ‘Why should we conceal it from you? We had a prophet, a priest, who would reprimand us in the name of Heaven. [He said to us]: Accept it, but we did not accept it from him. Rather, we rose against him and killed him.’
[Nevuzaradan] said to them: ‘I will assuage it.’ He then brought the Great Sanhedrin and slaughtered them onto it, but it did not rest. He slaughtered the lesser Sanhedrin onto it, but it did not rest. He brought young priests and slaughtered them onto it, but it did not rest. He slaughtered schoolchildren onto it, but it did not rest. He said to [the seething blood]: ‘Zekharia, I have eliminated the best of your people. Would you like all of them to be eliminated?’ Immediately, it rested. That wicked one contemplated repentance, and said: ‘One who eliminates a single Israelite soul, it is written in his regard: “Whoever sheds the blood of man, his blood will be spilled by man” (Genesis 9:6); this man¹³Nevuzaradan was referring to himself. who eliminated many souls, all the more so.’ At that moment, the Holy One blessed be He became filled with mercy, and He intimated to the blood, and it was absorbed in its place.
Rabbi Yudan said: [The Israelites] performed seven transgressions [via one act] on that day:¹⁴When they killed Zekharia. They killed a priest, a prophet, and a judge, they spilled innocent blood, they impurified the Temple Courtyard, and it was Shabbat and Yom Kippur.¹⁵Killing is a prohibited labor on these days, as well as a profound violation of the sanctity of the day.
But Yaḥaziyel did not do so;¹⁶He did not become haughty when he achieved an elevated status. rather, “Yaḥaziyel, son of Zekharia, son of Benaya, son of Yaḥaziyel, son of Matanya the Levite, from the sons of Asaf, the spirit of the Lord was upon him in the midst of the assembly” (II Chronicles 20:14). What is “in the midst of the assembly”? It is that he likened himself to the assembly.
Another matter: “If the spirit of the ruler comes upon you,” is speaking of Noah.¹⁷The midrash interprets the verse to refer to a ruler issuing a command to you. If he commands you to be in a certain place, do not forsake that place without another official command. He entered the ark with permission and he emerged with permission. From where [is it derived] that he entered with permission? [It is from the verse:] “Come you and all your household to the ark” (Genesis 7:1). From where [is it derived] that he emerged with permission? [It is from the verse:] “Go out of the ark, you …” (Genesis 8:16).
Another matter: “If the spirit of the ruler comes upon you,” is speaking of Joshua. Just as the Israelites crossed the Jordan with permission, so too they emerged only with permission. From where [is it derived that] they crossed with permission? As it is stated: “Pass through the midst of the camp…[in another three days you are crossing this Jordan]” (Joshua 1:11). They emerged with permission, as it is stated: “Joshua commanded the priests saying: Emerge from the Jordan” (Joshua 4:17).
Another matter: “If the spirit of the ruler…” is speaking of David. Before he reigned, “David is the youngest” (I Samuel 17:14). When he reigned, “King David stood on his feet [and said: Hear me my brethren]” (I Chronicles 28:2).¹⁸He remained humble even after he assumed the throne.
Another matter: “If the spirit of the ruler…” is speaking of Mordekhai. Before prominence came to him, “Mordekhai was sitting at the king’s gate” (Esther 2:19). When prominence came to him, “Mordekhai returned to the king’s gate” (Esther 6:12).¹⁹This indicates that Mordekhai did not become haughty due to his prominence.

Do not leave your place. Do not set aside your virtuous trait and say to Him, “Of what avail is my righteousness?”

For softness. The stringencies of the judgment with the afflictions that come upon you are a cure for your sins, and will relieve great sins for you.

Like an error emanating from the ruler. He is like a ruler who unintentionally let an error out of his mouth, and it is irrevocable. So does the Holy One, Blessed Is He, speak, and [His decrees] cannot be retracted.

“There is an evil that I have seen under the sun, like an error that emerges from before the ruler” (Ecclesiastes 10:5).
“There is an evil that I have seen under the sun, like an error that emerges from before the ruler” – so said Jacob to Laban: “With whomever you find your gods, he shall not live […and Jacob did not know that Rachel had stolen them]” (Genesis 31:32). So it was, “like an error that emerges from before the ruler,” and Rachel died.
The son of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi had something that he swallowed [lodged in his throat]. [Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi] went and brought one of the disciples of bar Pandeira²⁰Jesus of Nazareth to extricate what he had swallowed.²¹He wanted him to heal him with traditional medicine, but he recited an incantation, mentioning the name of his mentor, and the bone was extricated. He said to him: ‘What did you recite over him?’ He said to him: ‘This passage after that.’²²Referring to phrases in the incantation. He said: ‘It would have been preferable for him to be buried and not have you recite that passage over him.’ So it was, “like an error that emerges from before the ruler.”²³Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi’s son died. Rabbi Yirmeya of Shabashta took a crown of olive branches and tied it on his head.²⁴This was at his wedding. The Sages had issued a decree after the destruction of the Temple prohibiting crowns for grooms. Rabbi Yirmeya thought that only gold crowns were included in the decree. Shmuel heard and said: ‘It would have been preferable for him to be beheaded and not to have done so.’ So it occurred to him.²⁵He was eventually beheaded.
Antoninus the younger, grandson of Antoninus the elder, was asking our holy Rabbi,²⁶Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi he said: ‘Who will die first, me or you?’ He said to him: ‘I will.’ His students said to him: ‘Our Rabbi, the whole world is praying for your good life, and this is what you say?’ He said to them: ‘If my time arrives [first] what of it? And if the angel of death comes to take him [first], what will he say to him: Do not come to me [first], I am not coming? Moreover, if it will be so,²⁷If I will die before him. the gentiles will say: Blessed is the God of the Jews, as they even know the time of their death.’ So it occurred to him, “like an error that emerges from before the ruler.”²⁸Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi died first.
Another matter: “There is an evil that I have seen…like an error that emerges from before the ruler” – this is Eli the priest, who said to Samuel: My sons will not inherit my position, so, too, your sons will not inherit your position.²⁹This is explained further in the Gemara (Makkot 11a). Eli demanded that Samuel tell him what prophecy God had revealed to him, and cursed him if he would not reveal the prophecy (see I Samuel 3:17). Although Samuel did reveal the prophecy, Eli’s curse came true nonetheless. So it was, “like an error that emerges from before the ruler.”

Folly is set upon great heights. This is the evil that is like an error which goes forth from before the ruler, that foolishness and wickedness are placed on the loftiest heights, for the Holy One, Blessed Is He, elevated the fools and the wicked, for I see with the Holy Spirit, that they are destined to extend their hand upon His Temple and to make “their signs for signs.”⁶Tehillim 74:4. See also Maseches Gittin 56b.

“Folly is set on great heights, and the wealthy sit in lowliness” (Ecclesiastes 10:6).
“Folly is set on great heights” – these are the Chaldeans, as it is written: “All the princes of the king of Babylon came and sat in the Middle Gate” (Jeremiah 39:3). What is the Middle Gate [shaar hatavekh]? It is the place where they determine [meḥatkhin] the halakhot. “And the wealthy sit in lowliness” – this is the Sanhedrin, as it is stated: “They will sit on the ground and be silent [the elders of the daughter of Zion]” (Lamentations 2:10).

But the rich sit in low places. Yisroel, for despite all the greatness and honor that they have now in my days,⁷Alternatively, this verse describes the evil that Koheles observes in the previous verse. The rich who are deserving of honor are ignored, while fools and slaves are elevated to high positions that they do not deserve. (Metsudas Dovid) they are destined to sit in a low place, as it is stated, “they sit on the ground, they are silent.”⁸Eichah 2:10.

But the rich sit in low places. Yisroel, for despite all the greatness and honor that they have now in my days,⁷Alternatively, this verse describes the evil that Koheles observes in the previous verse. The rich who are deserving of honor are ignored, while fools and slaves are elevated to high positions that they do not deserve. (Metsudas Dovid) they are destined to sit in a low place, as it is stated, “they sit on the ground, they are silent.”⁸Eichah 2:10.

I have seen slaves on horses. These are the Chaldeans, about whom it is stated, “this nation never used to be,”⁹Yeshayahu 23:13. will be elevated [to ride] on horses, leading Yisroel’s captives, bound with neck irons.

“I have seen servants upon horses, and princes walking on the ground like servants” (Ecclesiastes 10:7).
“I have seen servants upon horses” – these are Ishmaelites; “and princes walking on the ground like servants” – this is Joseph. Rabbi Levi said: A slave³⁰Meaning an Egyptian, as the Egyptians were descendants of Canaan, of whom it is written: “Accursed is Canaan, a slave of slaves he shall be to his brothers” (Genesis 9:25). purchased, and the son of a maidservant³¹The Ishmaelites, who descended from Hagar sold, and a free man was sold to both of them.³²This is a reference to Joseph, who was sold to Ishmaelites, who then sold him to an Egyptian (see Genesis 37:28, 36).
Rabbi Akiva was ascending to Rome; he encountered a certain eunuch³³He was castrated as a youth and raised to serve in the Roman priesthood. from the royal court. He said to him: ‘Are you the rabbi of the Jews?’ [Rabbi Akiva] said to him: ‘Yes.’ He said to [Rabbi Akiva]: ‘Hear these three matters from me: One on a horse is a king; one on a donkey is a free man; one with shoes on his feet is a person; [therefore,] one without this and without that, one buried in a ditch is preferable to him.’³⁴The eunuch was riding a horse, whereas Rabbi Akiva was walking barefoot because of a public fast, on which it was forbidden to wear shoes (Midrash HaMevo’ar). [Rabbi Akiva] said: ‘You said three matters, hear from me three alternative matters: The glory of a face is the beard, the joy of the heart is a wife, and “the portion of the Lord is children” (Psalms 127:3). Woe unto that man who is lacking these three.³⁵The eunuch was unable to grow a beard, marry, or beget children. Moreover, the verse preceded it: “I have seen servants upon horses.”³⁶This contradicts the eunuch’s statement that only kings ride on horses. When that eunuch heard this, he banged his head against the wall and died.
Another matter: “I have seen servants upon horses” – this is Ahab; “and princes walking on the ground like servants” – this is Elijah, as it is stated: “[And Ahab rode and went to Yizre’el.] The hand of the Lord was upon Elijah, and he girded his loins and ran before Ahab…” (I Kings 18:45–46).

Walking on foot like slaves on the ground. Before the Chaldean chariots.

He who digs a pit. גּוּמָּץ is] a pit.

“One who digs a pit will fall into it; and one who breaches a fence, a serpent will bite him” (Ecclesiastes 10:8).
“One who digs a pit will fall into it” – this is the wicked Pharaoh, who said: “Every son who is born [you shall cast him into the Nile]” (Exodus 1:22). “He will fall into it” – as it is stated: “He shook Pharaoh and his people in the Red Sea” (Psalms 136:15).
Another matter: “One who digs a pit” – this is Haman, as it is stated: “To destroy, to kill, and to eliminate” (Esther 3:13). “Will fall into it” – as it is stated: “His wicked intentions will return […upon his head, and he and his sons should be hanged on the gallows]” (Esther 9:25).
“One who breaches a fence, a serpent will bite him” – this is Dina. When her father and her brothers were sitting in the study hall, she went out “to see the daughters of the land” (Genesis 34:1). She brought upon herself that Shekhem ben Ḥamor the Hivite, who is called a serpent,³⁷Hivite is related to the Aramaic word ḥivya, which means serpent. consorted with her and bit her, as it is written: “Shekhem ben Ḥamor saw her…” (Genesis 34:2). “He took her” (Genesis 34:2) – he seduced her with words, as it is stated: “Take words with you” (Hosea 14:3). “He lay with her” (Genesis 34:2) – with natural intercourse; “and he raped her” (Genesis 34:2) – with unnatural intercourse.
Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai and Rabbi Elazar his son went into hiding in a cave in Pekiin for thirteen years during a period of religious persecution. They would eat carobs and dates. At the conclusion of thirteen years, Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai emerged and sat at the entrance to the cave. He saw a trapper placing his traps to trap birds. He heard a Divine Voice saying: ‘Success,’ and [a bird] was trapped. He heard a Divine Voice a second time, saying: ‘Failure,’ and [a bird] escaped. He said: Even a bird, without a divine decree, will not escape; all the more so the soul of a person.³⁸Rabbi Shimon was saying: Since it is in God’s hands whether or not we will be caught, we do not need to continue hiding in the cave (Etz Yosef).
[Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai said to his son:] ‘Let us descend and be healed in the water of the hot springs of Tiberias.’³⁹Apparently conditions in the cave led them to suffer from skin ailments, and they hoped the hot springs would heal their skin (Etz Yosef). They descended and were healed in the water of the hot springs of Tiberias. They said: We must do good, and benefit the residents of this place, just as Jacob our patriarch did, as it is stated: “He encamped [vayiḥan]⁴⁰This is expounded as a reference to both market [ḥanut] and favor [ḥanina]. before the city” (Genesis 33:18), [indicating] that he established a market and sold to them at low prices. They established a market and sold to them at low prices. He said: We must purify Tiberias.⁴¹During the Roman conquest there were many casualties who were buried in unmarked graves, causing Tiberias to lose its presumptive status of purity. What did he do? He took lupines and scattered them in the street, and any place that a corpse was buried, it rose.⁴²It became visible on the surface of the ground.
A certain Samaritan saw him. He said: Am I not able to ridicule this Jewish elder? What did he do? He took a corpse and buried it in a street that they had purified. Some say it was [in the market] of the barrel makers and some say in the market of the sack makers. He came and said to [Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai]: ‘Did you purify such and such street?’ He said to him: ‘Yes.’ He said to him: ‘And if I produce a corpse for you from it?’ He said: ‘Pull it out and show me.’ Immediately, Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai saw through divine inspiration that he had buried it there; he said: ‘I decree that the one who is lying shall stand and that the one standing will lie.’ Some say [that he said]: ‘I decree that the one above will descend and the one below will ascend.’ And so it occurred to him.
He departed and passed before that synagogue in Migdal and heard the voice of Nakai the scribe: ‘Did ben Yoḥai purify Tiberias?’⁴³He was mocking Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai because of the corpse found on the street he had already purified. [Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai] said: ‘ , let [such and such] come upon me if I do not have traditions as numerous as the hairs on my head that this [city of] Tiberias is destined to be purified and will be available to those who partake of teruma, with the exception of this and that.’⁴⁴Only these streets will remain impure. He did not believe him. [Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai] said to [Nakai]: ‘You have breached the fence of the Torah scholars, “and one who breaches a fence, a serpent will bite him,”’ and so it occurred to him.
Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai was passing by during the Sabbatical Year; he saw a certain person who was harvesting aftergrowths⁴⁵These are grain and vegetables that grow on their own without cultivation. of the Sabbatical Year. He said to him: ‘But is it not the Sabbatical Year?’ He said to him: ‘But is it not you who permits it? Did we not learn: [Rabbi Shimon says:] All aftergrowths are permitted except for the aftergrowths of cabbage, because there is nothing corresponding to them in the growths of the field?’⁴⁶Mishna Sheviit 9:1. Since cabbage does not grow wild in the field, one must assume that it was cultivated in violation of the laws of the Sabbatical Year. [Rabbi Shimon] said to him: ‘But do my colleagues not disagree with me?’⁴⁷The Sages in the Mishna prohibit consumption of even uncultivated annual crops that grow during the Sabbatical Year. He read in his regard: “And one who breaches a fence, a serpent will bite him,” and so it occurred to him.

Will fall into it. Sometimes he falls into it, i.e., sometimes you have a plotter of evil, and ultimately he is trapped by his own plot, for Nevuchadnetzar’s seed was destroyed through the vessels of the Beis Hamikdosh, as it is stated, “you exalted yourself against the Lord of Heaven.”¹⁰Daniyeil 5:23. The verse continues, “and the vessels of His House were brought before you, and you, your nobles, your consorts and your concubines drank wine from them, etc.”

He who breaks down a fence. The fence [established] by the Sages, to transgress their ordinances.¹¹The Gemara in Maseches Avodah Zarah 27b, applies this verse to those who break down the “fences” established via Rabbinic ordinances which serve to safeguard the Torah; such individuals “will be bitten by a snake,” i.e., death at the hands of Heaven. The destruction caused by such people comes gradually without it being sensed and continuously grows. Its effect is similar to a snake’s venom which continues to spread without realization until it results in death. See Mesilas Yeshorim Chapter 6.

He who breaks down a fence. The fence [established] by the Sages, to transgress their ordinances.¹¹The Gemara in Maseches Avodah Zarah 27b, applies this verse to those who break down the “fences” established via Rabbinic ordinances which serve to safeguard the Torah; such individuals “will be bitten by a snake,” i.e., death at the hands of Heaven. The destruction caused by such people comes gradually without it being sensed and continuously grows. Its effect is similar to a snake’s venom which continues to spread without realization until it results in death. See Mesilas Yeshorim Chapter 6.

Will be bitten by a snake. Death at the hands of Heaven, and because he spoke with an expression of breaking a fence, he mentions his recompense with an expression of the biting of a snake,¹²Alternatively, whoever breaks down a fence which acted as a barrier to protect others from being bitten, will himself be bitten. This theme is a repetition of the first phrase, “he who digs, etc,” and continues into the next verse, to stress that these occurrences happen often. (Metsudas Dovid) who nestles in the cracks and holes of the walls of dilapidated houses.

He who removes stones will be hurt by them. One who quarries stones in the mountains will be fatigued by them.

Will be hurt. ‘יֵעָצֵב’ is an expression of weariness, as in, “with toil בְּעִצָּבוֹן shall you eat it,”¹³Bereishis 3:17. Alternatively, whoever scatters rocks to trip others, will himself be tripped and hurt by them. (Alshich) i.e., every man, his weariness is according to his work, so will the doer of evil reap according to what he sows.

Will be endangered by them. Shall be warmed by them, as in, “and she shall be to him a warmer סֹכֶנֶת.”¹⁴I Melochim 1:2. So will one who engages in [the study of] Torah and in [the performance of] commandments ultimately benefit from them.

If the axe is blunt. Sharp swords, whose sharp edges have become dull.¹⁵The Gemara in Maseches Ta’anis 7b, applies this verse to the type of student to whom studies are hard as iron [=ברזל]. It attributes the reason for this problem is that he did not organize his studies properly [= והוא לא פנים קלקל]. His remedy is to exert more energy in his studies [=וחילים יגבר] and to spend more time in Yeshiva [=ויתרון הכשר חכמה].

“If the iron is dull, and one did not whet the edge, he must intensify his exertion; the advantage is in preparation with wisdom” (Ecclesiastes 10:10).
“If the iron is dull,” if the teacher’s face is dull toward his student like iron,⁵⁰The teacher is not interested in expending energy to explain the material to his students. “and one did not [whet] the edge [panim],” and the teacher does not show the student a friendly countenance [panim], “whet [kilkal],” there is a deterioration [kilkul] in the actions of the student. “He must intensify his exertion” – what should [the student] do? He should bring ten people who will appease the teacher and, ultimately, he will have much preparation for wisdom.⁵¹He will be in a much better position to attain wisdom.
Another matter: “If the iron is dull,” if the student’s face is dull toward his teacher, as it is stated: “Iron sharpens iron; [so a man sharpens the countenance of his friend]” (Proverbs 27:17),⁵²The teacher could be sharpened by the questions and insights of his student, but this student is dull and not insightful. and [therefore,] the teacher does not show the student a friendly countenance, “kilkal,” there is a deterioration [kilkul] in the actions of the student. “He must intensify his exertion” – [the student] should bring ten people who will appease his teacher. “The advantage [veyitron] is in preparation [hakhsheir] with wisdom” – ultimately, he will relinquish [motir] his anger and will enable [veyakhshir] him [to succeed in] his studies.
Another matter: “If the iron is dull,” if your studies have become dull like iron, “and one did not whet the edge,” [your teacher] cannot come to explain it to you, overcome it with your own ability.⁵³If your teacher is no longer alive and you have unresolved questions, work hard to figure out the answers on your own (Etz Yosef).
One of the students of Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai forgot his studies. He went crying to the cemetery. As he was crying profusely, he was shown a dream, and [a voice] said to him: When you cast three pebbles at me I will come. That student went to an interpreter of dreams and recounted the incident to him. [The interpreter of dreams] said to him: ‘Recite your studies three times and it will come to you.’⁵⁴Recite each thing you learn three times and you will remember it (Matnot Kehuna). He did so, and so it was for him.
Rabbi Berekhya said: If the nation whose power is as strong as iron, as it is written: “And the Lord took you and brought you out from the iron crucible, from Egypt” (Deuteronomy 4:20), becomes dull; “and one did not whet the edge” – and the Holy One blessed be He is not forthcoming toward the generation; “kilkal” – there are evil deeds in this generation. What shall they do? “He must intensify his exertion” – let them decree fasts, and the Holy One blessed be He will grant them eternal forgiveness.
Rabbi Ḥama bar Pappa said in the name of Rabbi Yehuda ben Rabbi Simon: If the skies above your heads have become dull like iron,⁵⁵There is no rain. as it is stated: “I will render your skies like iron” (Leviticus 26:19), and the Holy One blessed be He is not forthcoming, there are corrupt [kilkal] actions in the generation. What shall they do? They shall decree a fast, and the Holy One blessed be He will provide relief to His world.

And one has not sharpened its edge. And they are not sharpened and burnished,¹⁶קלקל is a double form of קלל, as in נחשת קלל [=burnished brass], in Yechezkeil 1:7. (Ibn Ezra) [as in,] “in order that they may glitter.”¹⁷Yechezkeil 21:15. The text in our editions reads למען היה לה ברק [=in order that it may glitter]. Nonetheless, it still strengthens the armies. It strengthens the mighty men of the armies in battle to be victorious.

There is more profit in a skill of wisdom. Wisdom has an additional advantage over iron, for if a Torah scholar’s face is blackened by hunger, and you see him as a poor man among the rich, [realize that] many armies are strengthened by him. Do not wonder about the vav of ‘וַחֲיָלִים,’ for many vavin appear like that in the Hebrew language, as in, “If you saw a thief, you agreed וַתִּרֶץ with him,”¹⁸Tehillim 50:18. [and as in,] “The strength and the retribution of God was וַיְהִי to me a salvation,”¹⁹Shemos 15:2. Rashi there gives numerous examples of Scripture’s similar usage of the vav. and many [others] are similarly explained.

If the snake bites. A person.

“If the serpent may bite without a spell, there is no advantage to the charmer” (Ecclesiastes 10:11).
“If the serpent may bite without a spell [laḥash]” – Rabbi Abba bar Kahana said: A serpent bites only if it was whispered [nilḥash] to from above, and the lion devours only if it was whispered to from above, and a kingdom aggravates people only if it was whispered to from above.⁵⁶God determines whether one will be persecuted by the government.
Rabbi Shmuel bar Naḥmani said: [If] they [would] say to the serpent: ‘Why does your tongue bite one limb, but all of them feel it and tremble,’ it [would] say to them: ‘You are speaking to me? Speak to the one with a tongue.’⁵⁷The verse states: “There is no advantage to the charmer [baal halashon].” The most literal translation of the phrase baal halashon is “one with a tongue.” The term serpent is used here as a reference to one who speaks slander, which causes widespread damage. [If the serpent would be asked:] ‘Why does your tongue slobber,’ [it would say:] ‘Because it caused me [to be punished].’⁵⁸The serpent slandered God in the Garden of Eden (see Genesis, chap. 3). [If it would be asked:] ‘Why is your body lacking,’ [it would say:] ‘My tongue caused it.’⁵⁹This is a punishment for my sin, by means of my tongue, which caused the sin. [If one asked it:] ‘Why does your tongue bite one limb, but all of them feel it and tremble,’ it [would] say to him: ‘You are speaking to me? Speak to the one with a [slanderous] tongue, as he speaks here and kills in Rome, or in Rome and he kills here or at the ends of the earth.’ [If it would be asked:] ‘Why are you found among the fences,’⁶⁰Fences were generally stone walls, which have crevices where serpents hide. [it would answer: ‘It is because I breached the fence of the world.’⁶¹I caused the first sin. Rabbi Shimon ben Yoḥai said: The serpent breached the fence of the world; therefore, he became the executioner for all those who breach a fence.⁶²As in the verse: “One who breaches a fence, a serpent will bite him” (Ecclesiastes 10:8).
Rabbi Shimon ben Lakish taught: When the Holy One blessed be He said to the serpent: “You shall go on your belly” (Genesis 3:14), the ministering angels descended and amputated its hands and its feet, and its voice resonated from one end of the earth to the other. The serpent came and taught about the downfall of Edom, as it is stated: “Its sound will go like the serpent’s” (Jeremiah 46:22).
The Rabbis liken it⁶³They liken the loud sound of the serpent to the loud sound of the Tigris River. to this verse: “The name of the third river is Tigris” (Genesis 2:14). [If] they [would] ask the Tigris: ‘Why is your sound heard,’ it [would] say to them: ‘If only it would be heard among the rivers.’⁶⁴If only I would stand out among the rivers. [If the rivers would] ask the Euphrates: ‘Why is your sound not heard like our voice is heard,’ it [would] say to them: ‘My actions speak for me. If a person sows vegetable seeds in me, it sprouts in three days; [if one] plants a sapling in me, it sprouts in thirty days.’

Before it is charmed. Because the charmer did not charm it not to bite.

There is no advantage. To the wicked charmer who was accustomed to charm it, if he did not charm it. So, if the people of your city [are unaware and] stumble over prohibitions because the wise man does not preach to them or teach them the statutes of the Torah, he has no advantage with his silence, and he will not benefit.²⁰Alternatively, Koheles is comparing a slanderer to a charmer. A person who allows his tongue to slander is as guilty as a charmer whose snake killed someone because he did not prevent it from doing so. One’s slander often causes havoc and destruction, and sometimes even death. (Alshich) ²¹See the Gemara in Maseches Arachin 15b, which applies this verse to a slanderer [=בעל לשון הרע].

The words of a wise man find favor. In the eyes of their listeners, and they listen to him, and it is good for him that he assumes greatness over them.

“The words of the mouth of the wise are grace; but the lips of the fool will swallow him” (Ecclesiastes 10:12).
“The words of the mouth of the wise are grace” – this is Cyrus, king of Persia, who said: “Any among you from His entire people, may his God be with him, and he may go up [to Jerusalem]” (Ezra 1:3). “But the lips of the fool will swallow him” – as he recanted his words and retracted them.⁶⁵Cyrus initially allowed the rebuilding of the Temple, but he is also identified with Artaḥshasta, who ordered that the construction of the Temple be stopped (see Ezra, chap. 4; Esther Rabba 1:3).

But lips of a fool devour him. This refers to someone who misleads his fellow man from the good way [to the bad way]; e.g., Bilam, who broke the restrictions that the nations had imposed, that they restricted themselves from immorality from the time of the generation of the flood and onwards, yet, he advised them to offer their daughters for prostitution.²²Alternatively, Targum renders, “the words of a wise man find favor,” i.e., by his prayer he finds favor before God, Who removes the retribution destined to befall the world; “but the lips of a fool,” are words of reproach and bring destruction to the world.

The beginning of his words is foolishness. When the Holy One, Blessed Is He, said to him [Bilam], “Who are these men with you?”²³Bamidbar 22:9. he should have replied, “Adonoy, You know,” but [instead] he said, “Balak son of Tzippor, king of Mo’av sent them to me,”²⁴Ibid., verse 10. i.e., though I may be despised in Your eyes, I am esteemed in the eyes of the earthly kings.

“The beginning of the words of his mouth is foolishness, and the end of his mouth is evil debauchery” (Ecclesiastes 10:13).
“The beginning of the words of his mouth is foolishness” – as [Cyrus] said: “He is the God, who is in Jerusalem” (Ezra 1:3).⁶⁶Implying He is God only in Jerusalem. “And the end of his mouth is evil debauchery” – as he recanted and abrogated his decrees and said: Whoever has crossed⁶⁷The Euphrates has crossed, and whoever has not crossed shall not cross.
Another matter: “The beginning of the words of his mouth is foolishness” – this is Aḥashverosh, as it is stated: “And in the reign of Aḥashverosh, at the beginning of his reign, they wrote libel [against the inhabitants of Judah and Jerusalem]” (Ezra 4:6). “And the end of his mouth [is evil debauchery]” – as he arose and abrogated the labor of the construction of the Temple.⁶⁸Aḥashverosh, who is also identified as Artaḥshasta, began his reign with the foolish decree to stop the rebuilding of the Temple due to the libel, and he continued to prevent its rebuilding for the remainder of his reign.

And the end of talk is [evil] madness. Madness and confusion [by advising], “Come I will counsel you” with foolish lewdness.²⁵Alternatively, from beginning [=תחלת] to end [=ואחרית], a fool’s statements are folly and madness. (Metsudas Dovid)

The fool multiplies words. For he [Bilam] was boasting that he, “knows the knowledge of the Most High.”²⁶Bamidbar 24:16.

“The fool will increase words; man does not know what will be, and what will be after him, who can tell him” (Ecclesiastes 10:14).
“The fool will increase words” – Rabbi Berekhya in the name of Rabbi Simon interpreted the verse regarding Moses. The Holy One blessed be He said to Moses: I wrote in your regard that you are wise, but you are standing and speaking extensively, and you are not wise, “do not continue to speak to Me further about this matter” (Deuteronomy 3:26).

Man knows not what will be. To him in the future, for he went to take his pay in Midyan, but he did not know that he would be killed by the sword.

But according to its simple meaning: The fool multiplies words. He declares and says, “Tomorrow I will do this to so-and-so,” without knowing what will be tomorrow.²⁷Alternatively, although the fool multiplies his words, the listener nonetheless knows neither their meaning nor his intention. (Metsudas Dovid)

And what will be after him who can tell him. I.e., not only does he not know what will be after a time, but even what is presently now behind him, but is not in front of his eyes, only behind his back at a distance, he needs someone to tell him.

The labor of the fools exhausts them. Their foolishness causes them labor,²⁸Fools busy themselves to understand profound and mysterious matters, when they lack comprehension of even simple matters. They are compared to those who wish to enter a city but do not know the way. They stumble and grow weary without achieving their goal. (Ibn Ezra) which wearies them, because they did not learn the ways of the approaches to the city, and he becomes weary by entering by way of pits and marshes, and he is wearied by his feet sinking into the mire; i.e., the laziness of those who abandon the Torah causes them wearying labor in Gehinnom.

“The toil of the fools will exhaust him, as he will not know to go to a city” (Ecclesiastes 10:15).
“The toil of the fools will exhaust him” – this is a student who stagnates in his study; “as he will not know to go to a city” – should he not have gone to his teacher to restore his learning to him?
Another matter: “The toil of the fools will exhaust him” – this is Yiftaḥ; “as he will not know to go to a city” – should he not have gone to Pinḥas so he would annul his vow for him?⁶⁹Yiftaḥ had vowed that the first item that would exit his house to meet him upon his return home would be a sacrifice to God. When he returned home, his daughter was first to exit his house, and because of the vow, she lived out her life in solitude (see Judges 11:30–40). However, Yiftaḥ said: ‘I am the chief and commander of Israel; shall I go to Pinḥas?’ Pinḥas said: ‘I am a High Priest, son of a High Priest; shall I go to an ignoramus?’ Between the two of them that unfortunate one was lost, and the two of them are liable for her blood. Yiftaḥ’s limbs were severed one after another and buried, as it is written: “He was buried in the cities of Gilad” (Judges 12:7). In how many places was he buried that you say: “He was buried in the cities of Gilad”? Rather, it teaches that his limbs were severed one after another, and each one was buried in its place. What did Pinḥas lose? The Divine Spirit left him for two hundred years, as it is not written, “he was chief over them,” but it is written: “Pinḥas ben Elazar had been chief over them; in the past the Lord was with him” (I Chronicles 9:20).⁷⁰The Lord had been with him in the past, but was not with him in the present.

For he does not know the way. To the path of truth, to part from transgression,²⁹Alternatively, this phrase refers to an ignorant person who does not go to the city and learn from its wise people. (Targum) because he did not study Torah, as it is stated, “Your word is a lamp for my feet.”³⁰Tehillim 119:105.

Woe to you, O land if your king. When your king and your judges behave childishly.

“Woe is you, land, whose king is a lad, and your princes dine in the morning. Happy are you, land, that your king is a free man, and your princes dine at the proper time, in valor and not in drunkenness” (Ecclesiastes 10:16–17).
“Woe is you, land, whose king is a lad” – it is written: “Then, two women who were prostitutes came” (I Kings 3:16).⁷¹They each had a baby and one of the babies died. Each claimed the live one was hers, and they came before King Solomon for adjudication. See I Kings 3:16–28. Who were they? Rabbi Meir says: They were spirits. The Rabbis say: They were women awaiting levirate marriage.⁷²If a man dies without children, his widow is subject to the law of levirate marriage. The husbands of these women died without children but while their wives were pregnant, and the women subsequently gave birth. However, a child who dies within the first thirty days does not exempt the mother from levirate marriage, and therefore an outcome of the case would be the determination of which woman would be subject to levirate marriage (Midrash HaMevo’ar). Rabbi Simon in the name of Rabbi Yehoshua says: They were actual prostitutes, and he issued their verdict without witnesses and forewarning. “The one woman said: Please, my lord…it was on the third day after I gave birth…the son of this woman died” (I Kings 3:17–19) because she rolled upon him. “She arose during the night.… I arose in the morning to nurse my son.… The woman said: No, but…. The king said: This one says…” (I Kings 3:20–23). Rabbi Pinḥas and Rabbi Yirmeya [said] in the name of Rabbi Ḥiyya bar Abba and Rabbi Beivai, and some tend to cite it in the name of Rabbi Pedat: The procedure of the judgment is as follows: The judge sits, the judged stand, the mediator decides between them,⁷³Some commentaries suggest that the phrase “the mediator decides between them” is mistaken and should not appear (see Rabbi David Luria). the plaintiff lodges his complaint, the defendant responds, and the judge decides between them. Rabbi Simon said: From here it is derived that the judge must reiterate their claims, from this verse: “[The king said:] This one says: This is my son that lives [and your son is the dead], and that one says: [No, your son is the dead and my son is the living]” (I Kings 3:23).
“The king said: Bring me a sword.… The king said: Cut the living child.… The woman whose child was the living one…” (I Kings 3:24–26) – Rabbi Yehuda said that Rabbi Ilai said: Had I been there, I would have wrapped soft wool around his neck,⁷⁴Around Solomon’s neck, as a judge who issues a false judgment is executed by strangulation. as when he said: “Bring me a sword,” had [the mother] not been overcome by mercy for him [her child], he would have been killed. Regarding that moment, it says: “Woe is you, land, whose king is a lad.” At that moment, he began spouting wisdom; he said: Was it for nothing that the Holy One blessed be He created in this person two eyes, two ears, two feet, two hands? It was because the Holy One blessed be He foresaw that this judgment is destined to transpire.⁷⁵The Holy One blessed be He created man proportionally so it would be possible to cut the child lengthwise into two equal parts. [Ultimately] he did not do so, but rather he said: “Give her the living child, and do not kill him” (I Kings 3:27). Regarding that moment, it says: “Happy are you, land, that your king is a free man and your princes dine at the proper time” – at the time of the World to Come; “and not in drunkenness [vashti]” – in his strength and not in his weakness [bitshisho]. “The king answered and said: Give her the living child.” The Divine Spirit was shouting and saying: She is certainly his mother.
Rabbi Shmuel bar Naḥmani said: In three places, the attribute of justice shouted: In the court of Shem, in the court of Samuel, and in the court of Solomon. In the court of Shem, from where is it derived? It is as it is stated: “Judah recognized and said: She is more righteous than I” (Genesis 38:26), and the Divine Spirit shouted and said: All of these matters originated with Me.⁷⁶The events leading up to the trial (see Genesis, chap. 38) were a result of Divine providence. In the court of Samuel, from where is it derived? It is as it is stated: “Here I am; testify against me before the Lord.… He said to them: The Lord is witness for you, and His anointed is witness” (I Samuel 12:3–5). It is not written here, “they said…witness,” but rather, “he said…witness.” Who said “witness”? The Divine Spirit said: ‘You will testify regarding the revealed, and I will testify regarding the concealed.’ In the court of Solomon, from where is it derived? It is as it is stated: “The king answered and said: Give her the living child” (I Kings 3:27). The Divine Spirit shouted and said: She is certainly his mother.
Another matter: “Woe is you, land, whose king is a lad” – these are the kings of Israel; “happy are you, land, that your king is a free man” – these are the kings of Judah. “And your princes dine in the morning” – these are the kings of Israel; “and your princes dine at the proper time” – these are the kings of Judah.⁷⁷The kings of Israel were wicked, and therefore consumed in this world all goodness they will receive. Many of the kings of Judah were righteous, and have a share in the World to Come.

In strength and not in drunkenness. They engage in the power of wisdom and understanding and not in drinking wine.

Where there is slothfulness the ceiling sags. When a person is lazy and does not repair a small breach in the ceiling of the house.

“With slothfulness the ceiling sags and with idleness of the hands the house leaks” (Ecclesiastes 10:18).
“With slothfulness the ceiling sags” – because the Israelites were slothful from encamping at Mount Sinai in dispute,⁷⁸Although the Israelites had engaged in disputes in their other encampments, when they encamped at Sinai they did so peacefully. “the ceiling sags” – it is written: “He bent the heavens and descended” (Psalms 18:10).⁷⁹God descended to them and rested His presence in their midst. “And with idleness [uvshiflut] of the hands the house leaks” – because the Israelites humbled themselves [nishtapelu] [and refrained] from encamping in dispute at Mount Sinai, “the house leaks” – “the clouds, too, dripped water” (Judges 5:4).
Another matter: “With slothfulness the ceiling sags” – because the Israelites were slothful in repenting in the days of Jeremiah, “the ceiling sags,” – “He uncovered the covering of Judah” (Isaiah 22:8), he removed its covering.⁸⁰The roof of the Temple. “And with idleness [uvshiflut] of the hands the house leaks” – because the Israelites abased themselves [nishtapelu] from repenting in the days of Jeremiah, “the house leaks,” it is written: “For behold, the Lord commands, and He will shatter the great house⁸¹The ten tribes of the kingdom of Israel. into smithereens and the small house⁸²The two tribes of the kingdom of Judah. into fragments” (Amos 6:11). Rabbi Huna said: This shattering into smithereens is unlike the shattering into fragments. This shattering into fragments, there are no remnants from it, while the shattering into smithereens, there are remnants from it.⁸³When something is shattered into smithereens the tiny slivers cannot possibly be reconstructed into a whole. When something is broken into fragments the pieces are large enough to be usable and reconstructed (Etz Yosef).
Another matter: “With slothfulness the ceiling sags” – Rabbi Kohen interpreted [it] regarding a woman: Because a woman is slothful in examining herself at her appropriate time, she suffers, as it is stated, “and of she who suffers in her menstruation” (Leviticus 15:33). “And with idleness [uvshiflut] of the hands…” – because she abases herself [mishtapelet] [and refrains] from examining herself, she becomes a zava,⁸⁴A zava is a woman who experiences a discharge of blood when it is not the time for her menstruation. See Leviticus 15:25–30. as it is stated: “And a woman, if her bloody discharge shall flow [many days, not at the time of her menstruation]” (Leviticus 15:25).

The ceiling sags. The structure and beams of the house will sag— and its covering.

Leaks. The dripping rain leaks, i.e., when [Bnei] Yisroel are lazy with [observance of] the Torah,³¹See Maseches Ta’anis 7b. they melt away, and the Beis [Hamikdosh], the pride of their strength, becomes destroyed and impoverished.

A feast is made for laughter. For the joy of the musical entertainment at a wedding, we make a feast, and an ordinary large feast is called ‘לֶחֶם,’ as it is stated, “King Belshatzar made a great feast לֶחֶם.”³²Daniyeil 5:1.

“A feast is made for laughter, wine cheers the living, and money answers everything” (Ecclesiastes 10:18).
“A feast is made for laughter” – for revelry of idol worship one makes a feast. “Wine cheers the living” – this is the Torah, as it is stated: “The precepts of the Lord are upright, cheering the heart” (Psalms 19:9).⁸⁵In contrast to idolatry, for which one must make a feast in order to stimulate joy, Torah itself brings happiness without external stimuli (Rabbi David Luria).
“Money answers everything” – Rabbi Yehoshua of Sikhnin [said] in the name of Rabbi Levi: At times one is answered and at times one is not answered. At times, when one performs with it [money] acts of righteousness, he is answered, as it is stated: “My righteousness will speak on my behalf” (Genesis 30:33). At times, when one does not perform with it acts of righteousness, it denounces him; this is what you say: “To give false testimony against him” (Deuteronomy 19:16).
Rabbi Shimon ben Lakish, a certain neighbor called him. He saw people standing, dancing, and clapping, and [the hosts] gave them food and drink. He said: This is good. I, too, will stand, dance, and sing. He stood, danced, and sang, and they gave him a wineskin of aged wine. He read in his regard: “A feast is made for laughter.”

And wine. They give to drink at the feast, that which makes life joyful.

And money answers all things. Without money, there is no feast; therefore, a person should not neglect work, so that he will have what to spend.³³Alternatively, “money afflicts [=יענה] all,” i.e., either the abundance or lack of money causes affliction to mankind. Or, “money makes everyone respond [=יענה],” i.e., money causes people to readily listen and to obey.

Even in your thoughts [do not curse] the king. Even in your thoughts, without speech. “גַּם” means “even.”

“Even in your thought do not curse a king, and in your bedrooms do not curse the wealthy, as a bird of the heavens will carry the sound, and a winged one will tell the matter” (Ecclesiastes 10:20).
“Even in your thought do not curse a king” – Rabbi Yehuda ben Rabbi Simon said: The Holy One blessed be He says to a person: Because I have given you intellect beyond that of the animal, the beast, and the birds, you curse and blaspheme before me? I gave you eyes and [the animal] eyes, you have ears and it has ears, you have hands and it has hands, you have feet and it has feet, you have a mouth and it has a mouth, he is like the beasts that perish [nidma].⁸⁶This is an adaptation in the singular of Psalms 49:21. The verse compares people to beasts, but the midrash reads it as implying a difference between people and animals, that animals cannot speak. Nidma means nothing other than silence; I have silenced it before you.⁸⁷Unlike people, animals cannot speak. See the honor that I have afforded you. But you do not understand all this goodness, “man does not understand the honor” (Psalms 49:21).
Another matter: “Even in your thought do not curse a king” that is in your generation, “and in your bedrooms do not curse the wealthy” – do not curse the wealthy of your generation. “As a bird of the heavens” – Rabbi Yirmeya ben Elazar said: This is the raven, by means of bird divination.⁸⁸The king or wealthy people might find out what you said from the ravens, by means of bird divination. “And a winged one will tell the matter” – because the wall has ears.
Another matter: “Even in your thought do not curse a king” – the King of the world; “and in your bedrooms do not curse the wealthy” – the wealthy One of the world. “As a bird of the heavens will carry the sound” – Rabbi Yehoshua of Sikhnin [said] in the name of Rabbi Levi: There are some sounds that are for good and there are some sounds that are for evil. [There are] sounds for good, as it is stated: “The Lord heard the sound of your words…they have done well in everything that they spoke” (Deuteronomy 5:24). Ḥiyya bar Ada and bar Kappara: Ḥiyya bar Abba said: For good [hatava], as in the preparation of [hatavat] the incense. Bar Kappara said: For good, as in the cleaning of [hatavat] the lamps. [There are] sounds for evil, as it is stated: “The Lord heard the sound of your words, and He was enraged and took an oath…” (Deuteronomy 1:34).
Rabbi Abbahu [said] in the name of Rabbi Taḥalifa his father in law: It is written: “As I took an oath in My wrath” (Psalms 95:11) – the Holy One blessed be He said: I took an oath in My wrath, but then I recanted; “that they⁸⁹The generation of the wilderness, which left Egypt. will not enter My place of rest” (Psalms 95:11) – they will not enter this resting place,⁹⁰The Land of Israel but they will enter another resting place.⁹¹The World to Come Rabbi Beivai said in the name of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi: [This is analogous] to a king who was angry at his son and expelled him from his palace and took an oath that he would not allow his son to enter the palace. What did he do [once he reconsidered]? It was [already] built; he dismantled it and rebuilt it, and brought his son into it. He thereby brings his son in and [still] fulfills his vow. So too, the Holy One blessed be He said: I took an oath in My wrath and recanted. They will not enter this resting place, but they will enter another resting place.
“And a winged one will tell the matter” – Rabbi Bon said: When a person sleeps, the body tells the soul [what it has done], the soul [tells it] to the spirit, the spirit to the angel, the angel to the cherub, and the cherub to the winged one. Who is that? It is the seraph. The seraph will bring the matter and tell it before He who spoke and the world came into being.
Another matter: “Even in your thought do not curse a king” – do not curse a king who is before you. “And in your bedrooms do not curse the wealthy” – a prominent person in your locale. “As a bird of the heavens will carry the sound” – the Holy One blessed be He said to David: Would you not say: “All my enemies shall be ashamed and frightened” (Psalms 6:11)? Who were your enemies? Was it not Saul? Would you not say: “On the day that the Lord rescued him from the hand of all his enemies and from the hand of Saul” (Psalms 18:1)?⁹²Thus, you cursed the king I appointed over Israel. David said: Master of the universe: Do You calculate them for me as intentional transgressions? Consider them as unwitting transgressions [shegagot] for me. That is what is written: “A meditation [shigayon] by David, a song that he sang to the Lord concerning the words of Kush the Benjamite (Psalms 7:1).⁹³Kush the Benjamite is a reference to Saul (see Moed Katan 16b).
Another matter: “Even in your thought do not curse a king” – this is Moses, as it is stated: “There was a king in Yeshurun” (Deuteronomy 33:5). “And in your bedrooms do not curse the wealth” – this is Moses. From where did Moses become wealthy? It was from the residue of the tablets. Rabbi Ḥanin said: He discovered a quarry of sapphires in his tent, and from that Moses became wealthy, as it is stated: “Carve for you two tablets of stone…” (Exodus 34:1), its carvings will be for you.

Do not curse the king. Do not provoke the King of the Universe. Another explanation: According to its apparent meaning, this is a mortal king.

A bird of the skies. The soul, which is placed within you, which will ultimately fly up to the heaven.

And that which has wings. The angel who escorts you, as the matter is stated, “For He will command His angels on your behalf,”³⁴Tehillim 91:11. and according to its apparent meaning, “those who go back and forth;” [i.e.,] you should worry about every person, perhaps there are listeners, who will tell [the matter] to others.³⁵The Gemara in Maseches Bava Basra 4a states, that when Bava the son of Butta met with Hordos he applied this verse.