에스더 9:19의 탈무드

May a village dweller free a city dweller of his obligation? Should it follow “anybody not obligated for something may not free the public from their obligation”⁵³Mishnah Roš Haššanah 3:8. By this argument, neither the village dweller on the 15^th nor the city dweller on the 14^th may read for another person’s benefit.? May a city dweller free a village dweller of his obligation? Should it follow “anybody not obligated for something may not free the public from their obligation”? Or should it follow what “Rebbi Ḥelbo said, Rebbi Ḥuna in the name of the Great Rebbi Ḥiyya: Everybody may fulfill his obligation on the Fourteenth, which is the time of its reading⁵⁴Chapter 1, Note 67. By this argument, everybody may read for other persons on the 14^th. The question is not resolved (but Tosaphot Yebamot 14a, s.v. כי read the text as following the first opinion.)”? Rebbi Yudan asked. [A village dweller who] decided to move in the night of the Fifteenth? Is that not the Mishnah, “a villager who went to a walled city”? The Mishnah if he was in the walled city. What is problematic for him, if he was in a village. But those on an ocean trip or passing through deserts read normally on the Fourteenth. Rebbi Mana said, if he intended to return to his place. Rebbi Phineas said, therefore the dispersed Jews⁵⁵Esth. 9:19., in that hour he was dispersed⁵⁶Since he could not possibly reach his home on Purim. Babli 19a..